Financial Conditions Tighten Abruptly, Goldman Sachs Executive Warns Market Rotation Is Turning Into Broad-Based Selling

Deep News11-20 22:21

The combination of rapidly tightening financial conditions, escalating computing restrictions, and the Federal Reserve's hawkish stance is pushing US equities from a structural rotation into an outright liquidation-style selloff.

On Thursday, the S&P 500 Index initially climbed more than 1% intraday before reversing sharply to close down 2%, marking its longest six-day losing streak since April 2024. The index once again fell below its 200-day moving average, with only 38 constituents closing higher and 464 declining on the day. Rich Privorotsky, Goldman Sachs' head of EMEA Delta One trading, admitted in a Friday morning client note that the decline caught even him off guard, stating bluntly: "You can't have this many charts, this many assets breaking down at the same time and pretend we're still in a bull market."

The speed at which financial conditions have tightened is particularly alarming. The Goldman Sachs US Financial Conditions Index (FCI) macro basket closed at 124.48 on Thursday, the highest level in the past year and even exceeding the March peak. The index stood at approximately 116.5 in early November, implying a tightening of roughly 8 points in just two weeks. Privorotsky compared the current situation to the market crisis at the end of 2018, warning that the Fed may be repeating the same mistake of "lagging behind the market and over-tightening."

Markets Hit by a 'Perfect Storm'

Thursday's plunge was not driven by any single factor but rather multiple negative developments detonating simultaneously on the same day.

The first was the greater-than-expected escalation of chip export controls, followed by the Fed's persistently strengthening hawkish signals. Fed Governor Waller's remarks about a 50 basis point rate hike "genuinely rattled the market," and hawkish comments from multiple Fed officials combined with meeting minutes showing that nearly the entire FOMC favored continued rate hikes, together driving a rapid tightening of financial conditions.

Technical Breakdown Across the Board, Defensive Assets Also Falter

From the perspective of market internals, the damage from this decline far exceeds that of an ordinary correction.

Privorotsky described Thursday's technical damage as "breaching virtually every possible support level":

The S&P 500 had a single-day range of 3.3%, closing at its intraday low, with all 11 sectors finishing lower. Healthcare and consumer staples sectors led the declines.

Nomura's Charlie McElligott had previously warned that dealers, ahead of the triple event of Nvidia's earnings, the Anthropic IPO, and options expiration, held the largest short gamma position since 2019, with the negative gamma effect clearly amplifying the afternoon selloff.

What troubled Privorotsky even more was the collective failure of defensive assets. Although utilities and consumer staples sectors outperformed the broader market on a relative basis, they also posted absolute declines. "The rolling rotation we saw previously increasingly looks like outright equity liquidation." Gold fell below $3,700 for the first time since September 2025, and copper dropped about 5% in a single day. Market rumors suggest that some of the capital from this week's selling in gold, cryptocurrencies, copper, and Nvidia flowed toward financing the Anthropic IPO — a deal that ultimately raised $81.3 billion (or $107.3 billion including the allotment portion). "The IPO got the money, and everything else paid the bill."

Historical Mirror of 2018, Long-End Bonds First to Price In Policy Error

Privorotsky explicitly drew a historical analogy to late 2018 in his report, arguing that the current situation is highly similar to that period.

"In hindsight, the price action from November to December 2018 increasingly resembles the current environment. The Fed risks looking in the rearview mirror at inflation and the AI trade, effectively over-tightening when the market is already showing considerable stress." He noted that the 2-year inflation breakeven rate has fallen to low levels while the 2-year real yield is near relative highs. "This is an unusual tightening of real policy conditions at a critical moment when the stock market is signaling deteriorating growth and liquidity."

The history of 2018 was this: the Fed insisted on raising rates and maintaining balance sheet reduction, and the S&P 500 fell about 20% from its September high to Christmas Eve, only bottoming and rebounding after Powell promised "patience" on January 4, 2019. BTIG's Jonathan Krinsky also noted that over the past 30 years, there have only been three instances of a six-day losing streak closing below the 200-day moving average with a decline not exceeding 3%: September 27, 2000, October 11, 2018, and February 27, 2020. All three rebounded within the following five trading days, but each was followed by even larger declines.

Notably, long-end bonds may have already been the first to price in a policy error — amid simultaneous selling in stocks and gold, long-end yields actually moved lower while inflation breakeven rates compressed in tandem. Privorotsky believes this "increasingly looks like a shift from an inflation problem to a growth/liquidity problem."

When Will a Turning Point Come? The Key Is When the Fed Pivots

Facing the current situation, Privorotsky offered a relatively clear trading framework but remained cautious on the timing of a bottom.

He acknowledged that the market may experience "some forced financing or liquidation activity that won't repeat," but refused to use that as an excuse to avoid reality. He maintained his "long front-end bonds" call, arguing that receiving rates and holding duration "remains the trade that is most mismatched with equity internal signals and therefore relatively attractive." He also recommended watching gold as a "coincident indicator" alongside equities, with its selloff being "a clear reaction to tighter real rates and financial conditions."

From a contrarian perspective, the current extreme pessimism and one-sided deleveraging may mean the market is approaching a tactical local low, and the fact that funds are significantly underweight tech stocks means that any rebound could be quite violent. However, the catalyst to trigger a rebound is currently unclear: the near-term calendar includes next Wednesday's PCE data, followed by the non-farm payrolls report and the December FOMC meeting. Privorotsky believes that November CPI data is the key that could truly "force the Fed to recalibrate," but it is still some time away and "may not trigger a market reaction just yet."

Goldman Sachs economists currently still expect a 25 basis point rate hike in December and another in March 2027. Until the Fed clearly pivots, Privorotsky's judgment is: every rebound may be an opportunity to reduce positions on strength.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment