Alphabet and Apple have approached AI in ways that have resonated on Wall Street
Even amid recent pressure, Alphabet, led by Sundar Pichai, has been the best performer among the "Magnificent Seven" stocks since the start of 2025.
Most "Magnificent Seven" stocks have struggled to beat the broader market since the start of last year, as investors have gotten choosier about the technology sector.
Alphabet (GOOGL) and Apple (AAPL) are the only two companies within the Magnificent Seven group of megacap tech names that have outperformed the S&P 500 SPX over that span, which analysts attribute to the strategic ways they've approached artificial-intelligence integration.
Alphabet's stock has returned 50.8% since the beginning of 2025, while Apple shares have returned 42%. The rest of the group - Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla - underperformed the S&P 500, which saw a 29% return.
The dynamic was pointed out on Monday in an X post from Charlie Bilello, chief market strategist at financial planning company Creative Planning.
The market is "picking AI winners," Morningstar's William Kerwin told MarketWatch. Google has emerged as a favored choice among investors in part due to the company's tensor processing units, which he said rival Nvidia's (NVDA) chips. Additionally, the company's frontier AI model, Gemini, rivals those made by OpenAI and Anthropic, he believes.
Apple, meanwhile, doesn't have its own AI models, but the company has found ways to deploy AI "as a means to the end of better user experience," he said. The company has struck partnerships while spending notably less than peers on AI development.
On the flip side, Microsoft (MSFT), Amazon (AMZN) and Meta (META) are "getting punished" for their heavy spending on AI infrastructure, he said.
See also: Jensen Huang built Nvidia into a behemoth. His resignation puts the entire AI boom in jeopardy.
Apple has made a "wise decision to not play the same game as some of the other Mag Seven companies," Ben Carew, co-chief investment officer at Tandem Investment Advisors, told MarketWatch. He pointed out that others within the group are spending "enormous" amounts of cash on the AI race, which may be seen as "less rewarding."
MoffettNathanson analyst Craig Moffett told MarketWatch that Apple's appeal is "precisely its lack of correlation" to the broader AI trade.
When investors get nervous about whether major rivals will be able to show returns on their infrastructure spending, they "retreat to Apple as the 'safe' alternative," he said.
The company isn't without its share of challenges. Moffett thinks Apple's iPhone 18 cycle is "falling well short" compared with the iPhone 17 cycle last year. And there's risk that AI agents could "bypass Apple" and reduce the company's control over its systems, he said.
Since the start of 2025, Alphabet has benefited from a "sharp reversal" in sentiment among investors, with Carew noting that the company has positioned itself as an "AI contender" thanks partly to its TPU business, which he said has "arguably cut into the market share and dominance of Nvidia in the chip market."
That said, the recent performance of Apple and Alphabet shares has been divergent. Apple shares are down less than 2% from their closing high achieved last week, while Alphabet shares are off some 30% from their peak close reached in May.
-Hannah Pedone
Comments