Following a significant annual loss, the CEO of major Japanese automaker Honda Motor (NYSE: HMC) apologized to shareholders at the company's annual meeting on Friday and secured their support for his re-election to the board.
In his address, CEO Toshihiro Mibe stated that the company is working to recover from a costly strategic misstep. This comes after Honda reported its first annual net loss in seven decades last month, heavily impacted by over $9 billion in restructuring costs for its struggling electric vehicle business and intense competitive pressure from rivals in China.
After the CEO's apology and the subsequent investor backing, Honda's shares showed a relatively positive trend in Friday's Japanese trading session, with intraday gains exceeding 2%. Its American Depositary Receipts (HMC.US) also rose approximately 2.5% in overnight trading.
This stands in contrast to its year-to-date performance, where the ADRs had fallen nearly 10% following the announcement of the historic loss, significantly underperforming the S&P 500 and reducing the company's market capitalization to around $34 billion. The positive stock reaction is not merely a reward for the apology, but rather the market repricing Honda into a new growth framework characterized by "loss recognition, profit recovery, and a strategic pivot."
Previously, Honda recorded the loss due to massive EV restructuring costs. However, the company has since abandoned its overly ambitious long-term EV sales targets. Its strategy is now shifting toward hybrid vehicles—where it holds a strong industry advantage—and a more realistic outlook for cash flow from traditional internal combustion engine vehicles, alongside initiating partnerships for software and intelligent vehicle technologies.
CEO's Apology and Broader Industry Challenges
"I would like to express my deepest apologies to our shareholders for the significant concern and anxiety caused by the rare net loss in our financial results for the previous fiscal year," CEO Toshihiro Mibe told shareholders at the meeting's outset.
Alongside supporting Mibe, shareholders approved the company's slate of 10 other director candidates, which included nine incumbents and one new member. The voting outcome aligned with the recommendations of proxy advisory firms Glass Lewis and ISS, which had advised supporting all director nominees.
Mibe explained that the decision for a large EV-related write-down, amid reduced subsidies, was primarily due to battery-electric vehicle market share in the U.S. falling far short of expectations. Selling its planned EV models would have required substantial incentives.
He stated that continuing with the planned EV sales "would have meant the automotive business itself would remain in an operating loss for at least five years, possibly as long as seven years," adding that this would have placed the company in an extremely precarious long-term position.
In recent months, Mibe has faced sharp criticism from retired Honda executives over these strategic errors. According to media reports, former CEO Nobuhiko Kawamoto visited the Tokyo headquarters in April to urge Mibe to resign. These former executives criticized Mibe for neglecting the Chinese market—the world's largest—and for the failed EV strategy that led to massive losses, while also highlighting the company's growing reliance on its profitable motorcycle division.
Near the end of the meeting, a shareholder proposed a motion to remove Mibe. The CEO declined to put it to a vote, stating the item was not on the agenda and therefore could not be considered.
Mibe noted that negotiations with Nissan Motor and Mitsubishi Motors for deep collaboration on next-generation automotive technologies have reached an advanced stage. These talks, ongoing since mid-2024, aim to establish a large-scale platform for shared software, electrification, and autonomous driving technologies to reduce costs and improve efficiency across multiple manufacturers.
Strategic Reset Underpins Market Reaction
The CEO's apology is just one aspect of corporate governance. What truly reassured shareholders were three more substantive factors.
First, Honda has taken a one-time write-down to clear its EV strategic error, acknowledging that U.S. EV adoption is lower than expected and that pushing ahead with original models would require high incentives. Mibe explicitly stated that continuing would have meant losses for the auto business for 5 to 7 years, signaling to capital markets a willingness to "take the loss now rather than continue burning cash."
Second, the unanimous shareholder support for all directors, in line with proxy advisor recommendations, weakened the potential operational damage from pressure by retired executives and the removal motion.
Third, Honda signaled that its collaboration with Nissan and Mitsubishi on next-gen tech is at an advanced stage, offering the market a new narrative of shifting from "going it alone" to "alliances for cost reduction and shared platforms."
The relatively positive stock reaction essentially reflects the market repricing Honda into a new phase of "loss clearance, profit recovery, and strategic refocusing." This has fostered investor optimism for a long-term valuation recovery, highlighting whether "the worst of the capital expenditure drain has been cut off."
For the auto manufacturing sector, Honda's latest moves equate to an engineering "project halt for止损" and "production rescheduling"—halting low-return EV projects, protecting profit pools in North America and motorcycles, and using hybrids and alliance partnerships to secure a transition period with a more optimistic cash flow outlook.
Comments