Rebuttal to the "China Economic Governance Failure" Theory

Deep News04-03

Assessing China's full-year economic trends often hinges significantly on the initial momentum. Data shows that in the first two months of this year, the national Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose by 0.8% year-on-year, indicating a mild recovery, with February's CPI increasing by 1.3% year-on-year, marking the highest growth rate in nearly three years. The total value of goods trade imports and exports reached 7.73 trillion yuan, up 18.3% year-on-year. Value-added output in high-tech manufacturing above the designated scale grew by 13.1% year-on-year, while digital product manufacturing increased by 8.8%, both significantly outpacing the overall industrial growth rate. The upward trajectory of these key indicators fully demonstrates a strong start and a favorable opening to the year. However, prior to the release of the main macroeconomic data for January and February, market institutions exhibited considerable divergence in their forecasts for major indicators. This reflects both the complexity and severity of the current domestic and international environment, and illustrates how China's economic performance coexists with both highlights and challenges, intertwining hope with difficulty, and presenting both risks and opportunities. Consequently, the ultimately better-than-expected performance has once again prompted the question: where does China's certainty originate? Addressing this question requires an examination of the logical framework and implementation effectiveness of China's macroeconomic governance system.

Guiding expectations and calibrating policy orientation through development plans highlights strategic resolve. Viewing the Chinese economy through the lens of five-year intervals reveals a clear, steadfast development direction and robust policy consistency. From the 1st to the 15th Five-Year Plan, China's development has not been ad hoc but has consistently adhered to the overarching goal of building a modern socialist country, following a master blueprint and building upon achievements incrementally. Once approved, these plans carry binding force, with annual policies being advanced within their long-term framework rather than being subject to complete overhauls. Understanding the Five-Year Plans allows for a clear grasp of policy expectations. The formal enactment of the National Development Planning Law of the People's Republic of China has further established a legalized mechanism for linking national development plans with annual plans, breaking down major indicators from the plans into annual index systems and ensuring comprehensive annual balancing. This institutional design translates medium- to long-term high-quality development goals into quantifiable, implementable, and assessable annual tasks, facilitating step-by-step progress and sustained implementation. This is the very foundation of confidence in China's development and market environment.

Utilizing macro policies to smooth economic cycles and promote development aims for stability and progress. In confronting various challenges, even storms, during development, China emphasizes innovation not only in policy tools but also in policy combinations. Enhancing counter-cyclical and cross-cyclical adjustments, employing a range of macro policy tools to promptly smooth potential short-term economic fluctuations, while incorporating considerations for medium- to long-term economic development to balance short-term cyclical issues with medium- to long-term structural problems, represents an effective path for continuously improving macroeconomic governance efficacy. Early this year, the People's Bank of China announced several adjustments involving structural monetary policy tools and separately allocated 1 trillion yuan in relending funds for private enterprises. The Ministry of Finance, jointly with other departments, introduced loan discount policies for small, medium, and micro enterprises and fiscal discount policies for personal consumption loans. Furthermore, setting the deficit-to-GDP ratio at around 4%, with a deficit size of 5.89 trillion yuan, boosts market expectations for aggregate demand. The general public budget expenditure scale is set to reach 30 trillion yuan for the first time, targeting key areas precisely. The integrated issuance of 1.3 trillion yuan in ultra-long-term special government bonds and 4.4 trillion yuan in local government special bonds will direct financial resources accurately towards strategic areas such as the "dual focuses" and "AI+". China possesses ample policy tools to drive high-quality development.

Addressing shortcomings and removing deep-seated obstacles through institutional development strengthens the foundational base. Resolving insufficient effective demand is a critical task for the current Chinese economy, and all incremental policies are centered around this objective. For instance, policies are focused on creating employment opportunities and enhancing social security benefit levels, allowing people to feel secure about the future and assured in their livelihoods, thereby reducing the need for excessive precautionary savings and enabling individuals to spend more of their income in the present. Simultaneously, integrating short-term policies with medium- to long-term institutional development aims to fundamentally address the deep-seated issues of weak domestic demand and consumption from the perspective of the economic development model. Reforms such as deepening the fiscal and taxation system, accelerating the urbanization of agricultural migrant populations, and relaxing market access restrictions in the service sector are being advanced concurrently to form long-term mechanisms for expanding domestic demand and effective institutional arrangements for promoting consumption, thereby fostering an economic development model increasingly led by domestic demand, driven by consumption, and characterized by endogenous growth. In the first two months of this year, total retail sales of consumer goods increased by 2.8% year-on-year, accelerating by 1.9 percentage points compared to December 2025. Service retail sales grew by 5.6% year-on-year, significantly faster than the growth of goods retail sales. Fixed asset investment rose by 1.8% year-on-year, shifting from a decline of 3.8% for the full previous year to growth. The reality of a more robust domestic demand as the primary driver sufficiently illustrates that the combination of policy support and reform innovation is yielding tangible results.

China's macroeconomic governance seeks dynamic balance among multiple objectives and achieves synergistic effects across various tasks. In recent years, facing profound and complex changes in the domestic and international environment, China's macroeconomic governance system has demonstrated its capacity for adjustment resilience under extreme external shocks and the growth certainty released through the transformation of internal drivers. Understanding this logic and acknowledging the reality of China's economy advancing towards new and superior quality development, the erroneous arguments promoted by some foreign media regarding so-called "China's economic governance failure" are self-evidently refuted. Observers recognize that amidst the accelerated evolution of changes unseen in a century, China, like a vessel, navigates steadily through winds and waves, while simultaneously addressing and responding to a series of global, epochal, and historical transformations, contributing Chinese wisdom and solutions towards a more just and reasonable international order. Some, unable to accept the historic shift in the international balance of power, may continue to propagate baseless arguments to confuse public opinion, clinging to outdated hegemonic rules and orders. Regardless of rising challenges, China remains steadfast in managing its own affairs well, unwaveringly expanding high-level opening-up, and injecting strong momentum into a faltering world economy through the certainty of its high-quality development.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment