Wide moat beats narrow or no moat investing in the long run

When a new investor starts his journey in picking stocks, very often no thought process is given to the economic moat or management quality of the company.

What is economic moat?

An economic moat is a concept popularized by Warren Buffett, describing a company's sustainable competitive advantage that allows it to maintain its market position and fend off competition. Similar to a castle's moat protecting it from invaders, an economic moat protects a company from competitors trying to erode its profits and market share.

There are several types of economic moats that can contribute to a company's competitive advantage:

Cost Advantage: When a company can produce goods or services at a lower cost compared to its competitors. This could be due to proprietary technology, efficient processes, access to cheaper resources, or scale advantages.

Network Effect: Companies benefit from a network effect when their product or service becomes more valuable as more people use it. Social media platforms and online marketplaces are examples where the more users they have, the more useful they become, creating a barrier for new entrants.

Intangible Assets: Intellectual property, such as patents, trademarks, brand recognition, and regulatory approvals, can provide a significant competitive advantage. These assets are difficult for competitors to replicate quickly.

Switching Costs: Some companies build moats by making it expensive or inconvenient for customers to switch to a competitor. This can be through contracts, specialized equipment, or unique services.

High Barrier to Entry: Industries where significant investments in infrastructure, technology, or regulatory hurdles are required tend to have higher barriers to entry. This makes it challenging for new competitors to enter and compete effectively.

Economies of Scale: Larger companies can benefit from economies of scale, meaning their cost per unit decreases as production volume increases. This can create a significant advantage over smaller competitors.

A company with a strong economic moat tends to generate sustained profits and returns over an extended period. Investors often seek businesses with robust moats because they offer more predictability and stability in their earnings and are less susceptible to competitive pressures.

Morningstar found that companies with a wide moat outperform its peers with narrow or no moat

At investment research & rating firm Morningstar, they cover around 1,500 companies, and of that only fewer than 8% or 130 companies have both a wide Morningstar economic moat and earned an exemplary Captial Allocation Rating, which is a measure of management quality.

When investors are forced to choose between economic moats and management quality, moats win out in the long run.

From Morningstar's data, in a sample of nearly 1,000 companies that Morningstar equity analysts have covered from 2017 through today, only 13 stocks were assigned an Exemplary Capital Allocation Rating alongside no moat. But despite the rarefied air, these firms saw their median performance underperform wide-moat stocks with Standard- or even Poor-rated capital allocators at the helm.

One important point to note is that despite the moat, the valuation is also an important factor. If the investor over pays or buys a stock that is currently over valued, eventually the stock will correct to its fair value over time.

There are many ways to value a stock, for example working out a discounted cash flow model, or using PE ratio, EV/EBITDA ratios, etc.

The important part is to be able to find companies that have wide moats and are currently under valued.

One way is to take Morningstar's fair value (which is obtainable by a subscription) and then work out your own calculations.

Currently here are some of the fair values & moats of the magnificent seven:

Apple $150 ⭐️⭐️ (wide moat)

Microsoft $370 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (wide moat)

Alphabet $161 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (wide moat)

Amazon $155 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (wide moat)

Meta $322 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (wide moat) 

Nvidia $480 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (wide moat)

Tesla $210 ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (narrow moat)

@CaptainTiger 

@TigerStars 

$Amazon.com(AMZN)$ 

$Apple(AAPL)$ 

$Microsoft(MSFT)$ 

# What Has the Market Taught You?

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment14

  • Top
  • Latest
  • BorisBack
    ·2023-12-01
    TOP

    It's fascinating to see how the 'magnificent seven' tech giants stack up in terms of moat and valuation. Do you see any underdogs that could potentially disrupt this group?

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Lionel8383
      If you read the annual reports of the individual stocks, you will see their risk disclosures on competitors. In fact if you read Apple’s annual report, it is stated that some of their competitors sell their electronic products for very thin or at loss making margins in order to get mkt share
      2023-12-02
      Reply
      Report
  • LeilaLynch
    ·2023-12-01
    TOP

    I completely agree that valuation is crucial. How do you approach valuating stocks with wide moats to ensure you're not overpaying?

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Lionel8383
      I learn how to do my own DCF calculations, then compare my valuation with morningstar. If the stock is narrow moat, i might still enter if undervalued, but i will take profits and exit once my profit targets are hit. Usually no stop losses, but position size is smaller than my usual
      2023-12-01
      Reply
      Report
  • CatherineGunter
    ·2023-12-01
    TOP

    Impressive insights! Do you have any favorite stocks from their list of 130 with both wide moat and exemplary capital allocation?

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Lionel8383
      Microsoft and Meta! Especially Meta as it has 2x on my avg price which i have been buying since last year during the bear market
      2023-12-01
      Reply
      Report
  • Lionel8383
    ·2023-12-01
    Because there isn’t much network effect for example if you drive a Tesla, does your friend/colleague need to drive a Tesla too? Also how often does one change cars? Maybe 3-4 years in the United States? How about the chinese EVs or the traditional automakers like Audi/BMW/Mercedes that are also into EVs today. Probably Tesla has some cost advantage in terms of margins compared to other automakers but they are still losing market share as the others start to enter the EV space.
    Reply
    Report
  • vippy
    ·2023-12-24

    AMZN is beaten down (no doubt) but you better recognize it’s gonna get back that -20% off its all time high plus more. 5T market cap within 3 years.

    Reply
    Report
  • wigglyz
    ·2023-12-24

    Merry Christmas to all Longs - $160 next stop, then $170 and $180 and $200.

    Reply
    Report
  • snugglo
    ·2023-12-24

    I think Amazon’s best days are behind them. It’s not the same Amazon it was two years ago.

    Reply
    Report
  • bubblyx
    ·2023-12-24

    Best time to Buy is now when some are selling for the 3 day holiday.

    Reply
    Report
  • zinglee
    ·2023-12-24

    Everyday is like Christmas when you own AMZN stock. 👼 🎅🏻

    Reply
    Report
  • MyrnaNorth
    ·2023-12-01

    I'm surprised to see Tesla with only a narrow moat.

    Reply
    Report
  • VivianChua
    ·2023-12-02
    Nice 💚 💚 💚
    Reply
    Report