Guest: Carter Worth (Founder and CEO of Worth Charting), Host: Caroline Woods.
Caroline Woods: Today we have Carter Worth, founder and CEO of Worth Charting. Carter, welcome back.
Carter Worth: Glad to be back.
Caroline: Let's start with NVIDIA (NVDA). The market reaction after the earnings was very interesting: good earnings, but the stock weakened. What can you read from the price action?
Carter Worth: That's the key point. There is no absolute good or bad earnings report — it's all about how the stock trades. Even with raised earnings guidance, increased buybacks, and better-than-expected margins, if the stock still declines, it means those positives are no longer enough to support the valuation. It has already dropped nearly 40%, from around 242 down to about 150. If you're already holding and have endured this big selloff, you can choose to sell now, or hold and wait for a bounce to exit on a small recovery. If you haven't entered yet, you can build a small position in batches. My preference is the latter — if you have no position, you can establish a small one first.
Caroline: Looking at the chart, it has been almost a straight-line plunge since early October. Is that a warning signal?
Carter Worth: This is an extreme move. It's not that it can't fall another 40%, 45%, 50% — what really matters is the slope of the decline and the process of price clearing — turnover volume has already been very heavy. In my judgment, most of the bad news has already been priced in. But remember, valuation was never a good timing tool. NVIDIA can fall 35%, while Caterpillar (CAT) has already dropped 50%. Was it expensive before the decline? After lowering earnings guidance, is it expensive now? Stocks can keep falling — Nike (NKE) is an example, declining for ten consecutive years. Valuation can't be used for timing. Chart analysis looks at the sequence of price action: when price moves too far in one direction, there is a mean-reversion opportunity. This important stock right now — you can buy, you can sell, or you can do nothing. My choice is to buy.
Caroline: Are there any clues to predict what an NVIDIA bounce might look like?
Carter Worth: Trading earnings stocks is inherently difficult. Imagine a stock going from 10 to 12, a 20% gain. If you take profits and it then shoots straight to 18, you'll feel regret. Conversely, if you hold for higher returns and it falls back, that's the other side. Suppose you buy at 150 to play a bounce, and it rebounds to 160 — taking profits is a good trade, maybe days or weeks. But if it then continues to 190, you've missed out; or it could bounce to 160 and then fall back to 150 again. There is no perfect answer. My approach: buy now; then scale out as you gain unrealized profits. At 170 you can sell a third, at 175 and 180 continue reducing, and exit entirely in that range — that's a good trade. For a stop-loss: entering near 150, you can tolerate a $2-$3 move; if it breaks below 147, exit. Being wrong is fine, but don't keep holding a wrong position.
Caroline: What price level would mark a true turning point and trend reversal?
Carter Worth: A turning point requires time plus price. A seriously ill person doesn't suddenly recover and run a marathon. Bottoming, grinding, and repairing is a long process, often taking many months. What we're betting on now is not a trend reversal, just a technical bounce opportunity after this 40% sharp decline.
Caroline: NVIDIA used to be a long-term allocation target, and people often said "hold it, don't trade frequently." Has that thinking changed now?
Carter Worth: Long term, 98% of stocks underperform short-term Treasuries. The index can keep rising essentially due to survivorship bias: eliminating losers and continually adding new winners. Many people held Westinghouse, Western Union, and Cisco (CSCO) for the long term — Cisco has already fallen 70%. There is no such thing as a permanent growth stock, only stocks in a growth phase. IBM, U.S. Steel, General Motors, Microsoft, Apple, and NVIDIA were all benchmarks of their eras. You need to be on the right side of the trend while maintaining discipline; when losses reach a certain level, you must stop out. Being wrong is fine, but don't stay wrong.
Caroline: When you were on in August, you said that among the Magnificent Seven, Amazon (AMZN) had the healthiest chart and Microsoft was the weakest. After several months and changes in the market, does that judgment need adjusting?
Carter Worth: Microsoft indeed has the biggest volatility; by comparison, Amazon's chart pattern is better.
Caroline: Among the Magnificent Seven, if you could only buy one, which would you choose?
Carter Worth: Apple is currently too complacent — rule it out first; Tesla has too much uncertainty. Apple barely pulled back when semiconductors sold off heavily, and during this S&P correction it became a crowded safe-haven destination, just like consumer staples. When safe-haven trades get crowded, risk rises. For example, Costco (COST) reached a 50x valuation after a sharp short-term rally; low-growth large caps like Walmart and Johnson & Johnson have seen money pile in. Institutional investors can't easily go all to cash and must maintain high exposure; when semiconductors, Caterpillar, and NVIDIA sold off hard, money rotated into these defensive sectors. But the problem is these safe-haven names have already absorbed plenty of money — "the sponge is full of water" — leaving limited upside ahead. Among the Magnificent Seven, I choose Amazon. NVIDIA and Meta can be tried with small positions.
Caroline: You just mentioned the defensive rotation: energy, materials, consumer staples, and healthcare have outperformed tech this year. Do you think these safe-haven trades are already overcrowded? Which sector is relatively less crowded?
Carter Worth: First, energy. In the S&P, energy has only a 3.2% weight, 5.5% of earnings, and 7% of revenue — it's a discounted value sector. You can overweight it, but it's not a high-momentum sector and hasn't been overheated like consumer staples or healthcare. Within energy, I don't favor oil services (Schlumberger (SLB), Halliburton (HAL), Baker Hughes (BKR)); I prefer Exxon Mobil (XOM) and Chevron (CVX). For consumer staples, I lean underweight — the sponge is already full; healthcare depends on individual stocks, with big differences. Eli Lilly (LLY) can continue to be held and bought; Johnson & Johnson is relatively crowded; some medical device stocks have overshot, such as Edwards Lifesciences (EW). Strictly speaking, healthcare isn't the ultimate defensive asset in the traditional sense; the true defensives are daily necessities and food names like Procter & Gamble. Biopharma, devices, and managed care all have different logic and rely more on stock selection. Compared with already crowded consumer staples, healthcare is relatively more worth overweighting.
Caroline: Earlier you said to underweight tech overall. Does that view still hold now?
Carter Worth: Tech stocks have fallen massively over these months, with semiconductors and software hit very hard. I no longer recommend underweighting tech — I've shifted to a neutral allocation. But neutral doesn't mean strongly bullish; you still need to pick individual stocks carefully. Some software stocks are bottoming out, such as ServiceNow; Snowflake I would try with a small position. For memory chips, if you want to bet on an oversold bounce, you can choose NVIDIA, or directly buy the iShares Semiconductor ETF (SOXX), but these are all short-term trades. After a big decline, there won't be a quick recovery; a true bottoming and reversal often takes months, which is different from this kind of oversold bounce.
Caroline: You brought a pairs trade idea: swap Coca-Cola (KO) for Caterpillar. Coca-Cola is only about 3% from its high, while Caterpillar is down about 50% from its high. Why make this swap?
Carter Worth: A pairs trade doesn't discuss whether Coke tastes good or whether excavators work well; it looks at relative valuation and how extreme the ratio is. From June 30, Caterpillar is down about 50%, while Coca-Cola is up about 23%. Both are old-line U.S. equities, and their ratio relationship dates back to the 1980s: when cyclicals are strong, Caterpillar outperforms; in risk-off markets, Coca-Cola is stronger. Now this ratio has reached a rare extreme over the past 50 years, reflecting the current flight from growth into defensives. Coca-Cola has almost no growth, with revenue growth of only 2-3%, and money has become overly concentrated; Caterpillar is deeply oversold. Of course, risks exist: if AI capital spending fades and data center construction slows, Caterpillar's earnings will be revised down. This trade is based purely on the extreme chart spread, and we're looking at a mean-reversion opportunity: short crowded Coca-Cola, go long abandoned Caterpillar, targeting a net return of about 1000 basis points (10%). Historically, similar extreme spreads have appeared only 13 times, and most delivered this return potential.
Caroline: For ordinary retail investors who hold long term but also look at charts, what's your advice?
Carter Worth: Investors should first recognize their own positioning. If you are a buy-and-hold investor, just stay the course. If you are a long-term investor but agree the market has another 10%-12% downside, you don't need to overhaul your holdings. True buy-and-hold investors rarely adjust frequently anyway. If you want moderate flexibility, you can sell covered calls against long positions, or trim slightly. If you're purely a trader, follow trading discipline.
Caroline: From a buy-and-hold perspective, would you buy Caterpillar and sell Coca-Cola now?
Carter Worth: Yes. Of course, some people have a very low cost basis and don't want to trigger capital gains tax — that's a personal tax consideration, unrelated to charts, money flows, or valuation crowding.
Caroline: You screened the 100 lowest-volatility stocks in the Russell 1000, and 9 are suitable to buy. What are the screening criteria?
Carter Worth: The core is high-quality charts: relative strength, momentum, price-volume alignment; not in a steep downtrend, and not already extremely crowded. Simply put, stronger than the index with a steady trend.
Caroline: Besides the names we've discussed, what other chart opportunities are there?
Carter Worth: Deere (DE) has a very good pattern, just breaking above a clear high range from the past 12-18 months without being overextended — an ideal setup. For banks, I lean underweight; the trend is weak. In consumer discretionary, Starbucks (SBUX) has a good chart, holding up against broad market selling; Ralph Lauren and Williams-Sonoma have very poor trends — avoid them.
Caroline: At the index level, in November the S&P fell only about 3.5% and the Nasdaq about 4.5% — not devastating. Do you think there's more downside ahead?
Carter Worth: I believe so. The key is the market's internal structure. The index has been flat for half a year, but internally the divergence is extreme: names like Caterpillar have been cut in half, while safe-haven stocks like Costco keep rising. The index is made up of its components. Damaged names repair slowly, while safe-haven names are already filled with money. The market is now in a stalemate: either safe-haven stocks keep pushing higher with even richer valuations, or the deeply fallen names bounce collectively. I think neither scenario is easily sustainable. The internal structure has already deteriorated.
Caroline: The S&P 500 is now around 7300, and some year-end targets are 8000-8100. Do you have a downside target?
Carter Worth: Price targets themselves are a Wall Street habit of the past 20-30 years — essentially psychological comfort. Over the long run, sell-side strategists almost never turn bearish on the market; their job is to sell optimism. I don't worship price targets, but my judgment is: from now to year-end, the market will be lower, possibly another 10%-12%. Many components are already in bear markets (drawdowns over 20%), and the probability of further overall deterioration is higher than a quick stabilization. A recent survey showed 72% of institutional CIOs believe new highs will come before year-end — I disagree.
Caroline: If safe-haven sectors are already crowded, where does money go next? Cash?
Carter Worth: Money can hardly truly leave the market. Brokerage business models now favor asset gathering, encouraging clients to keep dollar-cost averaging; persistent inflows like 401(k) contributions are very strong support. But historically there have indeed been periods when investors reduce risk and shift toward cash-like assets, and I think that could increase.
Caroline: Are you heavily in cash yourself right now?
Carter Worth: I'm mostly a trader and almost never hold long term, rarely with long-term capital gains. I prefer small caps and high-beta names, trading actively; I'm a speculator, not a long-term investor.
Caroline: Final question: what's the best broad-market chart right now?
Carter Worth: Deere.
Caroline: The worst one you wouldn't touch at all?
Carter Worth: Nike.
Quick-fire round. NVIDIA near 150: buy now or wait? → Buy now. Tech selloff: opportunity or trap? → Trap. Semiconductors: bottoming or more pain? → Bet on a bounce (short term). Amazon or Microsoft? → Amazon. Defensive stocks: safe harbor or crowded trade? → Crowded trade. Utilities or industrials? → About the same. Buy the dip or wait for confirmation? → Wait for confirmation. S&P: market-cap weighted or equal weighted? → Market-cap weighted. Santa Claus rally: yes or no? → No. Year-end price higher or lower? → Lower, at least another 5% down. Chart that worries me most: S&P advance-decline line (cumulative advance-decline issues). One stock I'd buy on a pullback: Microsoft, waiting for a 10-12% pullback. One word to describe the market before 2027: Dodgy. What signal would make you turn bullish: A strong breakout in price action.
Caroline: That was Carter Worth. Thank you.
Carter Worth: Thank you.
Comments