Micron and Sandisk Stocks Might Look Like Bargains, but Analysts Say That's Actually a Red Flag

Dow Jones05:36

Cheap valuation multiples for memory stocks have historically been associated with peak pricing levels, according to analysts

Shares of Micron fell nearly 14% on Friday.

Memory stocks were among the biggest decliners as the technology sector bled red ink on Friday.

Shares of Micron Technology (MU) closed down 14% on Friday, while shares of Sandisk (SNDK) fell 16%. Western Digital's stock (WDC) sank 12%.

The pressure on these stocks is mounting. Micron shares are down 50.99% from their peak, while Sandisk shares are down 72.85% from their highs and Western Digital's stock has shed 64.97%.

The chip sector in general has been hit hard due to various factors. Those include concerns that politicians could get stricter about data-center construction, leadership uncertainty at Nvidia (NVDA) and the idea that Anthropic's (ANT) IPO might have sucked attention away from the broader tech sector.

Then there is the perennial debate over the price-to-earnings multiples of memory stocks.

Micron and Sandisk shares both trade at meaningful discounts to their recent historical valuations. Micron's stock trades at 3.76 times estimated earnings for the next 12 months, versus a two-year average of 9.10 times. Sandisk's multiple of 3.04 times forward earnings expectations is below its 10.47-times average since the time of its separation from Western Digital in February 2025.

But Brendan Burke, the research director for semiconductors, supply chain and emerging tech at the Futurum Group, says that low price-to-earnings ratios for memory stocks are a "warning label, not a bargain sign."

"Investors have learned over decades to sell memory stocks at peak earnings, because the earnings side of that ratio has historically collapsed when the cycle turns," he said.

"A multiple in the low single digits tells you the market is pricing today's profits as a peak," he added.

Admittedly, there are some caveats. The historical precedent "ignores that AI has changed the shape of this cycle." Some types of memory, like high-bandwidth memory and solid-state-drive storage, are tied to what he called "mission-critical data-center buildouts," as opposed to memory for PCs and handsets. That distinction means the earnings might be "more durable than these multiples imply," Burke said.

William Blair analyst Sebastien Naji told MarketWatch that there's a limit to the usefulness of low P/E ratios as a "valuation support metric."

Memory stocks often see "extreme volatility in pricing," CreditSights analyst Andy Li added, and that can lead to boom-and-bust cycles.

If investors assume the market is still cyclical, a "dramatic price decline may well be in the cards," he said. "The price action reflects that fear."

Li explained that cyclical stocks like memory often top with "very low" price-to-earnings multiples, because that's when their estimated earnings for the next 12 months are "most inflated." Meanwhile, they also bottom with relatively high multiples, following the same logic, he said.

Separately, he added that the fact that monthly options expire on Friday could also be a technical factor affecting the stocks.

See also: Jensen Huang was a 'China salesman' for Nvidia. His exit is weighing on Chinese tech stocks.

-Hannah Pedone

 

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment