Citigroup Expert Call: Traditional DRAM Shortage to Persist Through Next Year, HBM Supply Crunch Most Severe, NAND May Swing to Oversupply in H2 Next Year

Stock News11-16

Citigroup recently issued a research report stating that, according to industry experts, the structural shortage driven by artificial intelligence (AI) will continue to dominate the memory market, though conditions will diverge noticeably across different sub-segments: the traditional DRAM supply-demand gap will keep widening, HBM high-bandwidth memory will face the most acute shortage with an inflection point delayed until 2028, while the NAND flash market is expected to shift from shortage to oversupply in the second half of 2027.

Citigroup said it hosted a memory industry expert fireside chat during its 2026 China Conference, inviting industry expert Shijie Hou to provide in-depth analysis of the global memory chip supply-demand landscape, price trends, and the current state of China's memory industry localization.

In the traditional DRAM market, the expert judged that global supply shortages will persist throughout 2027, with the gap further widening. Calculations show that the global DRAM supply-demand gap will expand from -1.3% in 2026 to -4.6% in 2027, with the peak shortage occurring within 2027. Supported by the supply-demand dynamics, DRAM contract prices in the fourth quarter of 2026 are expected to rise 10%-15% quarter-on-quarter, with the price peak most likely falling in the second to third quarter of 2027.

The report specifically noted that HBM capacity crowding out ordinary DRAM wafers is a key factor intensifying general memory tightness. Although HBM products account for only 13% of total DRAM bit shipments, they consume 30% of DRAM wafer capacity; the share of DRAM wafers consumed by HBM will rise further from 20% in 2026 to 30% in 2027, with large amounts of wafer resources being taken up by high-bandwidth memory, further squeezing effective supply of conventional DRAM.

HBM is the segment with the most acute supply-demand contradiction in this memory cycle. The expert estimates that the HBM supply gap will widen further from -3% in 2026 to -9.6% in 2027, and the substantive inflection point for industry supply tightness will not arrive until 2028. Currently, the 2027 HBM capacity of the world's three major DRAM manufacturers has been fully locked up by customers through long-term contracts. On the pricing side, HBM3E (12H) prices already rose more than 50% in June 2026; looking ahead to 2027, HBM4 12H 36GB product prices are expected to double, rising from US$600 in 2026 to US$1,300.

Compared with the continued tightness in DRAM and HBM, the NAND flash market will see a clear turning point in 2027. The expert expects NAND shortage pressure to gradually ease: the supply-demand gap will be -3.9% in 2026, narrow to -2% in the first half of 2027 and approach balance, before turning into a 5% oversupply in the second half of 2027. Increased stacking layers, large-scale adoption of QLC technology, and the release of new industry capacity are the three core drivers pushing rapid NAND supply expansion.

On price timing, the peak window for consumer-grade NAND prices falls in the fourth quarter of 2026 to the first quarter of 2027; enterprise-grade SSD prices will show significantly stronger resilience than consumer categories and have the strongest pricing support. Overall NAND contract prices are expected to rise 15-20% quarter-on-quarter in the fourth quarter of 2026, with enterprise-grade SSD contract prices rising more than 20%.

Regarding China's memory supply chain channels and inventory situation, survey information shows that 70%-80% of domestic memory supply comes from direct sales by memory IDM manufacturers, including supply from manufacturers to module makers. Current inventory at memory manufacturers is only 2-4 weeks, significantly below the industry's normal level of 6-8 weeks, with the vast majority of inventory sitting at downstream module makers and consumer electronics distributors.

On the localization front, domestic penetration rates vary significantly across different memory products. Client SSD localization penetration has reached 40-45%, while non-flagship mobile DRAM localization stands at 15-25%; however, DRAM localization for server and enterprise-grade applications remains low at only 5-12%. According to expert forecasts, China's overall DRAM self-sufficiency rate is expected to reach 42% in 2027, and NAND self-sufficiency is expected to reach 45%.

In the semiconductor equipment sector, domestic equipment can cover 60-65% of production needs for mature processes, with localization coverage of 40-45% for advanced processes; however, the localization progress of metrology and inspection equipment lags behind, with a localization rate of only about 10%, remaining a weak link in the supply chain.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment