Jonathan Lo's Playbook: Valuation Ratios and the Moat Behind the Business

TigerClub
11-05
Reward Tiger-CoinsReward 500 Tiger-coins

Speaker: Jonathan Lo, Investment Representative at Tiger Brokers Singapore, on P/E, ROE, dividend yield, and why the quality of a business can matter more than the quality of its management.

[About the Speaker] Jonathan Lo is an Investment Representative at Tiger Brokers (Singapore). With nearly 20 years of practical trading and investment experience, he interprets markets through multi-asset, macro-directed long-short strategies expressed through equities and options.

[The Hook] Is management more important, or the enterprise itself? The speaker leaned on Buffett: a structurally disadvantaged company is hard to turn into a consistently profitable one, even for a good management team.

[The Popular Valuation Ratios]

  • P/E ratio comes in two kinds. Trailing 12-month P/E is backward-looking, "like looking in the rearview mirror." Forward P/E is based on analysts' projected earnings, like looking through the windshield.

  • Return on equity (ROE) = net income ÷ shareholders' equity × 100. A high ROE suggests the company uses capital productively. But ask how it got there: it could come from taking on a lot of debt to open stores or run subsidised campaigns to win market share.

  • Return on assets (ROA) measures income against the assets a company holds. The speaker noted it can be more useful for businesses like banks.

  • Dividend yield = dividend ÷ share price × 100. Pair it with the payout ratio, the share of earnings paid out as dividends. You don't want it too high, so the payout stays sustainable. The speaker's own emphasis: consistency, year after year.

[Using the Tiger App's Valuation Track]

In the Tiger app, under the Analysis tab, the valuation track shows today's P/E against its historical range, for both trailing and forward P/E. Green means below one standard deviation, red means above. It gives a sense of how optimistic or pessimistic investors currently are about a company. The forward version is based on analyst consensus, so it shows how bullish expectations are.

One subtle point: the same share price can mean different valuations at different times, because earnings change. A stock at $100 today may look different from the same $100 five years ago.

You can mix and match these ratios into your own screening process.

[Quality of the Business]

A company's problems sometimes surface only over time. The speaker's case study: a CEO celebrated as a superstar in his era, whose record looked different after he retired and the financial crisis hit. His point was not whether the man was good or bad, but that this is worth studying.

The Buffett lesson: the enterprise matters more than the person steering it. The speaker contrasted Coca-Cola, still held and still performing, with another company investors backed hoping for growth, which kept needing fresh capital.

[The Economic Moat]

A moat is a company's competitive advantage. The slide lists five:

  • Switching costs: obstacles that keep customers from changing products (e.g. Apple ecosystem)

  • Network effects: value rises as more people join (e.g. Facebook, TikTok)

  • Intangible assets: patents, licenses, brand identity (e.g. Coca-Cola brand)

  • Cost advantage: producing at lower cost (e.g. Costco)

  • Efficient scale: a market that supports only one or a few players (e.g. National Grid)

The slide's reminder: if a competitive advantage doesn't exist or may prove fleeting, there's no moat.

[Key Takeaways]

  • Know what a ratio measures before you trust it. A high ROE can come from debt.

  • Compare P/E with its own history, not just with other stocks.

  • Look for dividend consistency, and check the payout ratio.

  • Moats protect profits. Ask which kind a company has.

[Call to Action 🎯]

  1. Open the valuation track for a stock you follow, trailing and forward.

  2. Write down which of the five moats it has, if any.

  3. Drop a comment: which company do you think has the strongest moat, and why?

Markets are always moving - and sometimes, the best move is knowing what works for you.

With Treasury yields, oil prices and rate expectations keeping markets on edge this week, investors are once again thinking carefully about where to position next. There’s no one-size-fits-all choice in investing — and the same goes for Tiger Merch. This month’s hot picks are in, featuring the Tiger Toiletry Bag, Universal Travel Adapter, Tiger Umbrella and more favourites chosen by fellow Tigers.

Explore the Monthly Hot Picks in Tiger Coin Mall, now 12% OFF for a limited time.

https://laohu8.com/J/redeemGift?goodID=100561&type=delivery

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
Reward expired
Due to insufficient number of valid participants, 500Tiger coins have been refunded to the initiator
Deadline to 11/15 18:08
Reward-post

Comments

  • 苏36
    11-05
    苏36
    I would choose Costco (COST) as one of the strongest examples of a durable economic moat.

    What makes Costco special is not simply its low prices, but its membership business model. Customers pay an annual fee for access, giving Costco a recurring revenue stream while encouraging repeat purchases. This creates a powerful combination of customer loyalty, economies of scale and cost advantages.

    The numbers support this argument. In FY2025, Costco generated $5.32 billion in membership fee revenue, up 10% year over year. Its renewal rate reached 92.3% in the US and Canada. That is not just customer satisfaction; it is evidence of a business model customers are willing to keep paying for.

    However, even an excellent business can become a poor investment if purchased at an excessive valuation.

    My takeaway: A strong moat protects future earnings, but the purchase price determines our potential returns. Quality matters, but valuation still matters.

    @TigerClub [龇牙]

  • 未来会更好WW
    11-08
    未来会更好WW
    Microsoft arguably holds the strongest hybrid economic moat today. It locks in enterprise customers through massive switching costs—migrating corporate infrastructure away from Azure, Windows, or Office 365 is a logistical nightmare—while simultaneously benefiting from network effects across platforms like Teams and LinkedIn.
  • Atwosome
    11-08
    Atwosome
    Google (GOOG) for its economic moat. Google Search, YouTube and its advertising ecosystem are incredibly difficult to replace. Even with AI competition growing, its massive user base, data and distribution give it a strong advantage. Google new AI chip and new electricity generation are also an breakthrough
  • 爱喝水的小猫猫
    11-07
    爱喝水的小猫猫
    In the era of AI, anything is possible. And there are so many stocks having economic moat. I choose Google for the fact that I’m already using search, Gemini, YouTube on a daily basis!!!
  • Jason2607
    11-06
    Jason2607
    I choose Apple (AAPL) because it has a strong competitive moat through brand loyalty and switching costs. Its ecosystem of iPhones, iPads, and MacBooks encourages customers to stay. This helps Apple maintain its competitive advantage, customer loyalty, and long-term profitability.
  • Lanceljx
    11-06
    Lanceljx
    I believe Microsoft possesses one of the strongest economic moats, supported by high switching costs, network effects and its extensive enterprise ecosystem.

    Microsoft 365, Azure and enterprise software are deeply integrated into business operations. Switching providers involves substantial migration costs, retraining and operational disruption, supporting recurring revenue.

    However, a strong moat does not automatically justify a premium valuation. I would assess forward P/E, ROE, earnings growth and free cash flow alongside historical valuations. High ROE can also be distorted by leverage or share buybacks.

    Microsoft's substantial AI capital expenditure presents opportunities but also risks if returns disappoint.

    Ultimately, I favour businesses with durable competitive advantages, strong balance sheets and sustainable cash generation, purchased at reasonable valuations.

Leave a comment
16
3