December is usually one of the most anticipated months for stock market investors. The so-called Santa Rally has created expectations that stocks will finish the year on a positive note. However, this year Goldman Sachs is offering a more cautious message: the rally may come, but investors might have to endure another round of volatility before enjoying the gains.
In its latest report, titled “Chopsgiving”, Goldman Sachs describes the current market environment as a choppy climb. Its historical analysis suggests that the strongest part of the traditional year-end rally tends to arrive after December 15, rather than immediately after Thanksgiving.
For investors hoping for a smooth December recovery, this is an important distinction.
1. The Santa Rally may be concentrated in the final two weeks
Goldman Sachs examined S&P 500 historical performance dating back to 1928. Its analysis suggests that the market often experiences an early December slowdown and another period of weakness around mid-December before recovering towards year-end.
Historically, approximately 80% of the average gains during this seasonal window have occurred after December 14.
The S&P 500 has also experienced a median maximum drawdown of around 3% during this period.
This means investors should not assume that a positive seasonal pattern guarantees a straight upward move. Even in historically strong periods, temporary pullbacks are normal.
For me, the more interesting question is whether investors can remain patient when the market experiences another decline just before the traditional Santa Rally begins.
2. Retail investors are buying while institutions remain cautious
One of the most interesting findings is the difference between retail and institutional behaviour.
According to Goldman Sachs, retail investors purchased approximately $6.2 billion in US equities during the latest reported week, their strongest weekly buying in 11 weeks.
Technology and semiconductor stocks attracted significant attention:
• $NVIDIA(NVDA)$ $1.75 billion in net buying.
• $Advanced Micro Devices(AMD)$ $672 million.
• $Micron Technology(MU)$ $526 million.
• $Tesla Motors(TSLA)$ $523 million.
However, institutional positioning tells a different story.
Goldman Sachs reported that technology has been the largest net-sold sector in its global prime brokerage data for several consecutive weeks. The US technology long-short ratio also fell to its lowest level since records began in 2016.
This creates an interesting market dynamic. Retail investors appear willing to buy technology stocks during weakness, while institutional investors are becoming more selective.
It does not necessarily mean institutions expect the entire market to crash. Some may be reducing exposure to individual stocks while maintaining broader market exposure.
3. The $122 billion CTA risk is worth watching
Another important factor is systematic fund positioning.
Goldman Sachs estimates that CTA strategies sold more than $22 billion in S&P 500 futures and nearly $2.5 billion in Nasdaq futures over the latest reported week.
Although these funds could become net buyers again if markets remain stable or rise, their positioning creates a potential risk.
Goldman estimates that over a one-month horizon, a market decline could trigger as much as $122.97 billion in additional CTA selling, compared with approximately $89.1 billion in potential buying under an upward market scenario.
This is important because systematic strategies often react to price movements and volatility rather than company fundamentals.
If the market continues climbing, these funds could help support the rally through additional buying. But if prices fall sharply, the same strategies could amplify the selling pressure.
In other words, the market could experience a relatively quick change in direction.
4. December 15 could be more important than Thanksgiving
Goldman Sachs also highlights corporate share buybacks as another source of market support.
Buyback activity has been running above the average levels recorded during the same period in 2024 and 2025. However, this support may weaken when corporate buyback windows begin closing around December 13.
This timing is particularly interesting because it coincides with the historical seasonal weakness around mid-December.
Other factors could also influence sentiment, including Nvidia’s earnings, expectations surrounding the Federal Reserve’s December meeting and the possibility of thinner year-end trading liquidity.
There are therefore several reasons why the market may struggle before the final weeks of December.
5. How I would approach the market
I wouldn’t buy stocks simply because historical data suggests a Santa Rally is approaching.
Instead, I would consider three approaches:
• For long-term investors: Continue focusing on companies with strong earnings, healthy cash flows and reasonable valuations. A seasonal pullback does not automatically change a company’s long-term outlook.
• For investors holding cash: Keep some buying power available rather than deploying everything during the first market decline. If volatility increases, better entry points may emerge.
• For short-term traders: Watch market breadth, volatility and institutional positioning. A rising S&P 500 supported by only a handful of large technology stocks may be less convincing than a rally involving multiple sectors.
I would also be careful about chasing semiconductor stocks after strong daily gains, particularly when institutional positioning remains cautious.
My takeaway
The Santa Rally is a historical seasonal tendency, not a guaranteed market event.
What makes this year’s setup particularly interesting is the disagreement between different groups of investors. Retail investors are buying aggressively, institutions are reducing technology exposure, and systematic funds could become either an important source of buying support or additional selling pressure.
Goldman Sachs’ message is not that investors should abandon the market. Rather, stocks could gradually move higher, but the journey may include another period of turbulence before the traditional year-end rally takes hold.
I would rather prepare for volatility than assume every market dip is a buying opportunity.
The real test may come in the second half of December, when we find out whether seasonal optimism can overcome positioning risks and uncertain market sentiment.
For discussion purposes only.
Comments