Concern about financial condition seems to favor a gradual pace of rate hikes
Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh speaks at his press conference in October.
The U.S. stock market plunged this week into correction territory, with the major indexes down more than 10% from recent highs, but don't expect the U.S. central bank to come to the rescue.
Federal Reserve officials will continue to raise interest rates, despite the recent selloff in the stock market, as equity-market gains over the past four years dwarf the recent declines, economists said Friday.
"We would need a much larger retreat in equity values to make a dent in the wealth that has been generated by the stock market over the prior few years," said Avery Shenfeld, chief economist of CIBC Capital Markets.
Scott Anderson, chief U.S. economist at BMO Capital Markets agreed: "People have done so well over the past several years. There is some room for stocks to fall without all consumers stopping spending and air traffic going down."
Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, said most Fed officials are looking through the stock-market volatility.
"Regardless of the fact that financial conditions have tightened, they will still want to signal and implement a tighter monetary stance," Daco said.
The Fed raised rates a quarter-point in September, the first increase in three years, in an effort to battle the persistent upward creep of consumer prices.
Officials made no change to rates in October, in part because the stock market was weak, according to minutes of the Fed meeting released Wednesday. At the same time, almost all Fed officials anticipated further rate hikes.
CIBC's Shenfeld said there are two reasons why stocks would matter for the Fed: if the market falls far enough to cause negative wealth effects, or if the market is a predictor of where the economy is going.
That's less likely to be true after the huge run-up of the past few years, he said.
"At this point, I don't think it is material for them. It can become material, but we're not there yet," Shenfeld added. The S&P 500 SPX is clinging to positive gains in 2026 and has returned 100% over the past four years.
Fed officials are focused on the risks to the economy and markets from a reversal of optimism surrounding AI. Minutes of their October meeting disclosed that officials had lengthy discussions over various scenarios surrounding a possible market selloff.
"They are starting to get serious about what their playbook would be if this would get worse," Anderson said. The biggest worry would be "systemic dislocation" in financial markets, he added.
That might require the Fed to set up special credit lines to inject liquidity into markets, similar to actions taken in the financial crisis of 2008 and the dawn of the COVID pandemic in 2020, Anderson said.
At the moment, the Fed might be breathing "a sigh of relief" over the recent stock-market drop because it is concerned about high stock valuations and related hedge-fund leverage. A modest decline in equities "lets some the air out of the balloon," Anderson said.
Kathy Bostjancic, chief economist at Nationwide Financial, said if the Fed skips a hike in December, they would be accused of putting a floor under stock prices - in other words, "a Fed put" - a charge that has dogged the central bank since the late 1980s.
How bad would the stock-market selloff does have to get before the Fed changes their thinking about interest rates?
Officials will keep an eye on bank distress and distress in the plumbing of financial markets as signs that there may be more trouble lurking, Anderson said.
For now, a hike in December is seen as a done deal given the hot October inflation readings. After that, the future direction of the Fed becomes more of an open question.
Concerns about financial conditions seem to favor a gradual pace of hikes, meaning the Fed pausing at its January meeting and hiking again in March, wrote Michael Gapen, chief U.S. economist at Morgan Stanley, in a note to clients.
Many economist have penciled in a more aggressive rate path, with the Fed hiking three times - in December, January and March, before pausing to assess conditions. Shenfeld said he expects two hikes, one next month and another in January.
"I think they are worried about inflation getting ingrained at 3% as opposed to 2%, which is why they are willing to put a bit of a dent into growth to pull inflation down," Shenfeld said.
A modest slowdown in growth coupled with lower oil prices could take a lot of the wind out of inflation, he added.
Some economists are worried that the Fed will overtighten, and are blinded by concern that they haven't hit their 2% inflation target in almost six years.
"Markets are signaling that the current level of interest rates is unsustainably high," wrote Andrew Hollenhorst, U.S. chief economist at Citi, who is one of the most dovish economists on Wall Street.
A rate hike remains likely early next month, but then the Fed will stay on hold and eventually cut later next year, he said in a note to clients.
-Greg Robb
Comments