It's not Too Late to Add U.S. Energy Companies to Your 401(k). They've Been Making Out Like Bandits.

Dow Jones01:23

Energy stocks are pretending the war is over. It isn't.

A third U.S. aircraft carrier, the USS Theodore Roosevelt, has arrived in the Middle East.

Nobody knows what's going to happen next in this fiasco of a war in the Persian Gulf. That seemingly includes the commander in chief of the U.S. armed forces and his chest-thumping "secretary of war."

But the arrival of a third U.S. aircraft carrier in the region hardly sounds like the conflict is winding down. And why would the Iranians back down, now that the president's war policy has been so thoroughly repudiated by U.S. voters and even by his own vice president?

But the excellent news for the rest of us is that the world's biggest fund managers are once again heavily underinvested in energy stocks, which suggests it probably isn't too late to add an energy fund to your 401(k) or IRA.

The State Street Energy Select Sector ETF XLE is the simplest, low-cost option. It invests across the sector, but most of the exposure is in huge integrated energy companies such as ExxonMobil and Chevron. It charges just 0.08% in fees. VanEck Oil Refiners CRAK, which charges 0.61%, focuses on companies such as Valero and Marathon that refine crude oil into gasoline. It is very volatile, in both directions.

It's been the position of this column for ages-and well before the outbreak of this "brief excursion" in Iran-that as a long-term position we should all have some energy stocks in our portfolios, alongside the usual stock and bond funds.

If you don't, you risk getting hosed. Like, er, this year.

The United States is a net energy exporter. It has been since 2019. This country produces more energy than it uses, exporting the difference. That is particularly true of energy from fossil fuels, such as oil and natural gas.

U.S. energy production has exceeded U.S. consumption every month this year. Table 1.1 on page three of the U. S. government's Energy Information Administration's October monthly energy review shows that through the first seven months of this year the U.S. produced 63.6 quadrillion BTUs of energy, 14% more than the 56.0 quadrillion BTUs it consumed.

U.S. production of energy from fossil fuels this year exceeds consumption by 16%.

And the U.S. actually produced more energy this year than last, while consuming slightly less.

To be fair, the situation is slightly more complex than that. As the U.S. and foreign oil fields often produce different types of crude oil, the U.S. exports some of what it produces and imports other oil from overseas. But these complexities are more than offset by the broader energy exports.

The bottom line is that the U.S. energy companies are making out like bandits. They have been able to hike domestic gasoline prices by as much as 50% and diesel prices by up to nearly 100%, because the crisis in the Gulf means they face far less competition from international competitors. You can't get cheaper gasoline from overseas because they don't have it. And if you don't pay the new domestic prices, the oil companies know a lot of desperate Frenchmen and Chinese who will.

Net result: Every major U.S. energy company has reported skyrocketing profits, as revenues - thank you, all you hapless motorists at the gas pumps - have soared far more than any underlying costs.

How much? According to the U.S. Commerce Department, in the April to June second quarter last year, the U.S. "petroleum and coal products" industry made profits of $21.1 billion.

In the same quarter of this year, during the Iran War? Try $155.5 billion, or about seven times as much.

Crisis? What crisis?

Back in the olden times, when America wasn't as great as it is now, this sort of thing was frowned upon. Between 1917 and 1953 Congress passed multiple "excess profits taxes" that effectively stopped corporations from making big profits from things like energy shortages during wartime. Such companies were called "war profiteers" and such behavior was known as "gouging."

The last such act was signed into law in 1953 by that infamous communist and peacenik, President Dwight D. Eisenhower.

There is effectively zero chance of anyone passing a windfall or excess profits tax on U.S. energy companies these days.

Even following the sharp sell off in recent weeks, the energy sector has crushed the rest of the market since the outbreak of war. ExxonMobil (XOM) is up 13%, Chevron $(CVX)$ nearly 20%, ConocoPhilips (COP) 40%, and the downstream refiners Valero $(VLO)$ and Marathon (MPC) are up about 80% and 100%, respectively.

Yet today the sector remains inexpensive compared to almost any other sector of the market. According to Yardeni Research the energy sector trades for 12 times forecast per-share earnings, compared to about 18 times for the S&P 500 SPX as a whole.

Sector investing, naturally comes with risk. Energy sector earnings are cyclical. They boom and they can bust. Wall Street analysts are currently expecting energy company earnings will decline, slightly, from insane 2026 levels over the next two years. We shall see.

But if "diversification" is the only free lunch in finance, as investment gurus always tell us, then looks like a very inexpensive meal. Energy is a major diversifier, because it's precisely when energy prices skyrocket that the rest of your portfolio - all those stocks and bonds - tend to tank. That happened in 2022 and it's been happening this year.

Ordinarily, you might figure that you would be exposed to the energy sector through a diversified stock market fund such as the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF SPY. But energy makes up a tiny share of the market now. It's less than 4% of the S&P 500 by value. It simply doesn't compensate enough for when energy costs skyrocket and the rest of your stock portfolio takes it on the chin.

Over the past decade, a portfolio consisting of 80% S&P 500 SPDR ETF and 20% Energy Select Sector XLE (this is an illustration, not a specific recommendation) has produced higher average three- and five-year returns and lower volatility of those returns, according to an analysis via Portfolio Visualizer. Energy stocks tend to underperform when the rest of the market is booming-because cheap energy is one reason the rest of the market booms. But that typically reverses when it goes the other way.

The rationale of this is simply that if you can't beat them, join them. In America today you can't beat the energy companies. On the other hand, thanks to the stock market, you can join them.

-Brett Arends

 

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment