U.K. Prime Minister Andy Burnham is resurrecting the ghost of Brexit.
Six years after the U.K.'s acrimonious and chaotic break with the European Union, Burnham wants the country to consider a major U-turn and rejoin the trade bloc to bolster the British economy.
On Friday, the Labour Party leader traveled to Brussels to unveil a set of agreements aimed at marking a "reset" in U.K.-EU relations, including scrapping most border checks on food and agricultural products and reintroducing a student-exchange program.
Burnham's visit was aimed at kicking off a wider debate about an issue that has divided British society and dogged politicians for decades: To what extent should the U.K. integrate with its biggest trade partner?
"In a more dangerous world, we are stronger together," Burnham said Friday.
But even those limited deals proved fraught and fell short of expectations, suggesting any further talks aimed at a deeper relationship between both sides will be long and arduous.
While Burnham cast the "reset" deals as done, European negotiators said none of the agreements will be fully implemented unless European students could get lower tuition rates at U.K. universities. Both sides agreed to continue to negotiate student fees over the next six months.
The issue of Europe has finally cooled in British politics after years of heated debate that cut across party and class lines and often divided families. In a 2016 referendum, 52% of the British public voted to leave the EU, leading to a formal departure from the bloc four years later. Now, driven by public disappointment over how Brexit has played out, the government is wondering whether it should re-enter, raising the prospect that Brexit, followed by "Bregret", will lead eventually to "Breturn."
Raising trade barriers has slowed trade growth between both sides, hurting the British economy alongside the pandemic and the war in Ukraine that spiked energy prices. It also backfired spectacularly in immigration, with Britain closing access to European workers but allowing in millions more from the rest of the world.
An average of polls shows that 62% of Brits would like to rejoin the EU, compared with 38% who want to stay out. "The Brexit we were given has not worked," Burnham said in a speech this week. "We have lost more than we have gained." Research by Goldman Sachs suggests that rejoining the EU's single market would bolster the U.K. economy by between 2% and 5%.
Rejoining, though, would be a long and possibly costly process. The prospect will reopen a painful debate, including among working-class voters in Burnham's own Labour Party. There is no guarantee that Britain would get the same advantages it had the first time around, including getting to keep its own currency or a discount on membership fees it previously enjoyed. Without those advantages, polls show wavering public support for rejoining.
"There isn't a button you can press to go back to 2016," said Anand Menon, who runs the think tank U.K. in a Changing Europe, noting that Breturn could become politically all-consuming, creating uncertainty that could weigh on the economy in the short term and distract the government from sorting out pressing domestic issues.
"Thinking it's a bad idea you left is not the same as thinking you should join," he added.
Already, the siren call of another argument over Europe has reinvigorated the old Brexit guard. A campaign called "Stay Out" is pumping out content on social media. Burnham "will impale himself and his party on this point, and he needs to move off it because he won't win," said Boris Johnson, a former U.K. prime minister and Brexit cheerleader.
David Cameron, the former prime minister who pledged to end the debate over Europe once and for all by calling the referendum, said the government should focus on other problems plaguing Britain's economy, including ever-higher taxes, spending and debt, a lack of housing and the need to shore up the country's diminished armed forces.
A YouGov survey put rejoining the EU at No. 9 on a list of voter priorities, well behind the economy, immigration and healthcare.
Burnham, who has said he wants Britain to rejoin in his lifetime, said Friday he wants to use the next year for informal discussions with top EU officials over the options available for a new longer-term relationship. It isn't yet clear what those options are, or how Brits would choose -- either through another referendum or as part of the next general election, which could be as late as 2029.
Burnham said Friday that it will be for British voters to decide. He acknowledged that Friday's agreements probably hit the limit of increased cooperation the two sides can achieve before the next election.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, the EU's top official, said she was receptive to brainstorming with the U.K. on the future relationship and hit an optimistic note on Friday.
"We have already achieved a great deal together and as partners, allies and friends, we have every reason to be ambitious about what comes next," she said during a press conference.
Nonetheless, Europe will want to know what exactly Britain is seeking before it enters any serious negotiations. The last thing the trade club needs is Britain yo-yoing in and out depending on the political whim of the day.
"It's not priority No. 1 for the EU and they will want to be convinced that whatever Britain comes up with in terms of proposing a new relationship, it's something that will last," said Rosa Balfour, director of Carnegie Europe.
Most economists agree Brexit has been an economic mistake. But they also point out Britain hasn't taken advantage of it by making its economy much more competitive through steps like deregulation.
In fact, the quest to rejoin may be starting just as Brexit does bear some fruit. The U.K.'s economy has performed better than expected in recent quarters, in part due to what economists say is faster AI adoption. Some fear that signing up to the EU's more stringent AI regulation could snuff out a growth avenue for the country.
On some levels, Britain still needs Europe and vice versa. The war in Ukraine, a flood of cheap Chinese exports and strains with Washington are forcing European capitals to close ranks. Burnham's argument is that Britain will also have to link arms with Europe to contend with this new fractured world order. "We can't ignore this reality, nor the fact that we have a club of democracies on our doorstep which shares so many of our values and our interests," he said recently.
The U.K. isn't alone in debating the EU. Icelanders recently voted narrowly to reject membership negotiations with the bloc. The EU and Switzerland have spent more than a decade renegotiating their relationship, and Swiss voters will hold a referendum on the result. Half a dozen Balkan countries, Ukraine and Moldova have spent years trying to enter.
There is a large menu of options, each with trade-offs. The U.K. could seek to enter a customs union -- free movement for goods and a common external tariff for imports. That would ease two-way trade and allow Britain to keep regulatory control over services. But there would still be some checks on the flow of British goods to the EU's single market.
A bolder step would be to seek access to the single market, like Norway, but it would have to pay into some EU programs and allow workers to move freely as well as accept EU rules without any say in how they are made. The third option -- full EU membership -- would come with higher EU payments and freedom of movement but it would allow Britain to have a vote on the trade bloc's rules.
Meanwhile, new trade divergences are being erected between the EU and the U.K. The bloc's "Made in Europe" plan to force Chinese automakers to produce cars in the EU would also place tariffs on electric-vehicle exports from Britain.
Labour's previous prime minister, Keir Starmer, who brought Labour back into power in 2024, tried to stymie a broader debate over Brexit by barring his party from considering re-entering the EU's customs union, single market or full membership, at least until the next election.
At a minimum, Burnham looks likely to erase those red lines when he fights the next election.
Comments