The first small nuclear reactor to start construction in North America is facing delays and cost overruns, an ominous sign for the nuclear renaissance.
GE Vernova Hitachi's small reactor in Ontario, Canada is expected to go over its original cost target and probably won't be ready by October 2030, the month when it was expected to start operating, according to the Ontario Power Generation, a state-run power company.
That's bad news for the dozens of companies building the next generation of nuclear reactors, such as Oklo, X-Energy and NuScale Power.
While those companies use different technology than the GE Vernova Hitachi joint venture, they tend to trade based on the ups and downs of the entire nuclear industry.
The pitch from these nuclear start-ups -- none of which has built an operating reactor yet -- is that they'll eventually be cheaper and faster to build. That will be a hard case to make if nuclear companies are associated with high power prices and long construction timelines. The stocks have been volatile lately; they were most trading higher on Wednesday on unrelated optimism about the AI buildout.
Ontario Power Generation said on Tuesday that the delays and cost issues were caused by the "ongoing engineering for this first-of-a-kind SMR and the resulting impacts on construction execution and supply chain performance."
This isn't a new issue in nuclear: first-of-their-kind projects tend to take longer than initially expected because all the construction quirks need to be ironed out. A spokesman for GE Vernova said the company is committed to working through any issues affecting the project, which also may include "engineering, procurement and construction, as well as evolving market conditions, including inflation and geopolitical risks."
If the nuclear industry wants buyers to make firm commitments to power contracts, it will have to convince them that these issues can be worked out.
Even before the latest revelations, estimates for the GE Vernova Hitachi reactor were already quite pricey compared with other power sources.
The first 300-megawatt unit was expected to cost 7.7 billion Canadian dollars, or about $5.4 billion. About 80% of that, or $4.3 billion, was for the unit itself, while the rest was for shared infrastructure that will also be used by three other reactors that are expected to be built on site.
Just including that one unit's expenses, the reactor was set to cost over $14,000 per kilowatt. Compare that to the current cost of a new natural gas plant, at roughly $2,500 per kilowatt.
Nuclear has several attributes that make it better than natural gas: the plants are more efficient and don't cause carbon emissions for instance. But to get buyers interested, they'll also have to believe that nuclear can be cost-competitive too.
Comments