Why is Tesla plummeting and Musk is angry?

Tesla was kicked out of the S&P 500′s ESG index. Tesla CEO Elon Musk responsed to the ESG metrics is “Devil Incarnate.”

In order to figure out the ins and outs of the thing, the first thing we need to know is "What is ESG?"

ESG - Environmental, Social and Governance

In my opinion, this non-financial auditing standard is usually used to measure a company's contribution and impact in our daily life, such as pollution, human rights and labor force etc. Many securities markets require listed companies to provide ESG reports as one of the indicators to measure company‘s market value. Different trading markets have different standards. However, this standard is controversial.

The S&P 500 ESG Index uses environmental, social and governance data to rank and effectively recommend companies to investors. Its criteria include hundreds of data points per company that pertain to the way businesses affect the planet and treat stakeholders beyond shareholders — including customers, employees, vendors, partners and neighbors.

Story back to $Tesla Motors(TSLA)$

Why Tesla was removed from S&P 500's ESG index? The officials said that Tesla’s “lack of a low-carbon strategy” and “codes of business conduct,” along with racism and poor working conditions reported at Tesla’s factory in Fremont, California, affected the score. Tesla’s handling of an investigation by the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration also weighed on its score.

What makes people incomprehensible is that $Exxon Mobil(XOM)$ has a higher score than ev maker Tesla, and even $Ford(F)$ has a higher score than Tesla. So, Mush twittes:

In an earlier tweet on Musk wrote: “I am increasingly convinced that corporate ESG is the Devil Incarnate.”

Story not finished. Not only Tesla, these giants have also been removed to the index.

$Berkshire Hathaway(BRK.B)$ $Johnson & Johnson(JNJ)$ $Meta Platforms, Inc.(FB)$ $Home Depot(HD)$ $Chevron(CVX)$ $Costco(COST)$

Who's in

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

Tesla stock plummetd in last trading session. Do you agree that it was caused by removed from ESG index? Or is there other reason?

You may be rewarded with Tiger Coins for sharing your thoughts in the comment💸💸💸

Follow me! Don't forget I am the richest tiger in this community😎😎

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment

  • Top
  • Latest
  • Big Cat
    ·2022-05-19
    [Surprised]
    I didn't know $Tesla Motors(TSLA)$ got kicked out of ESG index... [Speechless]

    What the... indeed is a scam... & how is Exxon rated the top 10... [Speechless]

    It's a scheme I think...

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Big Cat
      What u guys think [Doubt]?
      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    • Big Cat
      I do agreed that $Tesla Motors(TSLA)$ share falls may be the cause of it being kicked out, but... behind the scene story... ahhem... "short seller" = who? [Silence]...

      So, what's the true reason?

      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    • Jason1989
      Ok
      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    View more 1 comments
  • highhand
    ·2022-05-19
    No! It dropped because Musk went on a madman rage about politics/free speech, n flip flop about Twitter. This spook investors about his priorities. But its good for us to collect Tesla at a "discount"
    Reply
    Report
  • MHh
    ·2022-05-19
    Dropped in line with the broad market with supply chain disruptions, rate hikes and inflation. Not spared from it. And also because acquring twitter which may jeopardise it
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • DiAngelReplying toMHh
      Thanks for sharing
      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    • Boo2020Replying toFenger1188
      could be a combination of all factors, kicked out of index, rising interest rate and attempted acquisition of twitter , when bad news come, they come altogether
      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    • RDPD富爸穷爸Replying toMHh
      Thanks for sharing 😊👍
      2022-05-19
      Reply
      Report
    View more 3 comments
  • Jenjorjack
    ·2022-05-20
    Over priced reverting to the mean at the wrong time for him lor.
    Reply
    Report
  • setia100
    ·2022-05-20
    The media used the word"kicked" annoyed him I guess 😂
    Reply
    Report
  • duseve
    ·2022-05-21
    Apart fr racism at Tesla’s factory,rampant sexual harassment & assault were also reported. Recently, was revealed that Musk paid $250,000 settlement w an employee he flashed & propositioned.Maybe that
    Reply
    Report
  • Fatfish
    ·2022-05-20
    So controversial. Burn petrol can be top 10, cut down on carbon emission got kicked down. No wonder Musk is angry
    Reply
    Report
  • StickyRice
    ·2022-05-20
    Yeah TSLA is very volatile but in long term will always go up. They are the first mover in EV industry. Also the proven one. They already build supply chain and parts equipment supplier everywhere
    Reply
    Report
  • Cris0
    ·2022-05-21
    Telsa shares have been affected ever since musk nuy twitter. And the products keeps failing the expectation with recalls. Not surprised when it is remove from the index
    Reply
    Report
  • Wayneqq
    ·2022-05-20
    There are many factors that causes tesla price to dip.. removal from ESG index is just one of the many.. but i think the main reason is key man risk and the ongoing saga with twitter..
    Reply
    Report
  • Truly_Lucky
    ·2022-05-20
    Good article. Viewpoint from Elon Musk is valid in comparison to other companies
    Reply
    Report
  • kelvin1234
    ·2022-05-20
    这篇文章不错,转发给大家看
    Reply
    Report
  • jipbu
    ·2022-05-20

    [Like] 

    Reply
    Report
  • lappiloco
    ·2022-05-20
    Apple and Google all the way for me, i think these 2 are the champion of clean n green
    Reply
    Report
  • Brocco
    ·2022-05-21
    Yes. Ageee that it is caused by the removal from ESH index. Musk buying Twitter has definitely affects the stock, on top of that, theres news on product recalls,etc. not surprised that it falls
    Reply
    Report
  • NewbieLeo
    ·2022-05-21
    thanks for sharing. when you have a standard to abide by, you got to uphold those standards in everyway. tesla may have practices that don't comply, but exxon qualifying is a joke
    Reply
    Report
  • Serene70
    ·2022-05-21
    I don't think ESG removal is the reason.  I felt there's a lot of uncertainty whether the buyout of twitter will pull through and if it does, telsa will drop further.
    Reply
    Report
  • Ghtan
    ·2022-05-21
    The criteria for ESG should be much clearer and a standard has to be used to select the companies. I‘M pessimistic about how the world is going to be if this continues. thanks!
    Reply
    Report
  • HH浩
    ·2022-05-21
    Tesla share price plummet partly due to ESG cause as more ane more funds were launched under ESG premise and investors buy the story. After all, only fund managers can move the share price.
    Reply
    Report
  • Netfalcon
    ·2022-05-20
    He’s off his rocker. Drugs are bad …mmmkay.
    Reply
    Report