趨勢派VS價值派,你是哪個派別?

按照投資風格劃分,追漲概念就是趨勢派,看重基本面見頂持有的就是價值派。

趨勢派投資的代表人是威廉·歐奈爾,他憑藉“CANSLIM選股大法”闖蕩江湖,在20世紀70-80年代期間股票投資年收益率都超過了40%。作爲趨勢派的創始人,歐奈爾認爲選股最重要的原則是--不要唯價格論。他認爲過早介入只是浪費時間,並且很可能在股價築底階段的反覆拉鋸中被清洗出廠。

威廉·歐奈爾

對於買點的判斷,他會選擇在股價大跌並開始創出階段性新高的時候買入;對於賣點,他有7%的止損法則:股價下跌超過買入價的7%,就拋出止損,絕不猶豫。

趨勢派投資的核心邏輯是小跌賣以規避單次大跌,升後買以求抓住單邊大升。

趨勢派之問:股票相對現在要上升300%,期間必須經歷什麼?

A、行業大發展

B、企業大幅盈利

C、先升20%。

虎友們可以先思考一下這個問題,趨勢派會選擇什麼?答案很顯而易見。

但趨勢派在實戰的過程中,經常會遇到價格震盪的情形。升起來觸及買入點買入,隨後就立刻跌下去,觸及賣點,這樣反覆走上了止損的路線,這也是趨勢投資的副作用。

價值投資的代表人物巴菲特,讓我們熟知了價值投資這一派別,而不是讓價值投資單單的掌握在少數金融精英手裏。他的投資理念是去選擇經營穩健、財務狀況優秀、被市場低估的企業進行投資,最具代表性的案例就是1998年巴菲特收購百事公司的股票,當年百事可樂公司的股價被低估了50%。

巴菲特

價值投資的核心邏輯是以合適的價格去持有合適的股票,從而達到某個確定的盈利目的,強調公司價值,喜歡越跌越買。如何評估公司的價值是價值投資中最重要的一環。

價值派之問:如果一支股票同時滿足3個條件:

第一、連續5年企業淨利潤爲正且同比增速>5%

第二、上市時間大於7年

第三、市值大於100億

你認爲這支股票5年內上升的概率是多少?你會不會持有這支股票?

價值派在實戰中的難點就在於怎麼判斷基本面向好,最簡單的是你可以把握行業趨勢去投資,複雜一點你可以通過鑽研企業業務、產品、扣企業的財務細節等提高準確度。價值投資可以很簡單,也可以很複雜。但是隻要你有真知灼見,相信市場會把你的認知變現。

另外還有一類投資者屬於蛋黃派[Surprised]價值派賺錢的時候,蛋黃派價值;趨勢派賺錢的時候,蛋黃派趨勢。雖然聽起來不錯,但這裏麪包含的假設是按照神的旨意要求自身,操作難度和分析、風控難度都更大。

🎯分享有禮:

每一個投資門派獲取收益的方式都不同,沒有絕對的好壞之分,只有適不適合自己的區別。你是趨勢派、價值派還是蛋黃派?[Onlooker]

🎁評論即可得獎品如下噢~

[USD]對以下帖子的所有有效評論都將收到5個老虎硬幣。

[Applaud]前10名和後10名有合格評論的小虎將獲得額外5個老虎硬幣。

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment151

  • Top
  • Latest
  • MHh
    ·2023-04-28
    TOP
    价值派!因为我比较喜欢买好股, 长期持有,有分红就更好了
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    View more 3 comments
  • Fenger1188
    ·2023-04-28
    TOP
    谢谢精彩分享👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻我是价值投资者,巴菲特是我的偶像,$苹果(AAPL)$是他的心头爱❤️,我相信股神的眼光,我会继续等待机会买入$苹果(AAPL)$🌟🌟🌟
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Shyon
      Hehe
      2023-04-30
      Reply
      Report
    • Helen1229Replying toAh ping
      👍🏻
      2023-04-28
      Reply
      Report
    • Ah ping
      👍🏻👍🏻
      2023-04-28
      Reply
      Report
  • 安安0715
    ·2023-04-28
    TOP
    我是趋势派,我喜欢跟着行情走,一但有不利消息,我就会买出我的股票😄😄😄
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • Helen1229
    ·2023-04-28
    TOP
    谢谢分享, 我是价值派,这类股一般都比较安全👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • 小美娜
    ·2023-04-28
    TOP
    各有特色,我是综合型👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻重点不管是属于哪一派,重点是要赢到钱😃🥳😄
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Fenger1188
      👍🏻👍🏻
      2023-04-28
      Reply
      Report
  • 我是价值派,因为这些年我一直在思考研究:人性和人的认知水平的分布状况,我发现,大多数人对于事物的认知要么不够深刻,要么看不清事物底层逻辑,要么过于极端,包括我自己也可能会被一些表象迷惑,所以,当众多投资者短时间内做出某个决策时,这个决策很可能还是个错误的决策,最终被时间修正。
    Reply
    Report
  • LMSunshine
    ·2023-04-29
    ⚖️Balance is the best-Buy value + Trend❣️Comment for 5 coins❣️@SR050321 @CYKuan @HelenJanet @rL @Universe宇宙 @Jadenkho @melson @Mrzorro @GoodLife99 @SPOT_ON @Kaixiang @BenjiFuji @RDPD富爸穷爸 @SirBahamut @b1uesky @PJoo @Pepermintpat @RiciaYang @jat @Omega88 @爱上投资学 @Zeniv @Elon2 @Yonhuat @Joker_Smile @grizzlylee @FrankieRed @spkek @snoopy123 @psk @pekss @amroui @Ericdao @StickyRice @StarLuck @Shyon @kungpao @CL Wong @Derrick 1234 @MeowKitty @Thonyaunn @紫南 @Zarkness @Ah_Meng @Ratt @Tigress02 @Viv22 @aunteenat @Cory2 @airui @0QH @Cris0 @Brocco @AhGong @deal2deal @nickname168 @Ccl2 @Lcc73 @HLPA @WanEH @markele @pipiso @hlw8888 @Huiz84 @Kingcat @Jo_Tan @RedpillBluep @Furore @breAkdaWn @boardy @Soyabean89 @ngph @KYHBKO @Lionel8383 @Downton @SanWangtikup @Setia100 @th0mastan @LesterTan @IAS @HSTew @Kerrisdale @PhilipChow @alylady @moliya @maricel @Sonoma @LuckyPiggie @Doge2theMoon @equitygenius @StayHome @SGboy @Sandyboy @Stayclose @DMTrader @BettyT @Bunta @tigjun21 @JohnL @jace0777 @DoreamonGo
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • SR050321
      Lovely 😊
      2023-05-03
      Reply
      Report
    • Shyon
      Nice
      2023-04-30
      Reply
      Report
    • Derrick_1234
      💕💕💕
      2023-04-29
      Reply
      Report
    View more 5 comments
  • icycrystal
    ·2023-04-29
    I would prefer safer and dividend stocks, therefore, would go for stable and established companies. guess I belong into value school. @Poi @Werv @Hux @SNY @ln what about you guys [smile] [smile] [smile]
    Reply
    Report
  • hd87
    ·2023-04-29
    我是价值派。如果一支股票同时满足3个条件,我认为这支股票5年内上升的概率是70%。我也会持有这支股票。
    Reply
    Report
  • Taurus Pink
    ·2023-04-29
    我應該算是價值派居多.雖然我剛接觸股票沒多久.之前玩了模擬盤有大概一個月有了吧!玩的獲利還可以.怎自己下來真玩.這個成績差強人意 [流泪] [流泪]. 我還要再加油了 [白眼] [白眼]
    Reply
    Report
  • koolgal
    ·2023-04-29
    TOP

    🌟🌟🌟Investing is all about our risk appetite.  While it may seem that Trend school can make more money, it is also more of a high risk/ high reward strategy.  For example meme stocks like $GameStop(GME)$  and $Bed Bath & Beyond(BBBY)$  were very popular but look what happened to BBBY now - it is filing for bankruptcy.

    I am more of a Value School type investor as I believe in buying quality stocks with wide moat and solid core fundamentals of profitability, strong balance sheet and an excellent management team.  It is slow and steady, if a little boring but I can sleep well at night. 

    That's how Warren Buffett became a billionaire as he has a long time horizon and allow the magic of compounding to happen.  To me, investing is a marathon, not a sprint for it is time in the market that counts, not timing the market. 

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • koolgalReplying toAlexTeddySG
      Thanks for sharing your awesome insights.
      2023-05-01
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgalReplying toAlexTeddySG
      Have a beautiful relaxing Monday 😍😍😍🏖️🏖️🏖️
      2023-05-01
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgalReplying toAlexTeddySG
      Yes the market is volatile but since I have a long term horizon, I am not too worried.
      2023-05-01
      Reply
      Report
    View more 40 comments
  • Brocco
    ·2023-04-29
    Value school. I usually hold the stock long term. trend school needs to keep monitoring which is not something am good in
    Reply
    Report
  • pekss
    ·2023-04-29
    我属于价值派,因为我喜欢购入股价被低估,低于实际价值的股票,然后耐心等待它们的价值被市场发倔! @Healthy Tiger @evepek @ngph
    Reply
    Report
  • 0QH
    ·2023-04-29
    i am both 趋势派、价值派. i also like apple. it is important to diversify, so you need to set aside money in both accordingly. but i am more of trend recently. wait for recession to convert back to value investing
    Reply
    Report
  • BenjiFuji
    ·2023-04-29
    TOP
    Definately a value investor. Trends are only an additional tool on top of value school, but never the fundamental. Chasing both schools at once can be highly confusing. Being trend based only takes up a lot of effort consistently. So value school is the best long term and allows for a good nights rest. [龇牙]
    Reply
    Report
  • HH浩
    ·2023-04-29
    当人人都认为自己能左右逢源,想趋势就趋势,想价值就价值,最终结果就是买贵了价值投资者抛出来的货,卖便宜了趋势投资者振出来的仓,两头不到岸,永世浮浮沉沉在股海里漂泊… 唉
    Reply
    Report
  • HH浩
    ·2023-04-29

    @小虎活动 @@CaptainTiger @Tiger_Comments @话题虎 @Tiger_Earnings @TigerPicks 在股市里没有永远左右逢源这件事,只有浮浮沉沉的人才左右在股海里进水。@kktan 

    Reply
    Report
  • HH浩
    ·2023-04-29
    TOP
    @TigerPicks @Tiger_Comments @话题虎 @Tiger_Earnings @CaptainTiger @小虎活动 //@HH浩:當人人都認爲自己能左右逢源,想趨勢就趨勢,想價值就價值,最終結果就是買貴了價值投資者拋出來的貨,賣便宜了趨勢投資者振出來的倉,兩頭不到岸,永世浮浮沉沉在股海里漂泊… 唉
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • sailors
      good
      2023-04-30
      Reply
      Report
    • Fish80
      ok
      2023-04-30
      Reply
      Report
    • Fish80
      ok
      2023-04-30
      Reply
      Report
    View more 15 comments
  • WanEH
    ·2023-04-29
    我尝试过趨勢派、價值派、甚至什么武林技术派。结果最后发现我是庄家口中的苹果派。 [Facepalm]
    Reply
    Report
  • Shyon
    ·2023-04-30
    TOP
    我属于趋势派的,因为无论如何,只要跟着趋势买卖,胜率还是蛮高的,当然前提是在股价跌破时要果断cut loss @melson @LMSunshine @Universe宇宙 @GoodLife99 @Aqa @koolgal @rL
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • koolgal
      Thanks for sharing your insights 😍😍😍Best of luck 🍀🍀🍀🌈🌈🌈
      2023-05-01
      Reply
      Report
    • Universe宇宙
      [Wow]
      2023-05-01
      Reply
      Report