The 2018 Script Returns: Relentless Rate Hikes Hammered Stocks 20% From September Peak, Forcing a Fed Pivot in January

Deep News13:29

US equities keep sliding and financial conditions are tightening sharply, with the market flashing warning signs reminiscent of late 2018: even as pressure builds, the Fed still faces policy expectations of further rate hikes, and investors are starting to worry that monetary tightening could once again deepen the turmoil.

According to a Friday note from Goldman Sachs trading chief Rich Privorotsky, today's market bears a striking resemblance to the end of 2018. He describes the recent selloff as "wholesale liquidation-style monetization" rather than ordinary sector rotation, and warns the market may be shifting from declining risk appetite toward a deeper liquidity contraction.

Back then, the Fed hiked rates repeatedly through 2018, and the S&P 500 fell 19.8% from its September peak to its December 24 low, closing in on a technical bear market. As pressure kept mounting, the Fed finally signaled a pause in January 2019, marking a shift in its policy stance.

Now, Privorotsky is paying especially close attention to gold. Stocks and gold have been sold off in tandem, with the traditional safe-haven asset failing to provide protection. In his view, gold may be the best gauge for judging the depth of the current liquidity crisis, and its price action could reveal whether market stress is worsening further.

The lesson of late 2018: sustained rate hikes eventually forced the Fed to pivot

In 2018, the Fed raised rates four times over the year. On September 20, the S&P 500 set a阶段性 high, and pressure then built steadily as global growth slowed, trade frictions intensified and monetary policy kept tightening.

In December, the Fed hiked again, lifting the federal funds target range to 2.25%–2.50%. Yet worries about the economic outlook and monetary policy kept escalating, and the S&P 500 fell nearly 20% from its September peak to its December 24 low.

The selloff ultimately pushed the Fed to adjust its stance. On January 30, 2019, the Fed said it would be patient about future rate adjustments, a clear signal that it was pausing hikes, and the market rallied afterward.

Privorotsky argues the market today faces the same dual pressure of tightening financial conditions and a strained growth outlook, with the conflict between policy and markets deepening.

Financial conditions tighten abruptly as the market shifts from rotation to broad selling

Privorotsky notes that the most obvious change is how the selling has spread from a handful of sectors to the entire market. On Thursday, the S&P 500 rose more than 1% intraday before closing down 2%, its sixth straight decline and another drop below its 200-day moving average. All 11 sectors closed lower that day, and traditional defensive groups such as utilities and consumer staples were not spared.

Meanwhile, the Goldman Sachs US Financial Conditions Index (FCI) macro basket rose to 124.48 on Thursday, its highest level in the past year. Since early November, the index has climbed about 8 points in roughly two weeks, showing financial conditions are tightening rapidly.

Fed officials have been sounding hawkish in quick succession, with Governor Waller's comments about a 50 basis point hike and minutes showing officials' support for further increases adding to market anxiety. Rising capital costs are also weighing on the expected returns from AI infrastructure investment.

Privorotsky believes market technicals have been badly damaged, and negative gamma effects in the options market are amplifying the decline. What began as sector rotation is turning into broader equity liquidation.

Gold becomes the best gauge of the liquidity crisis

Among all assets, Privorotsky is watching gold most closely. He sees it as the most valuable coincident indicator of current market liquidity conditions.

Normally, gold is viewed as a safe-haven asset, but this time it has fallen in tandem with stocks. Gold dropped below $3,600, and copper also plunged about 5% in a single day.

This synchronized cross-asset decline sends a signal different from an ordinary market correction: investors are no longer simply rotating from stocks into havens such as gold, but are selling different types of assets to raise cash. The market may be facing a broader liquidity contraction.

ANZ notes that speculative long positions in gold still have about 200 tonnes of potential reduction ahead, meaning deleveraging pressure may not be fully released.

At the same time, long-end Treasury yields are falling and inflation breakeven rates are compressing, while stocks and gold are being sold off together. Privorotsky argues this combination shows the market's focus is shifting from inflation to growth and liquidity concerns, and the bond market may already be pricing in a policy mistake.

Therefore, whether gold can stabilize and stop falling will be an important window for judging whether market liquidity pressure is easing.

When will the market get a policy pivot?

Privorotsky believes the current level of pessimism and one-sided deleveraging suggests the market may be approaching a tactical low. Because fund positioning is already significantly underweight, any rebound catalyst could trigger a sharp rally.

But a genuine turn still depends on whether policy expectations change. He remains bullish on long-duration short-term Treasuries, arguing that this trade is clearly misaligned with the risk signals reflected in the stock market.

In the near term, the market will focus on PCE data, the nonfarm payrolls report and the December FOMC meeting. Privorotsky argues the data most likely to force the Fed to reassess its policy path is the November CPI reading, but that is still some time away.

Notably, Goldman Sachs economists currently still expect the Fed to hike 25 basis points in December and again in March 2027, and bond market pricing diverges markedly from that forecast.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment