MSCI Drops Three Treasury Companies, Crypto-Funded Expansion Model Under Growing Pressure

Stock News11-12

MSCI Inc (MSCI.US) has published the results of its November 2026 index review, removing Strategy (MSTR.US), Metaplanet and Upexi, Inc. (UPXI.US), with the related adjustments taking effect after the close on November 30.

The removals mark the official implementation of MSCI's new "non-operating company" framework. Last year, MSCI proposed excluding treasury companies whose digital assets accounted for 50% or more of total assets. In January of this year, the plan was not implemented, and the review scope was subsequently broadened to cover "non-operating companies" across different asset classes. On October 15, MSCI announced it had adopted the new framework, to be applied with the November index review.

Under the new framework, MSCI first examines operating assets, then uses indicators such as operating expenses, operating cash flow, fair value changes and reliance on external financing to determine whether a company is closer to an investment vehicle. Existing constituents that fail the screen in both of the most recent two annual reporting periods will be deleted. For treasury companies, retaining software, hotel or consumer goods businesses may not be enough to keep index eligibility. If a company's assets are mainly tokens, its financial performance largely tracks coin prices, and its expansion depends on external financing, its legacy businesses may not be enough to change the screening outcome. In the end, Strategy, Metaplanet and Upexi all failed to retain their index eligibility, while ETH treasury company SharpLink (SBET.US) remains on the watch list and was not included in this round of deletions.

Data compiled by Woofun AI shows that after the three companies are removed, funds tracking the relevant indexes will need to adjust their holdings, directly reducing allocation demand. Among them, Strategy's potential selling pressure has drawn the most attention. In its earlier consultation response, the company disclosed that funds tracking the MSCI Global Investable Market Index (GIMI) held about 13 million MSTR shares, equal to 3.1% of its basic share capital. Based on the closing price of $121.07 on November 10, that stake was worth about $1.57 billion. JPMorgan (JPM.US) estimated last year that Strategy's removal from MSCI could trigger about $2.8 billion of selling, and that the scale could rise to about $8.8 billion if other major index providers follow suit. That estimate corresponded to MSCI's old October 2025 proposal, withdrawn in January 2026, for a "50% digital asset threshold," not the new framework adopted this time; MSCI has not officially disclosed the scale of passive fund outflows from this adjustment.

Although the potential selling pressure has attracted market attention, Strategy remains relatively calm about the impact of the adjustment. The company stressed that the above 13 million shares represent only about 60% of its 30-day average daily trading volume, and therefore it believes the adjustment will not have a material impact on the company. However, a holding below one day's trading volume can illustrate how actively a stock trades, but it is not enough to judge the impact of rebalancing on the share price. Metaplanet and Upexi also face pressure from related fund exits, but the actual selling pressure depends on each company's fund holdings and stock liquidity, and Strategy's scale cannot simply be applied to them. Metaplanet CEO Simon Gerovich has said the adjustment will not have a material impact on the company's business or its Bitcoin strategy; Upexi has not yet made a public statement on the removal.

Even after the rebalancing-driven selling pressure gradually fades, the impact of reduced stock demand will persist. After exiting the relevant indexes, these funds no longer need to buy the three companies' shares at their former weightings even if they receive new subscription inflows. Beyond the one-off selling, the three companies also lose a portion of continuous passive buying. Reduced passive buying may also affect treasury companies' ability to raise funds for further crypto purchases. Such companies have been able to keep increasing their crypto asset holdings largely because of a stock premium. When the share price is above net asset value per share, the company can issue new shares to raise funds, and the assets purchased have a chance to offset dilution from the larger share count while increasing the amount of holdings represented by each share. Investors are willing to pay a premium because they expect the company to accumulate more assets per share through subsequent purchases. Once the premium narrows, the same amount of purchase funding requires issuing more new shares. If the share price has already fallen below net asset value per share, continued issuance may also lower the net asset value per share for existing shareholders, and the room for raising funds to buy more assets will be constrained as well.

MSCI's removal this time will not directly force the three companies to sell crypto assets, but with less passive buying, maintaining a stock premium may become more difficult. If the share price remains under pressure, the companies will have to choose between slowing purchases and accepting less favorable financing terms. The old model of relying on premium financing and using purchases to attract investors will also become increasingly difficult to sustain. Whether financing crypto purchases can continue will also depend on how much return the purchases can deliver to shareholders. If the company holds more and more crypto assets while the assets represented by each shareholder's stake do not increase, it will be hard to persuade investors to buy into the next round of financing.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment