Speculation is growing on Wall Street regarding the potential merger of Elon Musk's two flagship companies, though such a move would not be without significant challenges.
There has been long-standing collaboration between Tesla Motors and SpaceX, with ties strengthening recently. In March, Musk announced a joint project to build a factory capable of producing one terawatt of computing hardware annually.
In a client note on Tuesday, William Blair analyst Louie DiPalma suggested this development might be a "harbinger" of a potential SpaceX acquisition of Tesla Motors. Rumors of such a combination have circulated among investors for months, with reports in May indicating internal discussions at Musk's companies about a merger.
Publicly, Musk has stated his companies are "moving in the direction of convergence." SpaceX's prospectus outlines plans for further "strategic collaboration" with Tesla Motors, which holds a stake in the aerospace firm.
"There is no doubt there is synergy between Tesla Motors and SpaceX, and there will be in the future," SpaceX COO Gwynne Shotwell said last month.
RBC analyst Tom Narayan cited the primary motivation for a merger as "operational cooperation" and raised his price target for Tesla Motors from $475 to $500 after considering the potential deal's impact. This new target implies a 22% upside from current trading levels.
Narayan pointed to the Terafab chip project, SpaceX's reliance on Tesla Motors' Megapack energy storage products, and collaboration on AI training as reasons for closer ties. He noted a likely all-stock deal, valuing Tesla Motors at a 20-30% premium to its current market price.
Narayan added that the Tesla Motors board might require such a premium to compensate for a potential loss of voting control, especially if Musk's stake in the combined entity exceeded 50%. He observed that only two executives, Musk and longtime Tesla Motors board member Ira Ehrenpreis, serve at both companies.
Separately, RBC initiated coverage of SpaceX stock on Tuesday with a $225 price target, suggesting 48% upside potential.
Shares of Tesla Motors fell 4% on Tuesday, while SpaceX shares dropped 6.8%. SpaceX was added to the Nasdaq 100 index before the market opened.
A team of JPMorgan analysts, led by Doug Anmuth, outlined three other potential deal structures besides an all-stock acquisition in a Tuesday note, though they agreed an all-stock deal remained the most likely outcome.
Anmuth stated that integrating SpaceX and Tesla Motors into a new entity could create a cleaner, merger-of-equals structure. A phased, partial integration could lower regulatory and governance hurdles. JPMorgan added that a third option, a cash-and-stock offer from SpaceX, could deliver a higher premium to Tesla Motors shareholders but would likely strain SpaceX's already pressured free cash flow.
Some analysts predict a merger could be completed as soon as 2027. Baird's Ben Kallo suggested in a June 23 note that a deal could materialize within the next 12 to 18 months.
Anmuth said the likelihood of such a transaction would "increase meaningfully" over the next one to two years but believes a merger is not imminent.
"Given governance asymmetry, valuation gaps, and regulatory complexity, we expect execution to lag the most optimistic timelines," he wrote, calling the combination "challenging."
As a major defense contractor, SpaceX's relationships are subject to heightened scrutiny.
Anmuth also cited a potential risk in Tesla Motors' weak business fundamentals, pointing to its full-year 2025 results. The company's second-quarter earnings report on July 22 will give investors a complete picture of its first-half 2026 operations.
Tesla Motors' Q1 2026 results slightly exceeded Wall Street consensus. While Q2's final profit picture remains unclear, recent delivery figures provide clues. The company reported last week that its Q2 EV deliveries were significantly above expectations, though its energy storage segment slightly missed forecasts.
"Tesla Motors hasn't beaten expectations by this magnitude in a long time, which is a positive sign that its core auto business is on solid, sustainable footing," William Blair's Jed Dorsheimer said in a note last week.
Regarding the energy business, he expects demand and deployment of storage products to accelerate in the second half of 2026.
Comments