Investor Warns: Tech Leaders Hurt by "Superstar" Status

Deep News11-16 19:40

An outspoken British technology investor has criticized the founder-dominated power model that is common in Silicon Valley, and he has cautioned that the superstar status held by executives such as Jensen Huang and Elon Musk may already have weakened the governance standards of several of the world's top companies.

James Anderson is a managing partner at Lingotto Investment Management and a former star fund manager at Baillie Gifford. In an interview, he said he worries that "great success and the fame that comes with it have weakened the leadership abilities of many of these founders."

This so-called "founder mode" has long been admired in Silicon Valley, but Anderson believes the scale of risk facing the industry is now much larger, which raises the importance of corporate governance.

An early investor in Tesla Motors (TSLA) and Amazon.com (AMZN), Anderson has held a position in NVIDIA (NVDA) since 2016. He said the extreme success and fame achieved by technology billionaire founders "often affect their private lives and then ripple through the entire company."

In NVIDIA's regulatory filings, there is no succession planning content at all, which is highly unusual for a company of its size. Before Jensen Huang resigned as CEO, the company's board had also never established a chairman role.

The NVIDIA board has now appointed Chief Financial Officer Colette Kress as interim CEO and launched a search for a successor at the same time. Anderson said one of the major problems Huang created is that "we know too little about the other internal candidates."

"What we do know is that many internal executives have been with NVIDIA since the company's founding. I believe there must be a suitable candidate internally," he said. He prefers promoting a successor from within in order to preserve the company's existing culture.

Anderson also raised a core question about the rapid wealth accumulation of some technology founders: "Can founder-led governance continue to operate in a healthy way?"

"Looking back, I once strongly supported Musk, and now I feel very uneasy about it," Anderson said of the chain of events that followed. He noted that Musk publicly supported Trump, while the Trump administration does not embrace the clean energy transition path Musk once championed.

Anderson still holds a small Tesla Motors (TSLA) position. He believes Musk's work at Trump's so-called Department of Government Efficiency "damaged the U.S. education system and, in turn, weighed on innovation," while money has also "corrupted American politics."

"In the long run, all of this is also a major negative for Silicon Valley. He has offended too many groups," Anderson said. Lingotto is backed by Italy's Agnelli family, and Anderson and Morgan Sarmet manage Lingotto Innovation there, a fund that covers multi-stage growth strategies and invests in both public and private companies.

Anderson said that in the past he often felt that "corporate governance was just for show, passive and rigid," but recently he has realized that "governance issues have become crucial again, especially now that we are facing a series of major risks."

Anthropic, an AI company set to enter the secondary market this week, warned in its IPO prospectus that the technology could bring "catastrophic or even existential risks" to humanity. Anthropic's IPO arrangement gives voting control to seven co-founders, allowing them to block other shareholders from pushing for board changes.

Over the past two years, many investors have been wary of soaring valuations for AI companies, and warnings have kept appearing in the market that the massive trillion-dollar computing infrastructure investment plans of large technology companies are not sustainable.

The U.S. Democratic Party won a landslide victory in this month's midterm elections, and the market is worried that AI regulation will tighten and the pace of data center construction will slow.

Anderson believes that a slower pace of AI development "may be a good thing from a financial perspective and even from the perspective of humanity as a whole."

"Fierce competition among frontier labs and major cloud companies, combined with geopolitical factors, has pushed AI development faster than is reasonable," he said. However, Anderson said that at current share prices, he would be very cautious about selling NVIDIA (NVDA) stock. "Although NVIDIA's strong position has weakened at the margin, its fundamentals for at least the next 18 months are basically locked in."

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment