Federal Reserve officials who held interest rates steady last month thought higher rates would still be needed to bring down inflation, and they were determined that investors not read the pause as a sign their fight was losing steam.
A few officials who supported the decision called it a "close call," according to minutes of the Oct. 27-28 meeting released Wednesday. The written account also revealed a cohort of officials -- not all of whom may have had a vote at the gathering and more than the two who formally dissented -- thought a rate increase was warranted.
"A few of them warned that further delay risked allowing high inflation to become entrenched or necessitating a larger and more disruptive tightening later," the minutes said.
The minutes suggested officials were preoccupied with how the decision would be interpreted. Many officials stressed the importance of making clear that the pause "did not reflect a weakening of the committee's commitment" to bringing inflation down to 2%, the minutes said.
Some of those pushing for an increase went further: They said they could have gone along with holding rates steady, but only if "it was clearly understood by market participants that further tightening was likely."
Chairman Kevin Warsh has tried to steer the Fed away from previewing its next moves. "It's a new chapter at the Fed, and we're not in that business anymore," he said in Bangkok last month. But the minutes suggest some of his colleagues aren't ready to get out of that business entirely, or at a minimum not while they're trying to lean harder on inflation without setting off a market rout. A sharp selloff could force them to pause before inflation is under control, inviting the kind of stop-and-start policy that undermines credibility.
Almost everyone at the meeting thought that, under their most likely scenario for the economy, tighter policy would ultimately be needed, and a few officials warned that inflation might prove more persistent than expected, "in which case a shift to a more restrictive policy stance could become necessary," the minutes said.
Data released since that meeting have tilted the debate in favor of officials who have said the Fed will have to do more to get inflation down. Job growth was solid in October, and underlying inflation was firm for a third straight month. Investors now see a December increase as all but certain, and attention has shifted to how much further the Fed will raise rates next year and how it signals what comes next.
Fed officials' public communications since the meeting have surfaced many of the same concerns that were cited in the minutes, with several hinting that a faster pace of increases or a somewhat longer interval of tightening could be warranted. Fed governor Christopher Waller has gone as far as to suggest a half-point increase in December, particularly if officials aren't prepared to signal that a smaller move would be followed by another early next year. Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan said last week the Fed might not need to stick to raising rates at every other meeting.
Supporters of more aggressive action worry that inflation won't fall without tighter policy. St. Louis Fed President Alberto Musalem said Tuesday that the economy would likely need several interest rate increases before the spring of 2027. He estimated that the Fed's benchmark rate is only about 1 percentage point above inflation, and he suggested it might need to rise to around 2 to 2.5 points above inflation, mostly through higher rates rather than lower inflation.
Others could argue that markets are now doing more of the Fed's work, giving officials room to wait and see next year how much further they need to move. Stocks tied to the AI boom have pulled back, pushing up borrowing costs for some companies building out data centers. Oil prices are falling, and refiners' profit margins are shrinking as supply rises, which could bring some relief on inflation.
Comments