The Danger of Jensen Huang's Handshake Deals at Nvidia

Dow Jones18:30

For investors, the most worrisome thing about the entire Jensen Huang scandal isn't the sexiest stuff.

Not the mistresses. Not the suspected Chinese spying. Not the notion of his returning to Nvidia as CEO after he resigned in disgrace.

It's the suggestion that one of the most valuable, most important companies was conducting major deals between suppliers and customers on handshake agreements with Huang -- and not with traditional contracts.

"Jensen drove supply chain brilliantly at Nvidia, but many of those deals were a handshake with Jensen, not a written contract," Elon Musk, a major customer of Nvidia chips through his SpaceX and Tesla businesses, recently posted on X. "Without Jensen, at least some of those critical deals will be lost."

Such comments help explain motivations of the powerful insiders pushing for Huang's return. They aren't only showing loyalty to the man who could once make or break their companies' growth ambitions, they're trying to ensure their special connections can live on.

At stake is nothing short of the U.S. economy, which has seen a massive boost from artificial-intelligence investment with Nvidia's AI chips and Huang's dealmaking at the center. Without Huang's magic to keep it alive, some worry what will happen next. That's why those, such as Musk, President Trump and others, say Huang should get a pass on his missteps and be allowed back.

Effectively, they're arguing, Huang is bigger than the institution. He's too big to fail.

The dynamic highlights a divide in corporate governance philosophy playing out in public. A New Boys Club of pro-founders is bucking traditional safeguards and limits for the sake of growth, while others embrace more traditional corporate governance, understanding why those rules are there in the first place: continuity.

The very idea of a publicly traded company, after all, is about shared ownership, not a single irreplaceable person.

"Founders are unbelievable in the sense that they create something from nothing -- so that is pretty magical," Satya Nadella, one of two chief executives to follow Microsoft founder Bill Gates, said this past week at the New York Times DealBook Summit. "Yes, they're singular, but they're not gods." He added, "As I used to say to Bill, founders also die so at some point a company, if it needs to succeed, it has to have someone take over."

To be fair, Nvidia's remaining leadership team is arguing they can carry on without their founder. The AI chip company does rely on contracts as it competes to lock down space among third-party foundries and in-demand memory. On Tuesday, interim CEO Colette Kress tried to alleviate worries as she highlighted Nvidia's purchase commitments of $390 billion.

"It's business as usual," Kress told analysts. "We've engaged with our customers, we've engaged with our suppliers...They're all 100% up behind us." And she even name-checked Nvidia's most important supplier, TSMC, which makes the chips that the California company designs.

Still, Huang had long celebrated the fact that, for roughly 30 years, he did business with TSMC without formal contracts. To him, it was a sign of trust. "I don't know how many tens, hundreds of billions of dollars of business we've done through them and we don't have a contract," he told a podcaster in March. "That's pretty great."

The following month, during another podcast appearance, Huang again touted that relationship. "There's always some rough justice -- sometimes I'm right, sometimes I'm wrong, sometimes I got a better deal, sometimes I got a worse deal, but overall the relationship is incredible," he said.

Supporters of Huang's approach say it played to cultural aspects of the Asian supply chain where personal relationships are currency. Or that such approaches allowed Nvidia to move fast to take advantage of a quick-moving technology. And, while Huang may have eschewed big contracts with the likes of TSMC, down in the middling ranks, there would have likely been actual purchase orders to assure quantities and prices were detailed. As microprocessor maestro Patrick Moorhead has argued, those agreements are mostly in place for at least 18 months.

"The real exposure is the next round: anything not on paper, and whether Nvidia keeps committing at Jensen's pace," the Moor Insights & Strategy founder wrote.

Part of Huang's success was the trust he developed throughout the ecosystem as something of a middleman between his technology's upstream suppliers and downstream customers. He helped build that ecosystem in part by locking up capacity with purchase agreements while using more "implicit" means -- selling suppliers on a vision for the future that they believed he could deliver.

"For example, a lot of the investments that are upstream are made by our supply chain because I said to the CEOs, 'Let me tell you how big this industry is going to be, let me explain to you why, let me reason through it with you, and let me show you what I see,' " Huang said on the Dwarkesh Podcast.

If anyone should understand the downside to doing business without formal contracts, it should be Musk, who helped found OpenAI with tens of millions of dollars before things eventually turned sour.

His yearslong legal battle with OpenAI revolved around his claims that Sam Altman betrayed him by remaking the AI lab into a commercial venture. OpenAI has argued there was never any contract.

The issue around whether they had an agreement or not was never decided because a jury earlier this year rejected the lawsuit, finding the statute of limitations for bringing a case had expired. At one point during the legal battle, though, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers questioned the wisdom of Musk's pumping money into OpenAI without the terms and conditions in writing.

"It's a lot of money to do on a handshake," she said.

Musk's lawyer, who had argued emails suggested a shared understanding, replied that there was no requirement for a formal contract. "I understand there's no requirement," the federal judge said. "I'm just stating the obvious: $45 million on a handshake and what do you end up with? You end up in...court."

At the very least, you end up with uncertainty -- which is what's hanging over Nvidia. Except in this instance, the proposed salve proposed through a public pressure campaign by the New Boys Club is to bring back Huang -- a suggestion that, so far, the Nvidia board has rejected.

On Wednesday, Musk continued his advocacy for Huang, arguing he is irreplaceable, in part because of his personal connections. "It's like kicking Michael Jordan off your team when you're on a winning streak," Musk said during a remote appearance at the Dealbook conference.

Huang may very well be the Jordan of his time, but that doesn't mean there won't be a LeBron James on the horizon.

 

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment