McCormick's Food Deal with Unilever Puts Sauce Mixes Under Threat, U.K. Says

Dow Jones11-12

The planned megadeal between spice giant McCormick & Co. and the food business of consumer goods maker Unilever threatens competition, especially in the dry sauce mix aisle of the grocery store, according to the U.K.'s competition regulator, which has given them a week to explain how they will handle that.

Shares of both companies were falling on Wednesday trading after the Competition & Markets Authority said the merger could result "in a substantial lessening of competition within a market or markets in the United Kingdom."

McCormick's shares were down 0.7% at $46.40. American depositary receipts of Unilever PLC, a London-based British consumer packaged goods company, were down 1.2% at $65.69. Unilever PLC stock was down 0.5% at 4,916.00 British pence, or about $65.25 in U.S. dollars.

McCormick, the maker and distributor of herbs, spices, seasonings, condiments, and other flavors for the food and beverage industry, announced on March 31 that it was merging with Unilever PLC's global food business to create a food giant with annual revenue of $20 billion. Combined, the company would be valued at $65 billion including debt.

The CMA said McCormick's acquisition of substantially all of Unilever's food business, including products under the Knorr, Maille, and Colman's brands, could reduce competition in the supply of dry ingredient mixes and the supply of dry sauces to U.K. retailers.

Because of limited shelf space in supermarkets and the well-established position of existing suppliers, "it is difficult to enter and/or expand in dry ingredient mixes and dry sauces," the regulator said.

"This is an expected step in the regulatory process, and we are working constructively with the CMA on a suitable remedy," a Unilever spokesperson told Barron's. The company said in August it would sell the Colman's brand mustard and assets "to proactively address potential competition concerns. Discussions with potential buyers are progressing well."

A McCormick spokesperson said: "This is an expected step in the regulatory process, and we are working constructively with the CMA. More broadly, we continue to make good progress on regulatory approvals globally, reinforcing our confidence in a timely closing."

The CMA also looked into the merger's potential competitive effects in the mustard market, where McCormick makes American-style mustard under the French's brand and Unilever offers English-style mustard under the Colman's brand and French-style mustard under the Maille brand.

This was less of an issue, CMA found. "Evidence from large supermarkets indicated that end-consumers typically do not consider English, French and American style mustard to be suitable alternatives to one another, and as a result, it is important for supermarkets to stock each of the different types of mustard," the CMA wrote.

The two companies have until Nov. 18 to offer measures to "remedy the competition concerns identified." If they don't, the CMA will refer the merger for an in-depth, phase 2 investigation.

Separately, Deutsche Bank AG research analysts led by Tom Sykes, who have a Buy rating on Unilever PLC stock, raised their price target to 5,350 British pence (about $71.05 in U.S. currency), from 5,300 pence previously (about $70.38).

News of the merger sent McCormick's shares down 6.1% that day, while Unilever's American depositary receipts fell 5%. While the deal appeared to be a good strategic fit for both companies, investors may have been anxious about how the transaction was structured and whether the post-transaction ownership makes sense.

McCormick is putting up $29.1 billion in stock and $15.7 billion in cash, and will own 35% of the combined company that includes Unilever's signature food brands such as Hellmann's mayonnaise and Knorr soup mixes.

On top of the $15.7 billion in cash, Unilever will receive shares equating to 65% of the new entity, with 55.1% going to its shareholders and 9.9% to the company itself.

 

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment