Speaker: Jeremy Tan Tze-Minn, CFA, shows how to let price tell the story, using Weinstein’s four stages, momentum setups from Qullamaggie and Minervini, and his own trend-following method, TrendLogic, with a USDCNH futures example.
[About the Speaker] Jeremy Tan Tze-Minn, CFA, has more than 25 years of experience across equities, futures trading, property development and business growth. A former SGX SIMEX floor trader in interest-rate and index futures and an SGX Ambassador for SDRs and structured products, he is a Tiger Investment Representative.
[The Hook] Most of us, Jeremy said, walk into a trade with a view. One simple way to become a more disciplined trader is to let the market tell you what is happening rather than imposing your own view. He starts from a fundamental view, then overlays technicals to time entries and exits.
[Let Price Tell the Story]
The deck’s principle: price is the ultimate truth, and news, opinions and forecasts are secondary. Your job is to observe structure, trend and participation.
-
Higher highs and higher lows mean an uptrend
-
Lower highs and lower lows mean a downtrend
-
Volume confirms or questions the move
-
Failed breakouts often reverse sharply
-
Multiple timeframes should agree
Jeremy added that looking only at the daily chart is not enough.
[Weinstein’s Four Stages]
Jeremy credited Stan Weinstein’s stage analysis as a framework for any stock or futures contract:
-
Stage 1, Base (accumulation): low volatility, range-bound, preparing for a potential breakout
-
Stage 2, Advancing (markup): trend is up, higher highs and higher lows, momentum and volume confirm, pullbacks are buying opportunities
-
Stage 3, Top (distribution): loss of momentum, price stalls after a strong advance, watch for breakdowns
-
Stage 4, Declining (markdown): trend is down, lower highs and lower lows, rallies are selling opportunities
Asked how to recognise Stage 2, he pointed to two signs: relative strength (the instrument holds up or rises even when the broader market is falling) and volume higher than during the base. The deck’s summary: stage awareness is an edge, and price action should confirm the stage.
[Momentum Setups: Qullamaggie and Minervini]
The deck distils the approach of Kristjan Qullamaggie and Mark Minervini into four ideas: trade only in advancing stages, look for tight bases and breakouts on expanding volume, prefer instruments showing relative strength, and use hard stops sized so a full stop is a small percentage of capital. The Qullamaggie setups it lists are high-volume breakouts at 52-week highs, episodic pivots on news catalysts, and parabolic shorts that fade euphoria.
Minervini’s volatility contraction pattern (VCP) has four parts: a strong prior uptrend, each pullback shallower than the last, volume that dries up, and a buy on the pivot breakout.
Jeremy drew a useful contrast: value investors tend to get interested as prices fall, while momentum traders usually engage only when price is rising. Decide which one you are before you choose a method.
[TrendLogic: Staying With the Trend]
TrendLogic is the trend-following method Jeremy adapted from one he learned from a mentor. His version uses daily and weekly data. It has four steps:
-
Identify: confirm the dominant trend across timeframes and avoid counter-trend trades
-
Enter: pullback or breakout entry in the trend’s direction, after confirmation
-
Manage: trail stops as the trend develops, let profits run, cut losers quickly
-
Exit: on a trend break or predefined target, with no hope-based holding
[Worked Example: USDCNH Futures]
The deck applies the method to USDCNH futures as an illustrative example:
-
Trend identification: a downtrend across daily and weekly charts
-
Price movement: a counter-trend rally toward the upper boundaries of moving averages or established price structure
-
Position entry: a short after a potential trend resumption, with a buy-stop order above the previous swing high
-
Stop management: trail the stop as lower lows develop
-
Exit considerations: a break in trend structure or a predefined target, with partial exits possible
On the chart, Jeremy marked minor tops (“antennas”) and four conditions for a sell signal: the volume-adjusted moving average crossing below the high-low band, a bar closing above the two most recent lows, a full bar below the parabolic, and the sell signal bar itself.
He was candid that this is not an exact science and does not catch every top. He added that most indicators, whether Bollinger Bands, MACD or RSI, are essentially averages of past data, so similar charts and logic apply across forex, equities and futures.
[Same Principles, Different Markets]
The deck says the same entry, stop and trail rules carry across contracts: Treasury futures (ZN, ZB), gold and silver (GC, SI), Nasdaq futures (NQ, MNQ) and HSI Tech futures (HTI). The deck describes Nasdaq futures as excellent for trend following when Stage 2 is confirmed.
[Key Takeaways]
-
Let price confirm your view. Structure, trend and volume come first.
-
Know the stage. Trade with the trend, and be careful in bases, tops and declines.
-
Have a method with defined entry, stop and exit. TrendLogic’s four steps are one example.
-
Know your style. Value investing and momentum trading are different games.
[Call to Action 🎯]
-
Open the weekly chart of a market you follow and mark whether it looks like Stage 1, 2, 3 or 4.
-
Check whether the daily and weekly trends agree.
-
Drop a comment: which stage do you think your chosen market is in, and why?
Markets are always moving - and sometimes, the best move is knowing what works for you.
With Treasury yields, oil prices and rate expectations keeping markets on edge this week, investors are once again thinking carefully about where to position next. There’s no one-size-fits-all choice in investing — and the same goes for Tiger Merch. This month’s hot picks are in, featuring the Tiger Toiletry Bag, Universal Travel Adapter, Tiger Umbrella and more favourites chosen by fellow Tigers.
Explore the Monthly Hot Picks in Tiger Coin Mall, now 12% OFF for a limited time.
Comments
一、最重要的知识:温斯坦四阶段
阶段 市场状态 交易思路
第一阶段 横盘整理 观察,不急着买
第二阶段 趋势向上 寻找买入机会
第三阶段 上涨乏力 考虑减仓或止盈
第四阶段 趋势向下 避免抄底,谨慎操作
对新手来说,第二阶段通常是动量交易者最关注的阶段,因为上涨趋势已经开始得到价格和成交量确认。
二、三个值得学习的方法
1. Qullamaggie: 寻找股价突破52周新高、成交量放大的股票。
2. Minervini: 寻找波动越来越小、成交量逐渐萎缩,最后向上突破的股票(VCP)。
3. TrendLogic: 先判断趋势,再找进场点,设置止损,最后按照规则退出。
三、我认为最值得记住的三个原则
不要逆势交易: 上涨趋势中寻找买入机会,下跌趋势中不要轻易抄底。
一定要设止损: 买入前先想好,如果判断错误,亏损多少就离场。
不要只看日线: 同时观察周线和日线,确认大方向是否一致。
四、对普通投资者有什么帮助?
这套方法比较适合短中线交易,不一定适合所有长期价值投资者。
例如:
长期投资者:关注公司盈利、现金流、估值和股息。
动量交易者:关注价格趋势、成交量、突破和止损。
我的看法: 新手最应该学习的不是如何预测股价,而是如何判断趋势、控制亏损和避免追高。
记住:看对方向不代表一定赚钱,买入价格和止损纪律同样重要。
**① 为什么关注第3阶段?** 前期AI行情推动科技股持续上涨,但近期部分半导体和AI概念股出现较大回撤,市场领涨范围也有所收窄。这可能是上涨动能减弱的信号。不过,只有结合周线支撑、均线斜率和成交量,才能判断究竟是正常回调还是趋势反转。
**② 我最认同Jeremy的观点:价格比预测更重要。** 即使长期看好AI,也不能因为基本面乐观就忽略技术面走弱。如果周线和日线重新形成更高的高点、更高的低点,并且突破伴随成交量放大,我才会更有信心判断第2阶段恢复。
**③ Minervini的VCP方法很值得学习。** 我会关注回调幅度逐渐收窄、成交量下降、随后放量突破的结构,而不是看到价格下跌就急着抄底。
**④ TrendLogic最实用的是完整的交易纪律。** 先确认趋势,再等待入场信号,随后设置止损,并通过移动止损管理盈利。尤其是期货交易,方向判断正确也不代表仓位管理可以放松。
🚀 **我的策略:当前以观察为主。** 如果日线和周线趋势不一致,我宁愿减少交易;如果价格有效跌破关键支撑并形成下降趋势,再考虑第4阶段的可能性,而不是提前重仓做空。
**我的结论:技术分析不是为了预测每一个顶部和底部,而是帮助我们识别当前市场环境,并决定什么时候值得承担风险。**
**我最想坚持的一条原则:让价格确认我的观点,而不是让自己的观点替价格作决定!**