Stu Peltz and Ellen Welch liked their vacation home in Barefoot Beach, Fla., well enough. But soon after buying it for $5.3 million in 2018, the couple began to wonder what it might be like to instead live down the street, right on the water.
The couple, then living in New Jersey, paid $19.1 million for three lots surrounded by private gardens in 2020 and 2022, property records show. Construction began in 2023, and they finished building a roughly 13,261-square-foot home with expansive windows this summer.
Now, the couple is listing the 0.5-acre property, which comes with a boat slip, for $64 million because of health reasons, Peltz said. If it sells for close to that amount, the home would set a record for the neighborhood, about 15 miles north of Naples, where the most expensive sale was roughly $16.1 million for a renovated, older home.
Peltz, a scientist, founded New Jersey-based biopharmaceutical company PTC Therapeutics in 1998. He was CEO for 25 years before stepping down in 2023. Welch was the company's chief science officer until 2023.
"There was a cause as well as a mission" associated with the business, which developed drugs for rare diseases, Peltz said. For 25 years, he said, they focused on building the company, taking off only around Christmas and New Year's.
The main house has five bedrooms, plus two guest suites in a separate wing that is connected by an art gallery. Peltz said he and Welch love art and viewed the home not just as a building but as an art project.
Since they lived nearby, Welch visited the construction site daily. Nothing deterred them because in drug development, she said, they were used to solving problems. (They sold their original home for $7.25 million in 2025.)
The pair wanted to make every floor usable, including the rooftop, where they built a 36-foot lap pool and an indoor-outdoor cabana. "A lot of people make these little dipping pools," Welch said. "Stu is a swimmer." The day the 5-ton pool was installed, a crowd gathered on the beach to watch a crane hoist it into place, she said.
Peltz declined to say how much they invested in the home. He said they were planning to stay in the area.
Barefoot Beach is a gated community with a private beach, where the most expensive home sales have been in the high teens.
A new-construction home of this size in Barefoot Beach is a rare find, said Ashley Baird Fenttiman of Coldwell Banker Realty, who has the listing with colleagues Dawn McKenna and Kathleen Thanas.
Peltz and Welch were among the first to create an assemblage of waterfront lots in the neighborhood, said the agents, who added that the market is appreciating amid a broader influx of wealth to South Florida.
Comments