Why Your Trading Results Have Nothing To Do With Your Strategy

Have you ever wondered why some trades feel different than others? You're following the same strategy, looking at the same patterns, but something just feels... off.

Last week, I received a message from a trader who was convinced that his strategy wasn't working. He had back-tested it extensively with 300 data points, showing a 45% win rate with a 1:2 risk-reward ratio. Statistically, he should have been profitable. Yet after three months of live trading, his account was down 28%.

What he and what most traders didn’t realize and never consider is that his problem wasn't his strategy. It was something far more dangerous.

The Hidden Force Destroying Your Trading Account

Think about your last losing trade. Be honest with yourself:

• Did you move your stop loss because you "felt" the market would reverse?

• Did you enter early because you were afraid of missing the move?

• Did you close a winning trade too soon because you couldn't handle seeing profits disappear?

If you answered yes to any of these, congratulations - you've just discovered why most traders fail, and it has nothing to do with your strategy.

The Expensive Truth About Trading Psychology

When I first started trading, I lost over $20,000. It’s not because my analysis was wrong. I just couldn't control my emotions.

Here's what would happen. I'd spot a perfect setup according to my plan. I’ll enter the trade. I’d sit right in front of my computer and watch every tick of price movement. I panic when the trade went against me which resulted in me to either cut winners short or let losers run.

Sound familiar? You might be making these same mistakes without even realizing it.

Why Your Brain Is Working Against You

Here's what nobody tells you about trading. Your brain is literally wired to make you fail.

When you see your account going into drawdown:

• Your heart rate increases

• Stress hormones flood your body

• Your prefrontal cortex (logical thinking) shuts down

• Your amygdala (emotional center) takes over

This is the same response your ancestors had when facing a lion. Great for survival, terrible for trading.

The Four Emotional Traps Every Trader Falls Into

1. Fear of Loss

• Moving stop losses

• Cutting winners short

• Not taking valid setups 

1. Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

• Entering without confirmation

• Chasing price

• Taking sub-par setups 

1. Revenge Trading

• Doubling down after losses

• Trading bigger size to "make it back"

• Taking trades outside your plan 

1. Overconfidence

• Increasing position size after wins

• Ignoring risk management

• Breaking rules because "you feel it" 

All these results in reduced win rate and smaller profits due to increased losses from poor entries, potentially wiping out weeks or months of profits. In serious cases, these may lead to blown accounts and destroyed confidence. 

The Math Behind Emotional Trading

Let's say you have a strategy with:

• 40% win rate

• 1:2 risk-reward ratio

• 1% risk per trade

Mathematically, this strategy should make money. But emotions change everything:

Without Emotions:

• Winners: 40 trades × 2R = +80R

• Losers: 60 trades × -1R = -60R

• Net Result: +20R

With Emotions:

• Cut winners early: 40 trades × 1R = +40R

• Let losers run: 60 trades × -1.5R = -90R

• Net Result: -50R

Same strategy, completely different results.

Signs You're Trading Emotionally 

Even if you don’t realize it, there are signs that you’re trading emotionally. You need to journal down and be conscious about it.

1. Before the Trade

• Feeling the pressure to trade

• Unable to wait for perfect setups

• Entering without proper analysis and confirmation

1. During the Trade

• Constantly checking your P&L

• Feeling anxiety about open positions

• Unable to follow your trade plan and trade management

1. After the Trade

• Feeling euphoric after wins

• Feeling depressed after losses

• Unable to stop thinking about trading

The Solution: Building Your Trading Psychology

Here's the framework I used to transform from an emotional wreck to a consistent trader:

1. Preparation Phase

• Write down exact entry, stop loss, target, and your emotional state (Check out my FREE trading journal here.)

• Calculate position size before entering

• Take screenshots of your analysis

• Review your rules checklist

1. Execution Phase

• Set and forget your orders (if applicable)

• No watching charts if not necessary

• No checking P&L

• No moving stop losses (unless it fits your trade management)

1. Review Phase

• Journal every trade

• Rate your emotional state

• Track rule violations

• Learn from mistakes

Real Results From Managing Emotions

My First Month Trading:

• Started with $10,000

• Took 45 trades

• Broke every rule in my plan

• Ended down 40%

After Implementing Emotional Control:

• Managing $200,000 funded account

• Taking 15-20 trades per month

• Following rules strictly

• Consistent 3-5% monthly returns

Here’s another challenge I passed this week using the FREE trade signals that I gave and the system I mentioned here.

Taking Action: Your First Steps

1. Start a Trading Journal

• Record your emotions before each trade

• Note any rules you break

• Track the cost of emotional decisions

1. Create a Pre-Trade Checklist

• Entry criteria

• Risk management rules

• Position sizing calculations

• Market condition requirements

1. Build Better Habits

• Trade smaller size while learning

• Remove P&L display from charts

• Set and forget your orders (If applicable)

• Review trades only at set times

The Path Forward

Remember, everyone feels emotions while trading. The goal isn't to eliminate emotions. It's to prevent them from affecting your decisions.

The market doesn't care how you feel. It doesn't care about your hopes, fears, or dreams. The only thing that matters is whether you can execute your strategy consistently, regardless of emotions.

The choice is yours. Continue letting emotions control your trading, or learn to control your emotions..

If you enjoy such content, feel free to click the like button and subscribe for more. Let me know what are your thoughts and learning points in the comments below so others can learn from you too! Please let me know what kind of topic you would like to read next :)

@CaptainTiger @MillionaireTiger @TigerStars