The downside & upside of ETFs

Hi Friends!

Most of us love ETFs. However, do we really know the pros and cons of ETFs in specific details?

Firstly, what are ETFs? (Exchange Traded Funds)

• ETF is a basket of securities that seeks to track an underlying index. These indexes can include stocks, bonds and commodities.

Personally, I do like some ETFs but not all of them.

The PROS of ETFs are pretty straightforward.

1. Lower Cost as compared to underlying individualsecurities

2. Lower Expense Ratio

3. Diversified

4. Saves time

Having said that, owning dozens of ETFs in your portfolio is very likely to be counterproductive.

Assuming Mr ABC buys:

•World ETF

•FTSE 100 ETF

•S&P500 ETF

•Russell 2000 ETF

•Sectors ETF (XLK, XLE, XLY, etc.)

•STI ETF

•HSI ETF

•Growth/Emerging Markets ETF

•Commodities ETF

•Bonds ETF

In my humble opinion, when an individual holds too many different ETFs in his/her portfolio, it introduces inefficiencies.

When you take a closer look, you’ll notice that your ETFs are overlapping, which creates redundancy in the other ETFs that you’re holding.

Furthermore, over diversification dilutes the effect of well-performing holdings in your portfolio and hampers your returns.

Geographically, we have to bear in mind that indices of different countries focus their weightage on different sectors respectively.

For example, $FTSE100 ETF(ISF.UK)$ is oil heavy. Basically meaning that it places a heavier weightage on Oil Companies. While $Straits Times Index(STI.SI)$places a heavier weightage on Banks.

The legendary Jack Bogle’s “The Bogleheads 3 Fund Portfolio” might be a good benchmark to make sound and informed investment decisions.

While ETFs have its advantages, there is no need to buy dozens of ETFs to be profitable and diversified. Less is more.

Cheers! 

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment

  • Top
  • Latest
  • Furore
    ·2022-06-03
    TOP
    I think what the author is trying to say about inefficiencies in buying multiple ETFs is more of the issue of them overlapping
    Eg. Why buy SPY when you're buying VOO, or QQQ and QQQM
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      A few more pointers. Respective indices emphasise weightage to different sectors. Overlapping causes reduncy=inefficiency in capital deployment & dilutes winning holdings.
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • NevermindQ
    ·2022-06-03
    TOP
    Fair, etf portfolio of 5 funds is more than enough
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Indeed. Less is more
      2022-06-03
      Reply
      Report
  • hh488
    ·2022-06-04
    TOP
    And ETFs usually don't give dividends.  But owning shares direct do.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Mmm.. Most major indices’ ETF do pay dividends. Eg: $SPY $VOO $ES3
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • benbent
    ·2022-06-03
    TOP
    i'm lazy so i like ETFs
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Yes. But buying a dozen of ETFs will be counterp roductive
      2022-06-03
      Reply
      Report
  • winwin123
    ·2022-06-03
    TOP
    Good advice. insightful
    Reply
    Report
  • Big Boy
    ·2022-06-02
    TOP
    Which is the best?
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • Oldhead
    ·2022-06-04
    TOP
    In uncertain times, individual shares would be better than ETFs.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      This is debatable.Because the goal of individual stock investing is to “beat the market”. Which translates to beating S&P500 etf. Statistically, 89% fail to beat S&P across 10years
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • MR_Wu
    ·2022-06-04
    TOP
    The biggest drawback of ETFs is the fees they charge.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Yes. Fees do add up and eats into profits. However, all securities bear fees too. Hence, efficient capital deployment plays a vital role.
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • BurnellStella
    ·2022-06-04
    Personally, I prefer to invest in stocks.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      There are pros and cons for both etf & stocks :)
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • BellaFaraday
    ·2022-06-04
    I see you know a lot about ETFs.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Im just a spoke on the wheel in these markets 🙏🏻
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • LouisLowell
    ·2022-06-04
    I am holding sti.si haha.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Me too. Cheers!
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • DonnaMay
    ·2022-06-04
    You're right, too much diversification is bad.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Indeed! Less is more. Cheers!
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • HilaryWilde
    ·2022-06-04
    What ETF do you have in mind?
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      On the lazy side, $ES3, $VOO.
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • 和我一起成长
    ·2022-06-04
    哇!真是跌跌不休呀!
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      不太明白 haha
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • nightfury
    ·2022-06-04
    yet it is the best way for most people to grow their asset with least risk
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Yes. It is. I agree. However, buying dozens of ETFs creates redundency=Inefficiency
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • 47ebd6a1
    ·2022-06-04
    it makes good sense [Grin] [Grin]
    Reply
    Report
  • Ranchy
    ·2022-06-03
    Thanks for sharing!
    Reply
    Report
  • EvanHolt
    ·2022-06-04
    Thank you for sharing your investment experienc
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Vixenvixen
      Most welcome! Hope it helps!
      2022-06-04
      Reply
      Report
  • 谢谢指
    Reply
    Report
  • mwhy
    ·2022-06-03
    Thanks for sharing! Very wise
    Reply
    Report