Middle Election Results Shift Balance of Power Between Trump and the Federal Reserve, Complicating Warsh's Plans

Deep News11-09

Nick Timiraos, known as the "Fed whisperer," wrote that the U.S. midterm election results have changed the balance of power between the Trump administration and the Federal Reserve, delivering the strongest check yet on Trump's efforts to control the central bank.

With Democrats controlling the Senate, they will gain greater say over Fed personnel appointments and the ability to block Trump from installing more loyalists on the Fed's Board of Governors.

Although Trump can appoint his chosen candidate, Kevin Warsh, as Fed chair, he still lacks one supporter to secure a majority on the seven-member board. The prospects for obtaining that seat have now clearly narrowed.

The White House under Trump launched the most direct challenge to the Fed's independence in decades, including an unprecedented attempt to fire a sitting governor.

Previously, checks on Trump came mainly from several sources: a retiring Republican senator blocking Fed nominations; Jerome Powell's decision to remain on the board after stepping down as chair; and courts temporarily allowing Fed Governor Lisa Cook to continue serving.

With Democrats controlling the Senate, these scattered checks will form a broader institutional constraint. For the remainder of Trump's term, Democrats will be able to exercise veto power over all personnel nominations to the Fed's seven-member Board of Governors.

Mark Spindel, an investment manager who studies Fed-Congress relations and co-authored a book on the subject, believes Trump's plan to reshape the relationship between the Fed and the White House has suffered a major setback.

"It clearly died last Tuesday," Spindel said. He further stated: "He can no longer get his people onto the board, nor can he fill partisan governor seats. It's over."

Personnel appointments blocked, Trump struggles to control the Fed board

Currently, Trump has appointed three of the seven Fed governors, including Warsh. Under existing arrangements, the next board vacancy will come from Powell, whose governor term runs through January 2028.

Trump has also tried to create a new board vacancy by firing Cook, citing alleged mortgage fraud. Cook denies the allegations, and the White House plans to hold a hearing on the matter in December.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in June that Cook could remain in office while she legally challenges her dismissal. Even if Trump ultimately wins the lawsuit, a Democratic-controlled Senate could still refuse to confirm a successor, leaving the seat vacant for an extended period.

Democrats have previously collectively opposed Trump's Fed nominees on multiple occasions. Last year, when Michelle Bowman was nominated to serve as the Fed's vice chair for supervision, not a single Democratic senator voted in favor.

Months later, when Stephen Miran was nominated to fill a Fed governor vacancy, he likewise received no Democratic support. In May, when Trump nominated Warsh to serve as Fed chair, only one Democrat ultimately supported him, Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman.

If Democrats continue to obstruct Trump's personnel nominations, his ability to change the Fed's policy direction through appointments will be limited. The president's primary channel for influencing Fed monetary policy has historically been personnel appointments.

Trump has never hidden his desire to lower interest rates, but the U.S. president has no power to directly decide rates. Rate decisions are discussed and made by a committee of Fed officials, most of whom are not appointed by the president.

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) involves 19 officials in policy discussions, but only 12 have voting rights at each meeting. These include seven Fed governors appointed by the president, the New York Fed president, and four of the other 11 regional Fed presidents.

Those four seats are held by non-political appointees and participate in voting on a rotating basis. Currently, Trump-appointed officials hold only three of the 12 voting seats.

As inflation re-emerges as a focus of monetary policy, the Fed under Warsh's leadership is actually moving in the opposite direction from the rate cuts Trump wants. The Fed raised rates in September for the first time since 2023 and held rates steady last month.

Investors currently expect the Fed to raise rates again in December. Trump blames what he calls a "politicized" board, arguing that board members are hostile to Warsh. Cook was one of two officials who voted against the rate hike last month.

However, a single dissenting vote has limited impact on FOMC decisions. Miran was a senior White House economic adviser whom Trump placed on the Fed board last year. Before leaving in May, he consistently supported looser monetary policy during the six meetings he attended, but only once did another official share his position.

Warsh's reform plans face internal resistance

Democratic control of the Senate affects Warsh not only by limiting Trump's ability to add board seats, but also potentially making it difficult for him to choose his own core aides.

Timiraos wrote that Warsh wants to comprehensively reform the Fed's external communications, its mechanism for assessing economic conditions, and its approach to balance sheet management. But if the White House cannot reach an agreement with Senate Democrats, these reforms will depend on Warsh persuading existing board members.

The current board includes three governors appointed by former President Biden, as well as Warsh's predecessor Powell. These members were not chosen with Warsh's involvement.

Monetary policy often depends on how the Fed chair guides the middle ground within the committee and builds consensus among members. Fed chairs historically have relied on core aides they helped select to consolidate policy positions and drive decisions.

Ben Bernanke, who took office in 2006, soon welcomed Warsh and Frederic Mishkin to the board. Warsh at the time helped Bernanke with the confirmation process, and Mishkin was Bernanke's co-author on inflation targeting research.

In 2014, veteran central banker Stanley Fischer became Janet Yellen's deputy several months after she became Fed chair. In 2018, Powell also worked behind the scenes to ensure he could appoint Richard Clarida, whose views aligned with his, as vice chair.

Timiraos wrote in the article that Democratic control of the Senate will also give them a say over who replaces Philip Jefferson as Fed vice chair next September. Even if Trump nominates a current Fed governor, Senate confirmation is still required. Bowman's promotion to vice chair last year also went through this process.

Derek Tang, an economist at Monetary Policy Analytics, said Fed chairs have all relied on "a very strong vice chair" to help them organize their own policy thinking and build committee consensus. He believes that for Warsh, "that path does indeed look narrower."

Still, even without new governors joining, Warsh retains room to influence how the Fed operates. As Fed chair, he can set the board's agenda and influence the arrangements for senior Fed staff.

In his first five months in office, Warsh has already shortened press conference durations and announced that the number of rate-setting meetings will be reduced starting next year.

Timiraos wrote that in the areas of bank supervision and the payments system, decisions are made solely by the Fed's Board of Governors. Democratic control of the Senate may have relatively limited direct impact on these policies, because the board rarely passes major regulatory rules by a narrow 4-3 margin.

But if Trump cannot appoint a fourth governor, Bowman's efforts to ease capital requirements for large banks and open the Fed's payments system to nonbank institutions may require support from a Democratic-appointed governor to pass.

In addition, whether Powell or other current governors will choose to leave the board early has become an unresolved question. The key is whether they believe the Fed's customary institutional arrangements are sufficient to safeguard central bank independence.

In April, when Powell explained why he chose to remain on the board after his chair term ends, he acknowledged that the decision was unusual. He said he hoped the Fed and the executive branch could "get back to a state of respect for legal requirements and longstanding conventions, that is, letting the Fed act according to its own responsibilities."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment