Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up Investing: Which One Suits You?
This week the market delivered a full-blown roller coaster: consecutive selloffs, extreme fear, a sharp rally followed by a crash on Thursday, and a weak open with a shaky rebound on Friday that barely closed in the green.
$NVIDIA(NVDA)$ earnings “failed to save the market,” U.S. equities were dumped across the board, and even Fed officials had to come out repeatedly to calm investors.
Amid the waves of panic, tech stocks finally showed a bit of stabilization. But the reality is simple: most investors ended this week in the red.
Whenever the market enters a violent correction, an old question always comes back:
Are you better suited for top-down investing or bottom-up investing?
🔍 What Is Top-Down Investing?
Top-down logic is straightforward:
Start with the macro → interest rates, inflation, GDP, policy shifts
Then look at sectors → which sectors benefit in the current cycle?
Finally choose your stocks or ETFs.
In an extreme week like this, a top-down approach often suggests adjusting exposure: reducing positions, hedging, or shifting to defense — all based on macro signals.
🔍 What Is Bottom-Up Investing?
Bottom-up thinking flips the order:
Start with the company → earnings, valuation, moat, growth drivers
Macro is just “background noise.”
These investors believe: “If the company is truly great, short-term volatility doesn’t matter.” They’re often long-term buy-and-hold types who love deep company research.
In a week of steep declines, bottom-up investors might actually see opportunity: high-quality companies dumped in panic, and “bargains” starting to emerge.
If you have cash and the ability to do deep research, this type of environment can feel like hunting season.
So Which Strategy Fits You?
The truth is, it’s not a binary choice. In practice, both approaches can and should coexist. Just like Merrill Lynch’s Investment Clock suggests, the economy moves through cycles, and your strategy needs to move with it.
In a market like this, what matters more — the “big picture” or “stock picking”?
Are you better suited for top-down investing or bottom-up investing?
Leave your comments to win tiger coins & vouchers!
Click here to view the event detail: Weekly Top Contributor (10 - 16 Nov): New Week, New Winners🐯 Check Our New Scheme!
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
我使用自上而下的观点来确定当前的宏观经济因素&确定投资哪些行业。如果经济衰退迫在眉睫，我会倾向于防御性行业，例如消费品。
一旦我选择了行业，我就会转向自下而上的方法，选择最有可能超越同行的公司。例如：在消费必需品下，我会选择 $可口可乐(KO)$ 拥有宽阔的品牌护城河。
通过使用自上而下和自下而上的方法，我两全其美。这不是关于完美的预测，而是关于稳健的风险管理和平衡的信念。
最好的方法最终是让我在波动性最高时保持自律和理性的方法。
在采用混合方法时，我会抓住机会，成为一名更好的投资者。
@Tiger_comments @TigerStars @Tiger_SG @TigerClub @CaptainTiger
Are you better suited for top-down investing or bottom-up investing?
Leave your comments to win tiger coins & vouchers!
@koolgal @SPACE ROCKET @nomadic_m @GoodLife99 @Shyon @Aqa @HelenJanet @rL @Universe宇宙 @Barcode @Zarkness @LMSunshine
But at the same time, I can’t ignore bottom-up fundamentals. When panic hits and everything gets sold indiscriminately, that’s when I start paying attention to high-quality names that are getting dragged down for no fundamental reason. If the company’s long-term story is solid, short-term volatility becomes less scary and more like an opportunity.
So for me, the best approach is a mix of both. I use top-down signals to adjust exposure and protect myself during macro turbulence, and bottom-up research to take advantage of mispriced opportunities.
@Tiger_comments @TigerStars
Hence, it would involved both ultimately.
Bottom-Up Investing during boom time!
During geopolitical crisis one can use the top-down approach to identify the promising sectors and selects specific stocks. Whereas in prosperity time when economy is generally stable, bottom-up approach focuses on company fundamentals which enable one to acquire undervalued stocks with great fundamentals. Thanks @Tiger_comments @icycrystal @TigerStars @Tiger_SG Thanks for tag!
依我看，大局不是那麼可控的。尤其是最近的地緣政治環境變化很快。
但最好是我們有分散風險的紀律&要有耐心。
Check them in the history - “community distribution“
For me, still the same saying: accumulate the cash, waiting for the the markets earthquakes before opening up the bank account and stay buying...
Current trading strategy: Swing trade