Revisiting former stock picks is less about nostalgia than accountability. Markets shift and theses age. The gap between what looked right then and what actually happened is where the real lessons sit, separating sound reasoning from lucky timing so we can refine what we do next.
In this update, we revisit the following former stock picks and examine how they performed:
Frontline, introduced by Todd Chanko in October.
OneSpaWorld Holdings, covered by Dan Victor in October.
Reddit, reviewed by Angela Palumbo in July.
This note revisits former stock picks from a technical perspective, focusing on those that favor buying opportunities. Read the last edition here.
Frontline
The shipping company's stock has more than doubled over the past year and pays a dividend yield more than 12%. The stock now trades 27% below its 52-week high, set just one month ago, creating a buying opportunity. Frontline is down 17% since our recommendation.
Looking at the daily chart, momentum flashed an early warning with bearish RSI divergence in September and October when a lower oscillator peak registered well above the overbought 70 threshold against higher price highs. Round number theory has played an important role with a reversal at the $60 handle, triggering a swift drawdown punctuated by a bearish engulfing candle on Oct. 14.
That rejection initiated the development of a potential double-bottom base, with corrective price action now nearing the $40 level and its rising 200-day simple moving average. This $40 zone carries substantial price memory. It served as the site of a bullish ascending triangle breakout in late June that initially evolved into a bull trap with a June 24 bearish engulfing candle, resolving a pattern that originally originated with a March 2 hanging man reversal.
The stock could be bottoming, allowing for an entry here. Frontline could reach $75 by the second half of 2027, representing a 70% gain from current prices. Remain bullish above $39. Frontline was trading around $45.50 Wednesday.
OneSpaWorld Holdings
The company, which operates spas, fitness centers and wellness facilities on cruise ships, is up 36% over the past month. The stock trades just 3% below its recent 52 week high and is looking to extend its current eight week win streak. It is up 32% since our recommendation.
Looking at the daily chart, the ratio chart against the SPDR S&P Retail ETF demonstrates strength, opening 2026 in a resilient relative uptrend before regaining positive momentum in September. Absolute price action has been firm with the recent low marked by a bullish hammer on Sept. 3 successfully retesting a prior breakout above the $22.50 bullish inverse head-and-shoulders neckline from April.
That defense laid the foundation for the start of a double bottom base that originated with a June 25 bearish shooting star. The stock decisively cleared its $27.18 double-bottom trigger on Oct. 28 via an explosive 12.5% single-session gain. While a bearish death cross materialized in mid-October, persistent accumulation promptly generated an offsetting bullish golden cross last week. Furthermore, buying pressure was evident at the $30 handle, shrugging off doji candles printed on Oct. 30 and Nov. 3.
Enter on a pullback near $31 and the stock could reach $40 by mid-2027, a 25% gain from current prices. Remain bullish above $29. OneSpaWorld Holdings was trading around $31 Wednesday.
The social-media platform trades 63% below its 52-week high after delivering its second straight 20% plus negative earnings reaction on Oct. 30 to fall under the very round $100 mark. The good news is the stock isn't following through lower after a historic 36% drop two weeks ago. The stock is down 45% since our recommendation.
Looking at the daily chart, relative performance against the State Street Communication Services Select Sector SPDR Fund reflects persistent underperformance since July. Absolute price action deteriorated in tandem, decisively breaking below a multi-month cup-with-handle base and starting a drawdown that saw the stock decline 10 of the last 17 weeks. As a consequence of this extended liquidation, price action remains deeply compressed beneath both its downward-sloping 50-day and 200-day SMAs.
Despite this technical overhang, bottoming candles are being registered, evidenced by back-to-back bullish morning star formations alongside doji candles recorded in two of the last three sessions. The stock is now set to potentially fill the upside gap from the Oct. 29 session near $132 by the end of the first quarter, representing a 33% gain from current prices. Remain bullish above $91. Reddit was trading around $105 Wednesday.
Doug Busch is the senior technical analyst at Barron's Investor Circle. His technical view is added to stock picks, including those published exclusively for Investor Circle readers. A glossary of technical terms is updated regularly with new entries.
Join us for the next live Q&A: Hear from our stock pickers and technical analyst as we discuss the latest market developments -- and take your questions. Register here
Share your questions and thoughts in the "Conversation" section below to engage directly with the author and our community
Receive alerts about more content from this author by clicking "Follow" next to the author byline at top
Comments