Even as the international spot gold price holds above the key $4,000 per ounce level, industry insiders believe the downward pressure on the precious metal has not yet subsided. According to Carley Garner, co-founder of DeCarley Trading and a seasoned commodity trader, if Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh successfully drives U.S. dollar strength and reverses the longstanding "currency debasement trade" narrative, gold could potentially fall further towards the $3,600-$3,700 range. In such a scenario, the U.S. dollar and Treasury bonds are poised to be the primary beneficiaries of this capital rotation.
Potential Impact of Policy Shift
In an interview, Garner stated that the market is underestimating the potential profound impact of Warsh's policy approach. She argues that Warsh's strategy to combat inflation relies not solely on interest rate tools but emphasizes restoring price stability by contracting market liquidity and reducing the money supply, a path that could lead to further dollar appreciation. One of the core drivers behind gold's multi-year rally has been concern over the declining purchasing power of the U.S. dollar. Garner suggests that if Warsh successfully rebuilds confidence in the dollar's credibility, this fundamental pillar for gold could be significantly challenged.
Challenging the Debasement Narrative
"Upon his appointment, Warsh made it clear his intention is to end the 'debasement trade,'" Garner said. "His goal is to withdraw liquidity, reduce the money supply, and thereby push the dollar higher. I believe he aims to use a stronger dollar to help control inflation, which is not positive news for commodities like gold, silver, and copper." She pointed out that since the pandemic, massive liquidity flooded markets, prompting investors to buy gold as a hedge against currency devaluation and inflation risks. If the Fed can restore confidence in the dollar by tightening liquidity, the "Debasement Trade" that has dominated markets in recent years could face a turning point.
Broader Commodity Pressure and Gold's Outlook
Garner believes that in an environment of sustained dollar strength, not just gold but the entire commodity complex could face increased pressure. While maintaining a long-term bullish view on gold, she contends the market has not yet completed its adjustment. She describes gold as entering a phase of sustained deleveraging and capital outflow, with the adjustment process resembling a "slow-motion train wreck." She anticipates that gold may ultimately establish a new long-term base in the $3,600-$3,700 per ounce range, which could serve as a crucial launchpad for the next major rally.
Valuation Concerns and Safe-Haven Alternatives
Garner posits that current prices for many assets, including gold, still reflect the liquidity premium from the ultra-loose monetary policies during the pandemic rather than true fundamental value. "For the past four years, we've been digesting this 'money created out of thin air.' Only when this excess liquidity truly exits the market will we discover where reasonable asset prices lie," she remarked. She believes that as speculative capital gradually exits gold, cryptocurrencies, and some high-valuation tech stocks, U.S. Treasuries and the dollar could become new safe havens. She noted that Treasuries currently offer yields around 4% to 5%, presenting a strong attraction for capital in a declining risk-appetite environment. "If the market experiences greater volatility, I believe the U.S. dollar and Treasury bonds are the assets truly worth holding," she added.
Positioning and Strategy
Despite her bearish outlook, Garner does not currently recommend directly shorting gold. She believes that with market volatility remaining elevated and option prices generally expensive, a lower-cost bear put spread strategy is more suitable. She suggests that if gold prices rebound to the $4,350-$4,400 area, one could consider buying a $3,600-strike put option while selling a $3,800-strike put option to construct a bear spread. She explained that because these options are far from the current price, the cost to establish the position is relatively low. Even if gold does not fall near the strike prices, the spread could still deliver favorable returns if the market experiences a significant decline. However, Garner emphasized that in the current market environment, she prefers to use rallies to find opportunities to establish short positions rather than attempting to prematurely buy gold against the prevailing trend.
Comments