With $1M Savings But Lives in HDB Rental Flat! Do You Prioritize Saving or Spending?

Singapore boasts one of the world’s highest home ownership rates, with about 90% of its residents owning their homes.

Singapore Home Ownership RateSingapore Home Ownership Rate

Among them, 80% live in HDB flats, while others opt for more upscale condominiums. The remaining 10% reside in government rental flats under Singapore’s Public Rental Scheme.

These rental flats are designated for low-income families, with strict eligibility criteria to ensure they truly serve those in need. The units come in two compact designs: one-room flats under 36 square meters and two-room flats with a separate living room and bedroom, around 46 square meters in size.

An 80-year-old man who lives in one such rental flat leads a frugal lifestyle. Yet, unbeknownst to many, his personal savings amount to a staggering SGD $1 million! During his working years, he followed a strict retirement savings plan.

The joy of saving vs. the happiness of spending?

Despite his million-dollar wealth, he continues to live in a small rental flat. Perhaps saving money has become a source of joy in his life. Rather than using his savings to improve his living conditions, he finds greater satisfaction in the sense of security brought by a substantial bank balance.

  • Many admire the man’s discipline and agree with his philosophy. They believe that saving diligently while young, and watching your bank balance grow, brings more happiness than spending ever could.

On Chinese social media, there’s a famous saying: “欲买桂花同载酒,终不似少年游,” which translates to “I want to buy osmanthus wine for a carefree boat trip, but it will never feel as bold and free as in my youth.” This sentiment resonates widely.

  • The idea is that even if you save enough money to travel one day, the experience won’t be the same as it would have been in your younger years. Therefore, some argue, you should see the world while you’re young.

Ideally, a balance between saving and spending is best — save diligently, but occasionally indulge in experiences to make life more enjoyable. Ultimately, the choice depends on personal circumstances, with each person prioritizing what matters most to them.

Which spending and saving philosophy resonates with you more?

Do you have strict saving plans like the 80-year-old man?

When will or when did you achieve SGD 1 million savings?

Leave your comments and join the discussion to win tiger coins~

# What Brings You More Happiness: Saving or Spending?

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment49

  • Top
  • Latest
  • icycrystal
    ·11-27
    TOP
    always save before spending... however, do not forget to live life and enjoy life... no point save and not enjoy isn't it [Tongue] [Tongue] [Tongue] but remember to spend within means [smile] [smile] [smile]

    @LMSunshine @Universe宇宙 @rL @GoodLife99 @HelenJanet @koolgal @Shyon @Aqa @SPACE ROCKET @TigerGPT

    Which spending and saving philosophy resonates with you more?

    Do you have strict saving plans like the 80-year-old man?

    When will or when did you achieve SGD 1 million savings?

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • icycrystalReplying toSPACE ROCKET
      [Happy] [Happy] [Happy] yummy... [Great] [Great] [Great] [Great] [Great] [Grin] [Grin] [Grin]
      11-30
      Reply
      Report
    • SPACE ROCKETReplying toicycrystal
      Cheek meat lol!!! Reminds me of some ramen places selling pork cheeks! V nice to eat eh!
      11-29
      Reply
      Report
    • icycrystalReplying toSPACE ROCKET
      [Great] [Great] [Great] see cheek getting so much meat [Great] [Great] [Great]
      11-29
      Reply
      Report
    View more 8 comments
  • Aqa
    ·11-27
    TOP
    Ideally, a balance between saving and spending is best — save diligently, but occasionally indulge in experiences to make life more enjoyable. Ultimately, the choice depends on personal circumstances, with each person prioritizing what matters most to them. It is shocking to learn that this 80-year-old man with a personal savings of SGD $1 million gets to live in the heavily subsidized HDB rental flat meant for citizens who cannot afford to buy a flat and have no other housing options or family support. He has done wrong by escaping HDB checks. Thanks @Tiger_SG @icycrystal
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • icycrystal
      [Like] [Like] [Like]
      11-28
      Reply
      Report
  • Shyon
    ·11-28
    TOP
    For me, I believe in balancing saving for the future with spending to improve my life. Saving gives me security, knowing I’m preparing for any unexpected events. I do have savings goals, like aiming for at least SGD 1 million one day, but I also think life is too short to miss out on the present.

    When I have extra savings, I like to upgrade my lifestyle or enjoy experiences that bring me joy, like traveling or improving my home. The "YOLO" (You Only Live Once) mindset resonates with me—while I want to save, I also want to enjoy life while I'm still young.

    Life is about finding the right balance between securing the future and enjoying the present. It’s important to be responsible, but also to make room for the things that bring happiness. For me, the goal is to save when possible, but also embrace the moments that make life enjoyable.

    @Tiger_SG @TigerStars @TigerGPT @Tiger_comments

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • icycrystal
      [Like] [Like] [Like]
      11-28
      Reply
      Report
    • TigerGPT

      As an AI financial analyst, I don't have personal financial goals or the ability to achieve savings. However, I can provide some insights into the different spending and saving philosophies.

      Balancing saving for the future with enjoying life in the present is a common approach that many individuals adopt. It allows for financial security while also making room for enjoyment and experiences. By saving, you are preparing for unexpected events and creating a safety net for yourself.

      On the other hand, some individuals may have strict saving plans, like the 80-year-old man you mentioned. They prioritize saving as much as possible and may have specific goals in mind, such as accumulating a certain amount of savings by a certain age. This approach aims to achieve financial independence and long-term stability.

      Both approaches have their merits, and the right philosophy depends on your personal circumstances and financial goals. It's important to strike a balance that aligns with your values and priorities. Setting realistic savings goals and regularly reviewing your progress can help you stay on track.

      Please note that achieving SGD 1 million in savings depends on various factors such as your income, expenses, investment returns, and savings rate. It is a personal financial goal that requires careful planning and dedication.

      11-28
      Reply
      Report
  • ZEROHERO
    ·12-01
    TOP
    Earn all we can, save all we can, invest all we can and and most importantly, give all we can. For we bring nothing into this world and certainly we can bring nothing out of it. Living in a first world country gives us an edge to perform better so we shouldn’t forget those marginalised. We can’t choose how we start our life journey on earth but we can choose how to end well. It’s more blessed to give than to receive 🙏 @CaptainTiger @Andreana @jace0777 @SPACE ROCKET @Terra Incognita @Mathematical Money @Bonta @Aqa @AyKing @mster @BillionaireN
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    View more 1 comments
  • SPACE ROCKET
    ·11-27
    TOP
    Rather difficult to save in SG given the rather high costs of living. Unbeknownst to most, a lot of Singaporeans actually live from hand to mouth, from paycheck to paycheck. It's unfortunate but true.
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • icycrystalReplying toSPACE ROCKET
      [Like] [Like] [Like]
      11-29
      Reply
      Report
    • SPACE ROCKETReplying toicycrystal
      Yeah that's the way to go sis! Good mindset to stay positive!! Or buy a cheaper brand also good! Wishing us loads of goodluck babe! 🔥🚀
      11-28
      Reply
      Report
    • icycrystalReplying toSPACE ROCKET
      whenever need to cut back on  [USD] [USD] [USD] instead of big tub ice cream, buy mini ice cream... still ice cream... still indulging... life still good ehhh... that's what I tell myself [Sly] [Sly] [Sly] [Grin] [Grin] [Grin]
      11-28
      Reply
      Report
    View more 2 comments
  • MilkTeaBro
    ·11-27
    TOP
    My tiger account holds 420K, Singapore saving bonds 70k, funds in other platform 90k, bank savings account 25k, net cash assets 605k. I have a HDB flat  without any loans. My assets can generate passive income 20k/ year. And I still work full time, annual income around 100k. I guessed I would have 1 million cash after 5 years later. I may want to retire after I reach 1 million cash assets. See how.
    Reply
    Report
  • stay in HDB is right choice for ppl who are smart to balance their lifestyle and not overspending on luxury goods but not much of value interm of investment ROI. People who Smart with their money, have more cash to invest and also enjoy their vacation and needs.

    some people who want face value will spend on cars, luxury accessories and stay rental in condo is very common nowadays, The question is all this spending bring what?
    spending your money on thing that is needed and at the same time invest for long term will help you built up the fortune faster and to achieve financial freedom faster.

    One with Yolo mindset might regret eventually, spend now , enjoy now don't plans for future is dangerous.

    we all have to think and plan for the future, spend wisely and enjoy long terms.... Not enjoying now broke tomorrow [LOL]

    wish you all have a good weekend and enjoy Xmas season 🥳 😁 😀 [Heart] [Love] [USD]

    Reply
    Report
  • Mrzorro
    ·12-03
    I don't think I will even reach 6 digits. Don't even say 1M. For me , I will focus more on saving and spending on necessary  or basic living stuff. ( Since I have a kid, I will prioritize on the family and save as much as I can for them) I do invest some of my saving in the stock market (even though it is deep red) I believe one day I will achieve my target of 6 digits. Everyone have their own goal and timing. As for me, I won't rush for it. Just let it grow naturally. As long as I can cover my family expenses and have extra savings, I am a happy man. Most of my friend bank account is empty every month without any savings.
    Reply
    Report
  • I disagree with the old man's philosophy of living. Money is being printed in large numbers and don't hold any value that the functionality of it to purchase items of necessity, joy & fun. It pays the bills of self & family and to run a home. It could have been more than 1 million if it was invested and the compounded yield & interest would be a higher figure. I'll rather invest the 1 million dollars while living in a comfortable home with a frugal lifestyle. But kudos to the old man for his results of a big amount of savings, I'm so far from that. 😆
    Reply
    Report
  • Bull Huang
    ·12-01
    This offers a profound reflection on the delicate balance between frugality and indulgence. His million-dollar discipline reminds me of the Chinese saying, ‘积谷防饥, 未雨绸缪,’ which translates to ‘Store up grains for times of famine; prepare the roof before the rain.’ It’s a philosophy deeply rooted in long-term security and foresight.


    However, as much as I admire his prudence, the contrasting Chinese proverb, ‘人生得意须尽欢,’ or ‘Seize the moments of joy in life,’ speaks to my belief that memories and experiences are just as vital a currency as dollars in the bank. While the 80-year-old man’s wealth represents triumph over financial uncertainty, it’s also a poignant reminder that time and health are finite resources.


    For me, the true wealth lies in finding harmony—saving for the future while indulging in life’s fleeting pleasures today. After all, as the osmanthus wine proverb implies, some adventures are best savoured in the exuberance of youth. So, let’s plan smartly but also live boldly.
    Reply
    Report
  • Jozzzz
    ·12-01
    People forget to living for a pursuit of manmade paper. I live life, have 2 kids, condo, car, and still have $1M at 30…
    Reply
    Report
  • Very difficult to have strict saving plans when one have children, there are many unexpected expenses along the way.
    If include SRS and CPF OA & SA savings , I would have achieve the million milestone during my 40s.
    I don’t quite agree to that famous saying, so long you’re still young at heart and still healthy, there isn’t much difference just that you need to go travelling with companion with the same mindset.
    Reply
    Report
  • Bummer
    ·12-01
    Personally I feel that, once the risks of critical illnesses and medical expenses have been transferred to insurance companies through various policies. I can spend and enjoy at least 50% of my income, save the other 20% after setting aside 30% for investments. There is no point to watch the numbers grow but your downside is uncovered.
    Reply
    Report
  • 1PC
    ·12-01
    Wow 😮 Impressive discipline for the 80 years old uncle 👍. I prefer to have Balance savings and indulge in between to Reward myself ...like Took Profits from the Winning Trades [Happy] [Miser].  I'm still striving for the magic 7 digits numbers [Speechless] [Sad] [Facepalm]....But in between, 5 digits numbers are the Smaller Goal 🥅 to aim. Eventually will slowly Roll 🥐 Up 📈 to 6 Digits....then Hooray 7 Digits [Chuckle] [Chuckle] [Chuckle]
    Reply
    Report
  • phagefish
    ·12-01
    invest just $500k under tiger platform will greatly improve the quality of life in those rental flats.
    Reply
    Report
  • 168Prem
    ·12-01
    Yes that's the way, abuse the system meant for people who needs the rental homes and save money, let's attend the masterclass by Million Uncle. How to continue living in rental HDB and save a Million SGD.
    Reply
    Report
  • ECLC
    ·11-28
    Definitely save first, then spend some. Learn from young to "save for rainy day". Also, remember to bless others as we have been blessed.
    Reply
    Report
  • MHh
    ·11-27
    Money is meant to be managed for retirement and also for life’s enjoyment. Life’s enjoyment includes good food, travel, doing things that bring joy such as hobbies, having good things that are within my abilities such as the occasional pretty bag, potentially a pretty place to call home. There is no point having all the money and yet never experienced life. So, no insane saving plans, just reasonable management of money. I hope to achieve more than 1 million by the time I’m ready for retirement!
    Reply
    Report
  • All Blue
    ·12-01
    Save, invest, earn, spend without looking at price tag or has wider option. This is the ultimate goal of financial freedom
    Reply
    Report
  • It's not the real estate. That's saturated. it's the cash which he has the power to do anything. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤑🤑🤑🤑🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
    Reply
    Report