Press Release: CIB Marine Bancshares, Inc. Announces Second Quarter 2025 Results

Dow Jones07-11

BROOKFIELD, Wis, July 11, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- CIB Marine Bancshares, Inc. (the "Company" or "CIB Marine") (OTCQX: CIBH), the holding company of CIBM Bank (the "Bank"), announced its unaudited results of operations and financial condition for the quarter and six months ended June 30, 2025. During the quarter, net interest income and mortgage operations both improved operating results on a quarterly and year-to-date basis as further outlined below.

Net income for the quarter was $0.7 million, or $0.50 basic and $0.48 diluted earnings per share, compared to $0.5 million, or $0.34 basic and $0.25 diluted earnings per share, for the same period of 2024 excluding the effects of the sale-leaseback transaction gain on sale reported in the second quarter of 2024. Net income for the six months ended June 30, 2025, was $1.0 million, or $0.74 basic and $0.71 diluted earnings per share, compared to $0.6 million, or $0.80 basic and $0.35 diluted earnings per share, for the same period of 2024 also excluding the effects of the sale-leaseback transaction gain on sale.

Financial highlights for the quarter and six months ended June 30 include:

   -- Net interest margin increased to 2.69% from 2.62% in the first quarter of 
      2025 and 2.38% in the second quarter of 2024. The cost of funds declined 
      51 basis points compared to the same quarterly period last year, due to 
      the repricing of interest-bearing liabilities in a lower-cost interest 
      rate environment, while yields on earning assets declined by 16 basis 
      points. The net interest margin improved to 2.65% for the six months 
      ended June 30, 2025, compared to 2.34% for the same period of 2024 as the 
      cost of funds declined 45 basis points compared to a 10 basis point 
      decline in yields on earning assets. Net interest income rose $0.3 
      million for the quarter compared to the same period of 2024, and $0.6 
      million for the six months ended June 30th compared to the same period of 
      2024. 
 
   -- Although quarter-end loan balances declined $19 million from March 31, 
      2025, and $32 million from December 31, 2024, the allowance for credit 
      losses to loans rose from 1.26% at December 31, 2024, and 1.29% at March 
      31, 2025, to 1.32% at June 30, 2025, primarily due to continued 
      deterioration in the Federal Reserve's economic forecasts used in the 
      Company's credit loss analysis. Non-performing assets to total assets 
      were 0.68% and non-accrual loans to loans were 0.85% on June 30, 2025, 
      compared to 0.67% and 0.84% on March 31, 2025, and 0.68% and 0.81% on 
      December 31, 2024, respectively. Business plans continue to include 
      higher loan balances by year-end 2025, primarily driven by anticipated 
      growth in the commercial segments. Non-performing loans, other real 
      estate loans, modified loans to borrowers experiencing financial 
      difficulty and loans 90 days or more past due but still accruing to total 
      assets increased to 1.85% at June 30, 2025, compared to 0.97% at March 
      31, 2025, and 0.98% at December 31, 2024. The increase was primarily due 
      to two commercial loans--one in the transportation industry and the other 
      in manufacturing--that were both 90 days or more past due but still 
      accruing interest and in the collection process. Since June 30, 2025, one 
      of the loans has been brought current and the adjusted ratio would be 
      1.43%. 
   -- The Banking Division reported net income of $1.6 million for the six 
      months ended June 30, 2025, a $0.4 million improvement over the same 
      period in 2024 excluding the sale-leaseback transaction gain on sale, 
      driven primarily by higher net interest margins and continued cost 
      controls. The Mortgage Division's $0.1 million net loss for the six 
      months ended June 30, 2025, is an improvement of $0.1 million from the 
      prior year. This modest progress reflects the decline in lending staff 
      noted in the first-quarter earnings release. The net remaining Other 
      Division, comprised primarily of parent company operations, had a net 
      loss of $0.5 million with roughly one-third of that amount attributed to 
      subordinated debt interest expense. Although the parent company has a $2 
      million line of credit, no draws have been made on that potential funding 
      source to date. 

Mr. J. Brian Chaffin, CIB Marine's President and CEO, commented, "Net interest margins continue to improve as we actively manage our cost of funds in a lower rate environment compared to last year. This contributed to stronger operating results from our Banking Division. While loan balances declined again, our commercial group continues to build the loan pipeline, and we anticipate higher balances by year-end. The Mortgage Division showed modest improvement despite ongoing challenges in the residential mortgage market. Although mortgage production is expected to be lower than last year due to lender staff reductions, our current team is well-positioned to maintain consistent performance in a competitive market. Expense controls continue to support improved operating results."

He added, "In February, we launched our 2025 common stock repurchase program, authorizing up to $1 million in share buybacks. During the second quarter of 2025, we repurchased 8,083 shares through open market transactions for a total of $262,000, at an average price of $32.37 per share. Year to date, we have repurchased 15,512 shares for a total of $497,000, at an average price of $32.02 per share. Barring unforeseen factors, we intend to complete our 2025 common stock repurchase program during the second half of the year, using available resources including $0.7 million in cash on hand at the parent company, our $2 million line of credit, and other potential sources such as a possible capital distribution from CIBM Bank."

CIB Marine Bancshares, Inc. is the holding company for CIBM Bank, which operates nine banking offices in Illinois, Wisconsin, and Indiana, and has mortgage loan officers and/or offices in six states. More information on the Company is available at www.cibmarine.com, including recent shareholder letters, links to regulatory financial reports, and audited financial statements.

FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS

CIB Marine has made statements in this release that may constitute "forward-looking statements" within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. CIB Marine intends these forward-looking statements to be subject to the safe harbor created thereby and is including this statement to avail itself of the safe harbor. Forward-looking statements are identified generally by statements containing words and phrases such as "may," "project," "are confident," "should be," "intend," "predict," "believe," "plan," "expect, " "estimate," "anticipate" and similar expressions. These forward-looking statements reflect CIB Marine's current views with respect to future events and financial performance that are subject to many uncertainties and factors relating to CIB Marine's operations and the business environment, which could change at any time.

There are inherent difficulties in predicting factors that may affect the accuracy of forward-looking statements.

Stockholders should note that many factors, some of which are discussed elsewhere in this Earnings Release and in the documents that are incorporated by reference, could affect the future financial results of CIB Marine and could cause those results to differ materially from those expressed in forward-looking statements contained or incorporated by reference in this document. These factors, many of which are beyond CIB Marine's control, include but are not limited to:

   -- operating, legal, execution, credit, market, security (including cyber), 
      and regulatory risks; 
 
   -- economic, political, and competitive forces affecting CIB Marine's 
      banking business; 
 
   -- the impact on net interest income and securities values from changes in 
      monetary policy and general economic and political conditions; and 
 
   -- the risk that CIB Marine's analyses of these risks and forces could be 
      incorrect and/or that the strategies developed to address them could be 
      unsuccessful. 

These factors should be considered in evaluating the forward-looking statements, and undue reliance should not be placed on such statements. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made. CIB Marine undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events, or otherwise. Forward-looking statements are subject to significant risks and uncertainties and CIB Marine's actual results may differ materially from the results discussed in forward-looking statements.

FOR INFORMATION CONTACT:

J. Brian Chaffin, President & CEO

(217) 355-0900

brian.chaffin@cibmbank.com

 
                                                       CIB MARINE BANCSHARES, INC. 
                                             Selected Unaudited Consolidated Financial Data 
 
                                                                           At or for the 
                           -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 
                                                           Quarters Ended                                          6 Months Ended 
                           ------------------------------------------------------------------------------  ------------------------------ 
                              June 30,       March 31,      December 31,   September 30,      June 30,        June 30,        June 30, 
                              2025            2025            2024            2024            2024            2025            2024 
                                                         (Dollars in thousands, except share and per share 
                                                                                data) 
Selected Statement of 
Operations Data: 
Interest and dividend 
 income                    $   11,017      $   10,941      $   11,408      $   12,283      $   12,052      $   21,958      $   23,853 
Interest expense                5,541           5,652           6,259           6,707           6,897          11,193          13,737 
                            ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       --------- 
  Net interest income           5,476           5,289           5,149           5,576           5,155          10,765          10,116 
Provision for (reversal 
 of) credit losses                  9              42            (332)           (113)             10              51             (18) 
                            ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       --------- 
  Net interest income 
  after provision for 
    (reversal of) credit 
     losses                     5,467           5,247           5,481           5,689           5,145          10,714          10,134 
Noninterest income (1)          1,765           1,552           1,724           2,897           6,904           3,317           8,531 
Noninterest expense             6,311           6,373           6,678           7,163           6,904          12,684          13,325 
                            ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       --------- 
  Income before income 
   taxes                          921             426             527           1,423           5,145           1,347           5,340 
Income tax expense                253             105             123             347           1,361             358           1,378 
                            ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       ---------       --------- 
  Net income (loss)        $      668      $      321      $      404      $    1,076      $    3,784      $      989      $    3,962 
                            =========       =========       =========       =========       =========       =========       ========= 
 
Common Share Data: 
  Basic net income (loss) 
   per share (2)           $     0.50      $     0.24      $     0.60      $     0.79      $     2.79      $     0.74      $     2.94 
  Diluted net income 
   (loss) per share (2)          0.48            0.23            0.54            0.59            2.06            0.71            2.17 
  Dividend                       0.00            0.00            0.00            0.00            0.00            0.00            0.00 
  Tangible book value per 
   share (3)                    59.55           58.46           57.37           57.80           55.36           59.55           55.36 
  Book value per share 
   (3)                          59.59           58.51           57.42           56.06           53.61           59.59           53.61 
  Weighted average shares 
   outstanding - basic      1,349,613       1,348,995       1,357,737       1,357,259       1,356,255       1,344,573       1,348,440 
  Weighted average shares 
   outstanding - diluted    1,397,365       1,396,274       1,507,344       1,833,586       1,833,881       1,392,090       1,826,911 
Financial Condition Data: 
  Total assets             $  838,441      $  852,018      $  866,474      $  888,283      $  901,634      $  838,441      $  901,634 
  Loans                       665,393         684,787         697,093         707,310         719,129         665,393         719,129 
  Allowance for credit 
   losses on loans             (8,793)         (8,818)         (8,790)         (8,973)         (9,083)         (8,793)         (9,083) 
  Investment securities       126,795         124,109         120,339         120,349         123,814         126,795         123,814 
  Deposits                    684,480         692,028         692,378         747,168         768,984         684,480         768,984 
  Borrowings                   59,292          67,214          81,735          33,583          28,222          59,292          28,222 
  Stockholders' equity         80,492          79,309          77,961          92,358          89,008          80,492          89,008 
Financial Ratios and 
Other Data: 
  Performance Ratios: 
    Net interest margin 
     (4)                         2.69%           2.62%           2.44%           2.55%           2.38%           2.65%           2.34% 
    Net interest spread 
     (5)                         2.06%           1.99%           1.74%           1.80%           1.71%           2.03%           1.67% 
    Noninterest income to 
     average assets (6)          0.83%           0.73%           0.82%           1.25%           3.09%           0.78%           1.91% 
    Noninterest expense 
     to average assets           3.00%           3.05%           3.06%           3.17%           3.09%           3.02%           2.98% 
    Efficiency ratio (7)        87.24%          93.65%          96.17%          85.32%          57.19%          90.35%          71.34% 
    Earnings (loss) on 
     average assets (8)          0.32%           0.15%           0.19%           0.48%           1.69%           0.24%           0.88% 
    Earnings (loss) on 
     average equity (9)          3.36%           1.65%           1.94%           4.71%          17.92%           2.52%           9.38% 
Asset Quality Ratios: 
  Nonaccrual loans to 
   loans (10)                    0.85%           0.84%           0.81%           0.44%           0.47%           0.85%           0.47% 
  Nonperformance assets 
   to total assets (11)          0.68%           0.67%           0.68%           0.38%           0.41%           0.68%           0.41% 
  Nonaccrual loans, 
  modified loans to 
  borrowers experiencing 
    financial difficulty, 
    loans 90 days or more 
    past due and still 
    accruing to total 
     loans (12)                  2.33%           1.21%           1.19%           1.62%           1.38%           2.33%           1.38% 
  Nonaccrual loans, OREO, 
  modified loans to 
  borrowers 
    experiencing 
    financial difficulty, 
    loans 90 days or more 
    past 
    due and still 
     accruing to total 
     assets (12)                 1.85%           0.97%           0.98%           1.32%           1.14%           1.85%           1.14% 
  Allowance for credit 
   losses on loans to 
   total loans (10)              1.32%           1.29%           1.26%           1.27%           1.26%           1.32%           1.26% 
  Allowance for credit 
  losses on loans to 
  nonaccrual loans, 
    modified loans to 
    borrowers 
    experiencing 
    financial difficulty 
    loans 
    and loans 90 days or 
     more past due and 
     still accruing (10)        56.76%         106.25%         105.95%          82.53%          91.24%          56.76%          91.24% 
  Net charge-offs 
  (recoveries) 
  annualized 
    to average loans (10)       -0.02%          -0.01%          -0.01%          -0.01%           0.03%          -0.01%           0.03% 
Capital Ratios: 
  Total equity to total 
   assets                        9.60%           9.31%           9.00%          10.40%           9.87%           9.60%           9.87% 
  Total risk-based 
   capital ratio                13.55%          13.34%          13.02%          14.54%          13.90%          13.55%          13.90% 
  Tier 1 risk-based 
   capital ratio                10.82%          10.62%          10.33%          11.89%          11.27%          10.82%          11.27% 
  Leverage capital ratio         8.54%           8.40%           8.14%           9.30%           8.93%           8.54%           8.93% 
Other Data: 
  Number of employees 
   (full-time 
   equivalent)                    144             152             165             170             172             144             172 
  Number of banking 
   facilities                       9               9               9               9               9               9               9 
 
(1) Noninterest income includes gains and losses on 
 securities. 
(2) Net income available to common stockholders in 
 the calculation of earnings per share includes the 
 difference between the carrying amount less the consideration 
 paid for redeemed preferred stock of $0.4 million 
 for the quarter ended December 31, 2024. 
(3) Tangible book value per share is the stockholder 
 equity less the carry value of the preferred stock 
 and less the goodwill and intangible assets, divided 
 by the total shares of common outstanding. Book value 
 per share is the stockholder equity less the liquidation 
 preference of the preferred stock, divided by the 
 total shares of common outstanding. Book value measures 
 are reported inclusive of the net deferred tax assets. 
 As presented here, shares of common outstanding excludes 
 unvested restricted stock awards. 
(4) Net interest margin is the ratio of net interest 
 income to average interest-earning assets. 
(5) Net interest spread is the yield on average interest-earning 
 assets less the rate on average interest-bearing liabilities. 
(6) Noninterest income to average assets excludes 
 gains and losses on securities. 
(7) The efficiency ratio is noninterest expense divided 
 by the sum of net interest income plus noninterest 
 income, excluding gains and losses on securities. 
(8) Earnings on average assets are net income divided 
 by average total assets. 
(9) Earnings on average equity are net income divided 
 by average stockholders' equity. 
(10) Excludes loans held for sale. 
(11) Nonperforming assets includes nonaccrual loans 
 and securities and other real estate owned. 
(12) A large loan 90 days or more past due and still 
 accruing was brought current after June 30, 2025. 
 The adjusted ratio to total loans would be 1.80% and 
 to total assets 1.43%. 
 
 
                          CIB MARINE BANCSHARES, INC. 
                    Consolidated Balance Sheets (unaudited) 
 
                                              December   September 
                        June 30,   March 31,     31,        30,       June 30, 
                          2025       2025       2024        2024        2024 
                                 (Dollars in Thousands, Except Shares) 
Assets 
Cash and due from 
 banks                  $ 10,363   $  7,717   $  6,748   $  13,814   $  10,690 
Reverse repurchase 
agreements                     -          -          -           -           - 
Securities available 
 for sale                124,618    121,939    118,206     118,145     121,687 
Equity securities at 
 fair value                2,177      2,170      2,133       2,204       2,127 
Loans held for sale        7,733      7,685     13,291      19,472      17,897 
 
Loans                    665,393    684,787    697,093     707,310     719,129 
Allowance for credit 
 losses on loans          (8,793)    (8,818)    (8,790)     (8,973)     (9,083) 
                         -------    -------    -------    --------    -------- 
  Net loans              656,600    675,969    688,303     698,337     710,046 
 
Federal Home Loan Bank 
 Stock                     3,401      2,607      2,607       2,238       2,238 
Premises and 
 equipment, net            1,660      1,486      1,570       1,526       1,569 
Accrued interest 
 receivable                2,733      2,680      2,651       2,926       3,230 
Deferred tax assets, 
 net                      12,160     12,529     12,955      12,796      14,840 
Other real estate 
 owned, net                    -          -        200         211         283 
Bank owned life 
 insurance                 6,536      6,486      6,437       6,388       6,340 
Goodwill and other 
 intangible assets            64         64         64          64          64 
Other assets              10,396     10,686     11,309      10,162      10,623 
    Total assets        $838,441   $852,018   $866,474   $ 888,283   $ 901,634 
                         =======    =======    =======    ========    ======== 
 
Liabilities and 
Stockholders' Equity 
Deposits: 
  Noninterest-bearing 
   demand               $ 87,479   $ 98,403   $ 86,886   $  95,471   $  95,457 
  Interest-bearing 
   demand                 74,921     77,620     84,833      90,095      86,728 
  Savings                226,663    232,046    224,960     234,969     244,595 
  Time                   295,417    283,959    295,699     326,633     342,204 
                         -------    -------    -------    --------    -------- 
    Total deposits       684,480    692,028    692,378     747,168     768,984 
Short-term borrowings     49,514     57,444     71,973      23,829      18,477 
Long-term borrowings       9,778      9,770      9,762       9,754       9,745 
Accrued interest 
 payable                   1,656      1,614      1,911       2,101       2,145 
Other liabilities         12,521     11,853     12,489      13,073      13,275 
                         -------    -------    -------    --------    -------- 
    Total liabilities    757,949    772,709    788,513     795,925     812,626 
 
Stockholders' Equity 
Preferred stock, $1 
 par value; 5,000,000 
 authorized shares at 
 periods prior to 
 December 31, 2024; 7% 
 fixed rate 
 noncumulative 
 perpetual issued; 
 14,633 shares of 
 series A and 1,610 
 shares of series B; 
 convertible; $16.2 
 million aggregate 
 liquidation 
 preference                    -          -          -      13,806      13,806 
Common stock, $1 par 
 value; 75,000,000 
 authorized shares; 
 1,385,842 and 
 1,372,642 issued 
 shares; 1,351,397 and 
 1,358,473 outstanding 
 shares at June 30, 
 2025 and December 31, 
 2024, respectively 
 (1)                       1,386      1,383      1,372       1,372       1,372 
Capital surplus          181,908    181,801    181,708     181,603     181,486 
Accumulated deficit      (98,498)   (99,167)   (99,487)   (100,297)   (101,373) 
Accumulated other 
 comprehensive income 
 (loss), net              (3,273)    (3,939)    (5,098)     (3,592)     (5,749) 
Treasury stock, 35,167 
 shares on June 30, 
 2025 and 14,791 
 shares December 31, 
 2024 (2)                 (1,031)      (769)      (534)       (534)       (534) 
                         -------    -------    -------    --------    -------- 
    Total 
     stockholders' 
     equity               80,492     79,309     77,961      92,358      89,008 
    Total liabilities 
     and stockholders' 
     equity             $838,441   $852,018   $866,474   $ 888,283   $ 901,634 
                         =======    =======    =======    ========    ======== 
 
(1) Both issued and outstanding shares as stated here 
 exclude 46,686 shares and 42,259 shares of unvested 
 restricted stock awards at June 30, 2025 and December 
 31, 2024, respectively. 
(2) Treasury stock includes 722 shares held by subsidiary 
 bank CIBM Bank. 
 
 
 
                                 CIB MARINE BANCSHARES, INC. 
                      Consolidated Statements of Operations (Unaudited) 
 
                                                   At or for the 
                      ----------------------------------------------------------------------- 
                                        Quarters Ended                       6 Months Ended 
                      ---------------------------------------------------  ------------------ 
                                 March    December   September 
                      June 30,    31,       31,         30,      June 30,  June 30,  June 30, 
                        2025      2025      2024         2024      2024      2025      2024 
                                              (Dollars in thousands) 
 
Interest Income 
Loans                 $ 9,653   $ 9,623   $ 9,999    $  10,573   $10,582   $19,276   $20,976 
Loans held for sale       149       137       215          300       213       286       355 
Securities              1,186     1,150     1,151        1,183     1,217     2,336     2,448 
Other investments          29        31        43          227        40        60        74 
    Total interest 
     income            11,017    10,941    11,408       12,283    12,052    21,958    23,853 
 
Interest Expense 
Deposits                4,795     5,029     5,638        6,354     6,466     9,824    12,693 
Short-term 
 borrowings               625       504       500          232       310     1,129       803 
Long-term borrowings      121       119       121          121       121       240       241 
    Total interest 
     expense            5,541     5,652     6,259        6,707     6,897    11,193    13,737 
                       ------    ------    ------       ------    ------    ------    ------ 
    Net interest 
     income             5,476     5,289     5,149        5,576     5,155    10,765    10,116 
Provision for 
 (reversal of) 
 credit losses              9        42      (332)        (113)       10        51       (18) 
                       ------    ------    ------       ------    ------    ------    ------ 
    Net interest 
    income after 
    provision for 
     (reversal of) 
      credit losses     5,467     5,247     5,481        5,689     5,145    10,714    10,134 
 
Noninterest Income 
Deposit service 
 charges                   65        59        55           63        67       124       133 
Other service fees        (10)       (9)       (5)          (5)        1       (19)       (4) 
Mortgage banking 
 revenue, net           1,424     1,140     1,564        2,264     2,166     2,564     3,375 
Other income              279       177       192          150       273       456       436 
Net gains on sale of 
 securities 
 available for sale         0         0         0            0         0         0         0 
Unrealized gains 
 (losses) recognized 
 on equity 
 securities                 7        36       (71)          78       (14)       43       (32) 
Net gains (loss) on 
 sale of SBA loans          0       161         0          420         0       161       202 
Net gains on sale of 
 assets and 
 (writedowns)               0       (12)      (11)         (73)    4,411       (12)    4,421 
    Total 
     noninterest 
     income             1,765     1,552     1,724        2,897     6,904     3,317     8,531 
 
Noninterest Expense 
Compensation and 
 employee benefits      4,060     4,066     4,344        4,852     4,700     8,126     8,989 
Equipment                 583       559       467          504       457     1,142       919 
Occupancy and 
 premises                 519       549       500          495       391     1,068       827 
Data Processing           212       221       220          243       208       433       420 
Federal deposit 
 insurance                101       129       144          182       219       230       418 
Professional 
 services                 218       278       240          254       219       496       418 
Telephone and data 
 communication             57        52        74           51        51       109       107 
Insurance                  75        64        71           78        80       139       161 
Other expense             486       455       618          504       579       941     1,066 
    Total 
     noninterest 
     expense            6,311     6,373     6,678        7,163     6,904    12,684    13,325 
                       ------    ------    ------       ------    ------    ------    ------ 
Income from 
operations 
  before income 
   taxes                  921       426       527        1,423     5,145     1,347     5,340 
Income tax expense        253       105       123          347     1,361       358     1,378 
    Net income 
     (loss)               668       321       404        1,076     3,784       989     3,962 
Preferred stock 
 dividend                   0         0         0            0         0         0         0 
Discount from 
 repurchase of 
 preferred stock            0         0       406            0         0         0         0 
                       ------    ------    ------       ------    ------    ------    ------ 
     Net income 
     (loss) 
     allocated to 
       common 
        stockholders  $   668   $   321   $   810    $   1,076   $ 3,784   $   989   $ 3,962 
                       ======    ======    ======       ======    ======    ======    ====== 
 
 

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

July 11, 2025 05:57 ET (09:57 GMT)

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment