[Events] Is the Australian bank likely to collapse as SVB did ?

The collapse of the Silicon Valley Bank in the US has echoes of the 2008 Global Financial Crisis and is likely to affect Australia, financial experts say. 

What has happened to Silicon Valley Bank?

SVB's woes stemmed from its tech customers ploughing money into the bank's deposit accounts, which tripled from $US62billion in 2019 to $US191billion by the end of 2021 as pandemic lockdowns buoyed technology companies.

Silicon Valley Bank invested this money in longer-dated US government bonds, with maturity dates 15 years or more into the future, during an era when economists were focused on deflation, amid concerns about weak economic growth in coming years.

The non-traditional bank, which didn't focus on home lending, saw the value of its bond assets plummet, however, as an inflation spike saw the US Federal Reserve's key interest rate - known as the federal funds rate - surge from zero to 0.25 per cent in March 2022 to 4.5 to 4.75 per cent now, via eight increases.

Is the Australian bank likely to collapse as SVB did ?

Digital Finance Analytics principal Martin North, who has worked in banking in the UK and Australia, said the effects of the SVB collapse were likely to be felt in Australia.

'We are at the very early stages of this rather than actually at the end of a mini crisis.'We are joined at the hip with the U.S. because a lot of our funding comes from international markets, particularly the U.S. and of course, our exchange rate is also very strongly linked to what happens in the the U.S.'
Then there are the Australian companies that had borrowed from SVB and opened accounts with them as a condition of obtaining venture capital. For example, Australian graphic design group Canva, Sydney-based online hotel booking group SiteMinder, employment site Freelancer and software company Xero and so on.

Some experts says SVB collapse can’t happen in Australian

Australian banks do not have significant amounts of their deposits sitting in Treasury securities, mortgage-backed securities and other liquid investments. Instead of sitting on deposits, Australian banks actually do what banks are supposed to do – lend money at a profit. They are intermediating between depositors and lenders.Australian banks have strong incentives to make sure they hedge the interest rate risk in their bank books.

What are your thoughts on the collapse of SVB?

💡Share Your Insights

  • Is the Australian bank likely to collapse as SVB did ?
  • What is your opinion of Australian banks? Are you bullish or bearish?

🎁Prizes

  • 🐯All Tigers who comment on the following post will receive 5 Tiger Coins.
  • 🐯10 Tigers will receive 50 coins for the highest-quality comments.
  • In addition, you get a chance to win USD 5 stock voucher(Australian citizens only 🇦🇺).

⏰Activity Duration

16 March 2023-23 March 2023 $Tiger Brokers(TIGR)$​, $COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRAL(CBA.AU)$, $NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED(NAB.AU)$, $AUST AND NZ BANKING GROUP(ANZ.AU)$, $WESTPAC BANKING(WBCPI.AU)$

# ASX Stocks Opportunities

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment130

  • Top
  • Latest
  • Trippsta
    ·2023-03-17
    TOP
    Australian banking system has procedures and strategies to prevent any close to this happening. Yes we are very close with US but we don’t have their plans and strategies ( Thankfully )
    Reply
    Report
  • Success88
    ·2023-03-21
    TOP
    I don't think so, Only SVB will have this issue as they use 60% of the fund to buy the bonds. Their Risk Management Team also not taking a look into that.
    I don't think all other bank will be the same mistake. I am confident in Australia Bank
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • SR050321
      Agree 👍😊
      2023-03-21
      Reply
      Report
    • Success88
      Good
      2023-03-21
      Reply
      Report
    • HelenJanetReplying toSuccess88
      Thanks for sharing 👍👍
      2023-03-21
      Reply
      Report
    View more 3 comments
  • Aqa
    ·2023-03-18
    TOP
    Thanks @Tiger_AU Australian shares have slumped more than 2.56% to their lowest level since earlyJanuary. The downfall is lead by banking and mining stocks. Traders in Australia are becoming worried about a broder financial crisis from the collapse of the U.S. based Silicon Valley Bank last week. The S&P/AXS 200 index fell for eight straight sessions, declining more than 2.1%.In Sydney, financial stocks slipped 2.8 to hit a more five-month low, with the ”big four” banks retreating between 2% and 3%. Australia’s financial Regulators have underlined the strength of Australia’s banks and vowed to keep a close eyes in the financial sector. They are monitoring how mortgage customers are coping with the sharp rise in interest rates. $COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRAL(CBA.AU)$$NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK(NABPH.AU)$ are strong and their shares’ price have regained some ground. Thanks 🐯 friends for tag, comment and like. @Shyon @GoodLife99 @Success88 @Universe宇宙 @Jadenkho @melson @SPOT_ON
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • SR050321
    ·2023-03-21
    TOP
    Thanks @Success88 for the tag, my opinion it will not collapse, FED should try to maintain the situation not to spread, and Aussie financial institutions will try to find ways not to be effected. Can you imagine if all bank collapse the rich where to put their money ? Aussie banks meet the same strict standards as all Australian banks which are set out in the Banking Act 1959 and overseen by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA). what u think @LMSunshine ?


    $COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRAL(CBA.AU)$ $AUST AND NZ BANKING GROUP(ANZ.AU)$
    Reply
    Report
  • AliceSam
    ·2023-03-16
    TOP
    澳大利亚银行没有大量存款投资于美国国债、抵押贷款支持证券和其他流动性投资。澳大利亚银行实际上做了银行应该做的事情,而不是坐拥存款——放贷获利。他们是储户和贷款人之间的中介。澳大利亚的银行有很强的动机来确保对冲银行账户中的利率风险。
    Reply
    Report
  • koolgal
    ·2023-03-21

    🌟🌟🌟While there is currently fear and contagion from the fallout of SVB, I have faith that the Australian government and RBA will do everything in their power to protect the integrity of the Australian banking system.  The Big 4 Banks are rock solid with their balance sheet too. 

    So my answer is a definite no that the Australian banks will collapse.  In the short term, the share prices will be volatile but this too will pass.  With a long term horizon I firmly believe that investing in the Australian banks especially the Big 4 is a good call as they have wide moats and pay excellent dividends too. 

    @Tiger_AU  

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    View more 44 comments
  • LMSunshine
    ·2023-03-23
    4 reasons why AU banks will not collapse like SVB in the same way. (1) 🇦🇺 banks do not have significant amounts of their deposits sitting in Treasury securities, mortgage-backed securities & other liquid investments. (2) 🇦🇺 banks have strong incentives to make sure they hedge the interest rate risk in their bank books. (3) 🇦🇺 banks do not have the lumpy, concentrated deposits found at SVB. (4) 🇦🇺 does not allow a bank to choose its regulator. Authorised deposit-taking institutions all have to abide by the same regulatory regime. Am neither 🐂-ish or 🐻-ish about 🇦🇺 banks as mortagage and high rental costs may weigh in causing loan defaults. THX LOADS @Tiger_AU for this Important Post❣️Conment for coins, last day 23/3😉 @CYKuan @HelenJanet @rL @Universe宇宙 @Jadenkho @melson @Mrzorro @GoodLife99 @SPOT_ON @Kaixiang @BenjiFuji @RDPD富爸穷爸 @SirBahamut @b1uesky @MHh @PJoo @Pepermintpat @RiciaYang @jat @Omega88 @爱上投资学 @Zeniv @Elon2 @Yonhuat @Joker_Smile @grizzlylee @FrankieRed @spkek
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    View more 1 comments
  • LMSunshine
    ·2023-03-23
    Comment for coins❣️ Last day 23/3- @GrumpyDino @YTGIRL @VivianChua @MSJYJ @YJ13 @Bons @bernardtayet @Kindryl @angyenyen @KBWSG @JazzyTizzy @icycrystal @KryZ @aiyoh79 @drandy @eeth @Zack44 @Cyberguard @kaite @BlueDragon @Tonyoh @AlfonsoDex @nerdbull1669 @InvisibleTig @AlanTiger @kwk @InvisibleP @miaomiao007 @TigerHulk @MGOH @Alconies @justforcoins @cubinvestor @我i168 @Zacv @ZeroG @JennyChiang @Star0331
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Bons
      thanks bro
      2023-03-23
      Reply
      Report
  • Universe宇宙
    ·2023-03-23
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    View more 3 comments
  • LMSunshine
    ·2023-03-23
    Comment for coins❣️ Last day 23/3-@snoopy123 @psk @pekss @amroui @Ericdao @StickyRice @StarLuck @kungpao @CL Wong @Derrick 1234 @MeowKitty @Thonyaunn @紫南 @Zarkness @Ratt @Tigress02 @Viv22 @aunteenat @airui @0QH @Cris0 @Brocco @AhGong @deal2deal @Ccl2 @Lcc73 @HLPA @WanEH @markele @pipiso @hlw8888 @Huiz84 @Kingcat @Jo_Tan @RedpillBluep @Furore @breAkdaWn @boardy @Cory2 @Soyabean89 @ngph @KYHBKO @Lionel8383 @Downton @SanWangtikup @Setia100 @th0mastan @LesterTan @IAS @HSTew @Kerrisdale @PhilipChow @alylady @moliya @maricel @Sonoma @LuckyPiggie @Doge2theMoon @equitygenius @StayHome @SGboy @Sandyboy @Stayclose @DMTrader @BettyT @Bunta @tigjun21 @JohnL @jace0777 @DoreamonGo @TTrade @VonCat @boonk @Trevelyan @jgaldon @fxaw @Kok @Agxm @Dodonan @BubTigger @Niskil @OddEyeCircle @StarAce @zerolih @WuDi @Asphen @MasterStonker @MoneyCub @MiniAce @StayCalm @ee244c @Huangyulee @tarotsgirl @Lord_Kuberan @ShengSoon @Decromer @jllwang @Shiella @cristine @Gunawanh @WLing @Zash @Snoopymint
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • Shyon
    ·2023-03-21
    Unlikely to have the Australian bank to collapse due to SVB, else it will be a disaster throughout the world by that time. In my opinion, the bank stock continues to be bearish in short term, but long term still a bullish after the remedy actions. Safe and steady, time to collect slowly. @Aqa @rL @LMSunshine @koolgal @Universe宇宙
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • Zarkness
    ·2023-03-23
    Its not going to happen in aussie as they(banks) do not overly loan out to the tech sector like usa did. MUch of this saga is due to leveraging on tech sector and cryptocurrency…
    @HelenJanet @Tigress02 @LMSunshine @airui @Viv22 @Universe宇宙 @SirBahamut @Fenger1188 tag to join in the discussion and win coins
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • Zarkness
      😊👍
      2023-03-24
      Reply
      Report
    • Universe宇宙
      [Like] [ShakeHands]
      2023-03-23
      Reply
      Report
    • HelenJanet
      Thanks for sharing 👍👍
      2023-03-23
      Reply
      Report
  • Bons
    ·2023-03-23
    the cause of the fall of SVB is actually bank run which is done in a massive amount by their customers. sadly, it's something that every bank will fall due to the fact that its business is a high leverage business where it will fall quickly the moment the third party fund is withdrawn. as you can see, the equity of all banks wouldn't be able to cover the third party composition withdrawn from their balance sheet.
    the fact that most of the Australian Banks are composed from loan wouldn't make it any better. loan is a long term contract which gives a long term income. however, the needs of a quick fresh fund from the withdrawal of the third party fund will make it sold in cheaper price owing to the fact that a loan, even a high quality one, may not be able to be sold in a short time in a profitable price wanted.
    thus, the most important thing to do is keeping the public trust in the economy and specially banking system. in addition, they could arrange an emergency backup liquidity loan
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
  • Sandyboy
    ·2023-03-23
    Each if these failuers, SVB, Credit Suisse etc are not connected to each other and are stand alone. Just like singapore banks will not be affected, so too banks in HK, Australia etc will not be affected
    Reply
    Report
  • Ah_Meng
    ·2023-03-21
    Firstly, SVB style of collapse is unusual and unlikely to repeated anywhere else in the world. Whether any Australian bank is likely to face collapse, it depends on what type of 🏦 we talked about. Big 4 is totally different from the regional 🏦 and with the government and regulator being tightly aligned with their interests, they are unlikely to collapse. Recall the banking royal commission, you will notice it is never about the strength of Australian banking system. As mentioned by the article, Australian 🏦 do what they do best, which is the lend! The risk comes in loans defaults in a rapid rate raising environment. We all know very well that RBA will not let the big 4 run into trouble, so rate will stabilise if RBA senses increased sign of default.
    The regional 🏦 may not be as fortunate. The saving grace would then be the fear in contagious effect among the sector. Rescue and bank guarantee with taxpayer's money would follow. I am neutral on Australian 🏦 in this environment.
    Reply
    Report
  • WanEH
    ·2023-03-23
    I don't study much about Australia bank. By theoretically, if the banks bought a lot of bond in year 2020, they they might have the same issue with SVB. But I don't think the bank in Australia will do like that. At least they have risk management control.
    Reply
    Report
  • icycrystal
    ·2023-03-23
    Australia & Singapore bank are much alike. they are well diversified and have contingency plans in place should an emergency arise. so I think it's safe to have [USD] [USD] [USD] with them [Sly] [Sly] [Sly]
    Reply
    Report
  • Ericdao
    ·2023-03-23
    It's unlikely to have further collapse of bank unless it's really badly managed. Bank collapse is serious n will normally involve fast recovery action from government. Small bank still could be sacrificed but controlled. What would collapse next is those funds or companies that invested in those insolvent banks, but as of now, happy investing until the next episode starts. [Miser] [Cool]
    Reply
    Report
  • GoodLife99
    ·2023-03-23
    $COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRAL(CBA.AU)$ $WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION(WBC.AU)$ $NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED(NAB.AU)$ are in my watchlist! I'm bullish for long for these 3 pioneers banks which are at great opportunity buy at the moment!
    Reply
    Report
  • Joker_Smile
    ·2023-03-23
    no one want a bank to collapse. normal working citizens would feel the most pain. I wouldn't hope for any bank to be like SVB. Not bullish due to the surrounding bad news about banks, slightly bearish
    Reply
    Report