SanDisk Corp. (SNDK.US), which had soared on the wave of a supercycle in memory chips, received a sharp blow from prominent short-selling firm Citron Research on Tuesday. The firm publicly announced it had established a short position in SanDisk, pointedly stating that the market was severely mispricing the stock. Following this news, SanDisk's stock price fell by nearly 8% during Tuesday's trading session. Although this decline appears minor compared to its staggering year-to-date gain of approximately 175% and its cumulative return of over 1200% in the past year, the entry of a short-seller has undoubtedly cast a long shadow over this rocket-like ascent.
"NVIDIA has a moat; SanDisk sells a commodity," Citron stated bluntly in a post on the social media platform X. "The market is pricing SanDisk like it's pricing NVIDIA (NVDA.US). But there's one problem: NVIDIA possesses a competitive moat, while SanDisk sells a commodity." This comment directly addresses the core vulnerability of SanDisk's business model – the highly cyclical nature of its primary product, NAND flash memory. Citron believes the current surge in demand and prices for NAND flash is a classic cyclical phenomenon, and this cycle is nearing its peak. Citing historical precedent, they warned, "We've seen this in 2008, 2012, and 2018. This time is no different. Memory chips are a cyclical industry, and cycles always peak." Citron emphasized that the supply shortage for NAND memory could reverse rapidly, potentially disappearing "after just one earnings call."
Citron identified industry giant Samsung Electronics (SSNLF.US) as the most significant threat to SanDisk, detailing Samsung's habitual competitive tactics. The firm pointed out that Samsung has a 30-year history of prioritizing market share over profits. "They wait for pure-play manufacturers like SanDisk to get comfortable with high gross margins of 50%, and then they 'flip the switch,' squeezing prices by increasing supply." More urgently, Citron observed that Samsung is shifting its strategy and directly encroaching on SanDisk's core territory. "Samsung just told the world they won't sell products below a 50% gross margin and are moving their best chips into the same high-end solid-state drive market as SanDisk." Citron warned that Samsung is no longer just a "gorilla" relying on production scale; it is now competing for SanDisk's core customers with lower prices and more advanced technology.
Beyond industry competition and cyclical factors, Citron also highlighted another critical signal: the ongoing divestment by long-term investor Western Digital Corp. (WDC.US). As SanDisk's former parent company, Western Digital is offloading its remaining stake through a series of secondary offerings. Citron commented on this, "While pundits on TV are cheering retail investors onto the 'bull market train,' long-term investor Western Digital sold a large block of shares days ago at a price 25% below the current level. Ask yourself why. Because they know the cycle is nearing a peak; they aren't waiting for the bell to ring."
It is noteworthy that just before Citron announced its short position, SanDisk had released a second-quarter earnings report that far exceeded Wall Street's expectations. Buoyed by robust demand for enterprise SSDs from data centers, the company reported substantial quarter-over-quarter revenue growth and provided an optimistic third-quarter outlook. This strong earnings report had initially pushed the stock price even higher, making the timing of Citron's short bet particularly significant.
SanDisk is currently in a critical transition period. With Western Digital's exit, the company is attempting to capitalize on the growing demand for NAND flash memory driven by AI and data centers as a fully independent entity. However, Citron's short-selling action undoubtedly adds a significant voice to the market debate between "cyclical versus structural growth." The company's next quarterly report, scheduled for release on May 15 Eastern Time, will serve as the next key test for market confidence and the industry's direction.
Comments