Morgan Stanley's chief equity strategist, Mike Wilson, has issued a warning: the price momentum for semiconductor stocks is approaching historical extremes, with their trajectory bearing a striking resemblance to that of silver stocks earlier this year—which flamed out quickly after a brief surge. He suggests this momentum "peak" may be playing out as expected, to be followed by a more sustainable and broad-based market rally.
The Nasdaq Composite Index has fallen 4.6% over the last five trading sessions, marking its longest losing streak of the year, with a decline more than double that of the S&P 500 over the same period. The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index (SOX) plunged 7.9% last week, after surging 7.3% the week prior—this whipsaw action is proving difficult for investors holding historically large exposures. According to Morgan Stanley's latest weekly equity strategy report, recent weakness in the stocks of hyperscale cloud providers may be a leading indicator that the breadth of earnings-per-share (EPS) revisions for the semiconductor sector has hit a historical extreme and is poised to enter a phase of relative underperformance.
Wilson advises investors to reduce exposure to hot momentum trades and instead position in sectors like consumer discretionary, transportation, and regional banks. His logic is built on a triple tailwind: persistently falling oil prices, peaking tariff-related inflation dampening expectations for Federal Reserve rate hikes, and median S&P 1500 company earnings already growing at a double-digit pace—a broadly underestimated earnings recovery that is driving the return of a broad-based market.
However, Wilson also highlights a significant near-term risk: the Federal Reserve's conservative stance on liquidity provision is clashing with rising liquidity demands from both the real economy and capital markets, a pressure already visible in the price action of cryptocurrencies, precious metals, and momentum stocks.
Silver Analogy Serves as Warning: Semiconductor Momentum May Be Peaking
In his report, Wilson cites an analogy that should alarm bulls: semiconductor stocks are the latest "commodity-like" asset to experience explosive gains this year, following silver, with their price movements showing a roughly four-month lagged correlation. Wilson first illustrated this chart in early June, and the current action is "proceeding as scripted" to confirm this view. "If a sustainable broadening is taking hold, semiconductor price momentum likely needs to experience a peak and it appears that is happening," Wilson stated.
The extreme volatility in the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index over the past two weeks—up 7.3% one week, then down 7.9% the next—reflects high instability within the sector. Wilson notes that with historical net exposure already at elevated levels, this volatility is making it increasingly difficult for investors to maintain large positions in the sector, even amid the rare combination of "rising prices and rising volatility" seen recently. Morgan Stanley's report indicates that conversations with investors over the past week confirmed this sentiment—sensitivity to the sector is rising, while interest in broad-based trades is increasing.
"This does not mean the (semiconductor) cycle is over... but a cyclical peak in price momentum could create room for other areas to outperform," Wilson said.
Hyperscale Cloud Weakness: A Leading Signal for Semiconductors
Wilson characterizes the recent stock price weakness in hyperscale cloud providers as a key leading indicator for gauging the semiconductor sector's path. The logic is that cloud providers are core buyers on the demand side for semiconductors, and marginal changes in their capital expenditure outlook directly impact chip companies' earnings prospects.
"In our view, the rotation out of hyperscalers may be a leading indicator that semis—the primary beneficiary of that capex—are about to enter a period of underperformance as the sector's EPS revision breadth is constrained by historical extremes," Wilson wrote in the report.
From the March lows through May, market funds had notably concentrated in semiconductors and memory chips, with exceptionally strong EPS revisions causing the market to overlook improving earnings expectations in other sectors. The weakness in hyperscale cloud providers has disrupted this narrative. Given that semiconductor earnings revision breadth is currently at a historical high, there is extremely limited room for further upward revisions.
Broad-Based Rally Resumes: Favoring Consumer Discretionary, Transport, and Regional Banks
Wilson and his team have reiterated their positive view on a broad-based rally since last month, with a core allocation focus on consumer discretionary, regional banks, and transportation. He points out that these sectors have already achieved relative outperformance over the past six weeks, although this trend has not yet gained broad market recognition, and investor positioning remains relatively light—particularly for consumer discretionary stocks, where client interest and holdings remain subdued.
Supporting this view is an improvement in the overall earnings structure. Morgan Stanley data shows that median S&P 1500 company earnings growth is now in the double digits, the fastest pace since the post-pandemic recovery; median revenue growth is around 7%, with nearly two-thirds of S&P constituents seeing revenue growth above 5%. Wilson terms this the "underappreciated earnings recovery" and believes it is the fundamental driver enabling equal-weight indices and small-cap stocks to outperform their market-cap-weighted counterparts.
Oil Prices and Fed Expectations: A Dual Tailwind for the Broad-Based Trade
Morgan Stanley has held a relatively bearish stance on oil prices over the past one to two months—a view formed before market awareness of U.S.-Iran negotiation news, primarily based on the narrowing Brent-WTI spread and energy stocks' persistent underperformance since the conflict's onset. West Texas Intermediate crude is now trading around $70.42 per barrel.
The significance of softer oil prices extends beyond dampening inflation; it directly boosts consumer disposable income, providing support for the consumer discretionary sector. Wilson also believes that falling energy prices, peaking tariff-related inflation, and contained services and housing inflation will lead the Federal Reserve to hold rates steady this year rather than hike—a clear divergence from the market's current hawkish expectations. If this prediction materializes, lower real rates would provide a positive surprise for equities, further fueling the broad-based rally.
The June FOMC meeting has already delivered a key signal: a significant weakening of forward guidance indicates that the inflation path will dictate policy direction, diminishing the reference value of the "dot plot." Wilson notes that just as energy stock underperformance was an early signal of declining oil prices, the recent relative strength in several economically sensitive sectors may also be hinting that this year's policy rate expectations have become overly hawkish.
Liquidity Tightening: A Near-Term Risk for Indices and Momentum Stocks
Despite maintaining a constructive view on the broad-based rally, Wilson also points out a significant near-term risk: this iteration of the Federal Reserve is unlikely to be as proactive on balance sheet and liquidity provision as in the past, and this tightening is coinciding with rising liquidity demands from both the real economy (via capital expenditures) and the market (via equity and credit issuance).
He believes the price action of the most liquidity-sensitive assets—including cryptocurrencies, precious metals, and current momentum stocks—is already signaling tightening liquidity. This pressure may continue to weigh on major indices until the Fed or Treasury responds with more generous liquidity provision in reaction to bond market volatility or funding market stress.
Morgan Stanley's base case target for the S&P 500 Index is 8300 points (implying roughly 13% upside from the current level of 7354), but in Wilson's view, achieving this target relies more on a broad-based earnings recovery than on continued leadership from hot momentum sectors.
Comments